9 ms·
Deductions on personal taxes are intentional provisions to encourage certain types of saving/investment/giving. Weaknesses in tax treaties are not designed to e
by notahacker 11y ago
Deductions on personal taxes are intentional provisions to encourage certain types of saving/investment/giving. Weaknesses in tax treaties are not designed to encourage people to repatriate their profits to artificial entities in tax shelters.
Google pretending that sales are made in Ireland (and not by the revenue-targeted local salesperson selling local ads to local eyeballs) in order to enable them to deduct fictitious license fees owed to a subsidiary in Bermuda is not even in the same ballpark.
It's the equivalent of me donating most of my salary to a "charity" created for the purpose of paying my mortgage. I don't think many people here do that, or would consider it if their accountant suggested it.
- nunyabuizness 11y ago>It's the equivalent of me donating most of my salary to a "charity" created for the purpose of paying my mortgage. I don't think many people here do that, or would consider it if their accountant suggested it. Why not? If it was legal, why wouldn't you do it?
- DanBC 11y agoSome tax planning is clearly legal, and is an expected use of the tax laws. Some tax planning is clearly illegal. People are hiding money and evading tax. There is a grey area in between. People use tax laws in unexpected ways. Their accountants and lawyers claim this new planning is legal. The tax authorities claim it isn't. To find out if it's actually illegal it gets tested in court, except no-one wants that. Companies don't want it because lawyers are expensive. Tax authorities don't want it because lawyers are even more expensive for them and it looks terrible if they fail in court. So some weird deal is made. The company repays a trivial amount of tax, some rule gets added or taken away to make it clearer that the tax plan is unlawful. So, here, a big company can do it because spending many thousands on lawyers and tax accountants means they save hundreds of thousands, millions, billions, on the tax bill. I can't afford the tax accountant, so those schemes usually are not available to me. And as soon as enough people start using them the laws change, sometimes leaving me in a tricky situation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- baddox 11y agoHow could the double Irish arrangement possibly be considered a grey area? It's incredibly well know, and many of the richest companies use it. I'm pretty sure that if it were truly a legal grey area, there would be court cases testing it, which there aren't to my knowledge.
- justincormack 11y agoThe double Irish was created by Apple's tax lawyers. It is well known because of that. It has been ruled illegal I think now and Apple is no longer using it. Apple are lobbying hard not to pay billions of back taxes in Ireland as their deals with the government to not pay tax are likely to be ruled illegal by the EU.
- joelrunyon 11y agoThe problem is with the laws. Poorly written, lazy or "bought-for" laws are being used exactly as they are worded. If you want better laws, you need to write better laws - not just hope that people will follow what each law intended. For the people that claim that the tax loopholes are something that the companies lobby for - again - it's interesting that people are upset with the companies who lobby for this, rather than the fact that politicians are receiving the actual money. The problem is not with the companies - it's with the politicians that allow money to influence themselves. It's laughable to me that politicians denounce "money in politics" with one hand and are busy recruiting, fundraising and accepting it on the other.
- mattmanser 11y agoThe problem is definitely the companies. They're the ones exploiting the system. I'm not sure what your agenda is, but the problem is definitely the companies. If they just paid their fair share with a little bit of mild tax dodging no-one would give a fuck. But they're taking the fucking piss at the moment, generating billions in revenue and then not paying for any of the infrastructure which is supporting their business.
- nezumi 11y agoYou have to account for competition. Suppose there are two companies with the same business model, operating in the same countries etc. One files taxes "fairly" and one minimizes its tax burden as far as the law will allow. Which one do you think is going to be in business for longer? Which one would you buy shares in? You can get as angry as you like at the companies, or the legislators, but in the end it's the system you need to be scrutinizing.
- mattmanser 11y agoThis is clearly nonsense, what serious competition does Google have in Europe? Or Apple? Apple are making billions in profits, they have no competitive need for lower prices! Also this is an advantage only massive multinationals have, so again, complete nonsense as they're already past that stage.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Google pretending that sales are made in Ireland (and not by the revenue-targeted local salesperson selling local ads to local eyeballs) in order to enable them to deduct fictitious license fees owed to a subsidiary in Bermuda is not even in the same ballpark. The whole problem is that it isn't a tax on local sales. It isn't a tax on property or labor or consumption. It's a tax on income. But income is revenue minus expenses. So the company in the US pays developers to make software which costs $99 and the company in Ireland pays $100 for the software. Then the company in Germany sells $1100 worth of advertising and pays $1099 to license the software from the company in Ireland. Which means the company in the US made $1, the company in Germany made $1 and the company in Ireland made $999. The allocation of the income between the different subsidiaries is almost completely arbitrary so companies arrange to do it in the way that minimizes their taxes. If you don't want them to do this, tax something other than income.
- joering2 11y ago> Which means the company in the US made $1, the company in Germany made $1 and the company in Ireland made $999. Any reasonable judge in their sound mind would find it to be a tax avoidance, because it is! I'm very certain and can put my $100 on it, that US courts know thousands of cases where same scheme has been put in works and people in charge put behind bars. But not Google...
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoTax evasion is the thing where Al Capone makes a lot of money without reporting it to the IRS and goes to jail. Tax avoidance is the thing where Ford builds a plant in Chihuahua instead of Detroit in part because Mexico has lower taxes. There is an obvious PR nightmare when the entity that makes all the profit is in a jurisdiction where they have hardly any operations, but seizing that as an opportunity to lambaste them in public does nothing to solve the actual problem. The underlying problem is this: When Google buys something from Google, how do you determine when the seller should act like a monopoly or the buyer should act like a monopsony? If you can't answer that question in a way that can't be gamed then you can't in practice tax international corporate profit.
- IncRnd 11y ago>> It's the equivalent of me donating most of my salary to a >> "charity" created for the purpose of paying my mortgage. I >> don't think many people here do that, or would consider it >> if their accountant suggested it. Not even close. But, actually people do that. Your example is off-base, because they pay tax on the fair market value of the rent they don't pay as if that missing rent were income. What do you think the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is? The Clinton Foundation? Donations to purchase buildings at Universities? Donations to your favorite charity? Donations to get annuities? This is something that many people and corporations do. It sounds like you enjoy it personally, but not when other people do it with greater amounts of money.
- icebraining 11y agoI don't think Bill Gates pays his mortgage with money from the foundation.
- IncRnd 11y agoAh, I see that my comment could be read that way. What I meant was the construct of donations for deductions and later benefit is what those foundations do.
- ghaff 11y agoFurthermore, given enough money involved, there are a variety of advantages to creating an entity like a foundation. No, it won't cover clearly personal expenses like a mortgage; that would be clearly illegal. But it can write off salaries, travel, entertainment, etc. related to the operation of the foundation in a way that would be difficult for an individual.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ptaipale 11y ago> Deductions on personal taxes are intentional provisions to encourage certain types of saving/investment/giving. Weaknesses in tax treaties are not designed to encourage people to repatriate their profits to artificial entities in tax shelters. What you call "weaknesses in tax treaties" are very often exactly though up as intentional provisions to encourage certain types of saving/investment/giving
- e98cuenc 11y agoAll Google sales rep managing spanish accounts that I know of are spaniards living and working in Ireland.
- e98cuenc 11y agoAll Google sales rep managing spanish accounts that I know of are spaniards living and working in Ireland.