6 ms·
I've worked with the FBI and the Secret Service investigating computer crime. The Secret Service is extremely competent when it comes to computer forensics, an
by jedberg 11y ago
I've worked with the FBI and the Secret Service investigating computer crime.
The Secret Service is extremely competent when it comes to computer forensics, and when they don't know what to do, they don't guess, the consult with experts.
The FBI is the opposite in every way, mostly because of budget constraints and the subsequent lack of training. I hope that this is a good learning opportunity for them and a chance for them to increase their training budget in this area.
- m3rc 11y agoAlso hearsay personal experience but a friend of a friend had his house raided by the FBI and all his computer equipment impounded. When he got it all back they told him his hard drives were empty or unformatted. He had them all formatted as ZFS...
- rpgmaker 11y ago> When he got it all back they told him his hard drives were empty or unformatted. Maybe that's what they wanted him to think. I refuse to believe the alternative...
- pjc50 11y agoWhy? It's people following a forensics script/program which looks for Windows partitions. There aren't a huge number of people who understand this kind of thing and most of them are able to work at places where they're paid much better than the FBI.
- leeoniya 11y agoYou're going to go through the trouble to get a warrant for a raid and then apply such gross incompetence to the seized evidence? When was the last time you pulled a hard drive out of a functioning machine, found it to be empty and didn't immediately think, "huh, that's odd" before throwing it in the trash. I guess it depends on whether the hard drives were the target of the raid or just a collateral of "grab anything that may be useful" mindset. They could already have gathered enough evidence without needing to waste time/money on digital forensics. Hard to say without specifics. The fact that they went out of their way to assure him that his own hard drives were empty reeks of manipulation. Color me highly skeptical.
- angrow 11y agoI'll color you trusting: you are choosing to be fixedly _un_-skeptical of the FBI's competence.
- asgfoi 11y agoSlightly off topic, but it really isn't hard to find partitions. Just run the various software to scan and that's it. I've done it at least twice when accidentally erasing a windows partition (once with fdisk when I misread the output, and at that time I didn't even know what a partition is).
- munin 11y agothe forensics programs (EnCase, FTK) have a lot of problems but they don't assume that the drive is "windows partitions" though it's possible that they don't deal with ZFS. you would think that national level stuff would have people take more care, but if you're dealing with state or local police, they will have someone who has taken an 8 hours Encase or FTK class driving a GUI to gather evidence and if the tool doesn't support it, there's effectively no evidence to gather.
- ryanlol 11y agoYeah, I once had to explain to an officer what a known_hosts file is so they could send MLAT requests and release me from jail without risking that I would wipe (the already automatically wiped) servers myself when I got out.
- michaelcampbell 11y agoI'm unsure as to how to read this; are you saying because they were ZFS, the FBI couldn't read them and because of their lack of expertise, assumed they were empty? Or that they formatted them before returning them?
- ptaipale 11y agoFBI assumed them to be empty, or wanted the owner to believe that they had assumed them empty...
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIf you plug in a non-FAT/exFat/NTFS drive to a Windows machine, Windows will act almost as if the drive is empty and needs formatting in My Computer.
- jrs235 11y agoI read it as his drives were formatted as ZFS and the FBI couldn't read them because of their incompetence (probably only thinking to try and read them with Windows as FAT32 or NTFS.
- xg15 11y agoJudging by how Windows, when presented with an unknown FS, acts as if the disk were unformatted and immediately offers to format it, my guess would be both... (And by "unknown" I mean of course "anything that is not FAT* or NTFS"...)
- wantreprenr007 11y agoJohnny clubfingers 5-0 clicks Ok, and destroys "evidence" for being a total idiot... I take it he/she was hungover during that 2 hours of computer forensics in the academy. For crooks, this is good news; for stopping potential future victims, this isn't good, and misapplied to innocent/MPAA/RIAA enforcement, it's destructive and lowers LE credibility. The moral of the story is for individuals, whom should implictly fear government overreach no matter whom is in office, one has to back their shit up and make it SWAT-proof, even if that means running several TahoeLAFS boxes in countries like Switzerland, because running a server (physical or Linode) or just replicating data to a friend's server just doesn't cut it and never did.
- qb45 11y agoThat's weird, it looks like they didn't even try something like photorec. I wonder how would they handle full disk encryption.
- vonklaus 11y agoSounds like they call customer support and order a software modification for the entire system...
- autoreleasepool 11y ago> his house raided by the FBI and all his computer equipment impounded. Thanks for reminding me to set up Amazon glacier for my FreeNas today. Jesus Christ, the world is a messed up place.
- raverbashing 11y agoJust a note, read up on glacier pricing and issues. Standard S3 might be better
- milesward 11y agoOr go GCS Nearline, same great price, no terrible gotchas. https://cloud.google.com/storage/docs/nearline https://cloud.google.com/storage/docs/nearline Disclaimer: I work on GCP
- sandworm101 11y agoI wouldn't read too much into this. SOP for most police forces is a tiered approach to seized drives. They plug it into a windows machine and see what's what. If that doesn't get the immediate results they have to hand it to the professional data recovery people. Even a cursory forensic examination of a drive starts at 1,000$ and may yield nothing if encrypted. With a small pile of drives to look at, they probably didn't bother trying after spotting it wasn't going to be plug-and-play.
