3 ms·
I'm convinced they have a wish list in wait for every tragedy That's not even remotely debatable, unless you believe the 350+-page Patriot Act was written with
by CamperBob2 11y ago
I'm convinced