- ryao 11y ago> Also hearsay personal experience but a friend of a friend had his house raided by the FBI and all his computer equipment impounded. When he got it all back they told him his hard drives were empty or unformatted. He had them all formatted as ZFS... I had imagined that computer forensics "experts" would make this mistake somewhere at some point, but I did not think I would actually hear that it had happened. Thanks for the affirmation, even if it is just hearsay. It makes me curious about what goofs were made with the IRS hard drives that had "crashed" according to forensics "experts".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chatmasta 11y agoJust curious, and sorry if this is intrusive, but your blog is very up front about your employment history... reddit, netflix, paypal/ebay, sendmail... At which job were you working so closely with the FBI and SS that you were able to ascertain their technical abilities?
- kordless 11y agoIn the mid-90s I had several encounters with the FBI while running an ISP in Oklahoma City. They asked me to write code to pull out specific entries in our massive amount of dialup logs and when I told them they had to pay me, they refused based on budget constraints. I can well imagine jedberg has had to deal with them just being a systems admin for such large deployments as reddit and paypal.
- mrbill 11y agoJust curious - which one? I started out teaching "Welcome to the Internet" classes once a week, and then was the first tech support guy at ioNet / Internet Oklahoma. Worked my way up to assistant sysadmin before I moved to Austin to be a sysadmin for Texas.net. April 95 to September 96.
- mrbill 11y agoAnd my first day on the job was April 19, 1995. Talk about a hell of a first day... We pretty much switched into full "get news about the bombing online in some form or fashion, however possible" mode for about 48 hours. This was before CNN had a huge online presence, so we had stuff going like a RealVideo stream of a webcam pointed at local TV news, a couple of people went down to take pictures, etc, etc...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kordless 11y agoThe Internet Shop: https://web.archive.org/web/19990423075248/http://www.theshop.net/ https://web.archive.org/web/19990423075248/http://www.thesho... Started it in mid to late '96.
- mtgx 11y agoThen they should apologize to Apple for tarnishing their name all over the media for "helping terrorists" to the point where the front-runner of a party, who has a chance of becoming the next president, called for their boycott because of it - when all along it was FBI's dumb mistake for not getting that data and Apple has no responsibility to fix FBI's stupidity. I think it's only fair. That's assuming it wasn't all staged to take advantage of this situation to pass some backdoor law or set a precedent here, in which case, I don't expect the FBI to retract anything, because then their goal isn't to unlock this phone, but to set that precedent.
- exw 11y ago<<The FBI is the opposite in every way, mostly because of budget constraints and the subsequent lack of training. I hope that this is a good learning opportunity for them and a chance for them to increase their training budget in this area.>> Besides the legal precedents and other associated drama, I think is one of Apple's major concerns, and one of the reasons they implemented the "we don't have the keys" approach to their encryption. If the FBI can always just call on Apple (or Google) to fix whatever mistakes they made, there is little motivation for training / getting better on this front, effectively making Apple the computer forensics arm of the government.
- marcoperaza 11y ago>I think is one of Apple's major concerns, and one of the reasons they implemented the "we don't have the keys" approach to their encryption. They do have the keys. A 4-digit pin is useless if you have Apple's private key.
- djrogers 11y agoCompletely false, as has been endlessly detailed by nearly everyone at this point.
- marcoperaza 11y agoPlease enlighten me. Is this not exactly what the FBI is asking for? For Apple to flash a custom version of iOS that doesn't have the software rate-limiting and auto-wipe, which only someone with Apple's private key can do. A four-digit PIN is only secure in combination with those features. Having Apple's code-signing key is in fact "having the keys", except in the most pedantic literal sense.
- cyphar 11y agoSoftware update signing keys, which can't be disabled by the end user. This is what most people would consider "a flawed security model". Even UEFI lets you change the trusted booting keys.
- 11y ago
- jack9 11y agoI worked with multiple agents (FBI and Secret Service) in 1999 - they were not competent back then. I'm glad they have improved.
- spydum 11y agoi suspect just like every other large organisation, you have small islands of excellence, spread across oceans of mediocrity.
- void-star 11y agoThis is so true. It has been a number of years since I worked with either agency doing computer forensic work, but my experience was pretty much the exact same. While SS consistently made a concerted effort to investigate crimes and build a solid case, FBI seemed often to be interested primarily in raising the public profile of the cases they worked on to get more visibility in the press, often at the expense of (what appeared to me at least) due process. Whereas SS had a number of excellent specialists who understood acquisition, the FBI seemed to be wearing clown-shoes most of the time. I'm not surprised at all that they botched this case so badly. It's clear as day that Apple is on the right side of this argument. It's not their job to bail out the FBI for yet another colossal screwup. Especially not when it damages their product so severely.
- sandworm101 11y agoI've worked with vice-principals at elementary schools investigating porn on library machines who had a better grasp of forensics. Really, I teach a course in a local forensics program and have helped a couple local schools over the years. Any teenager with an iPhone could have explained that resetting the AppleID was a bad idea. There are plenty of very intelligent kids out there who need jobs. For the FBI to act in such a manner is inexcusable. Ditch some of these hack cops and hire some proper technology experts.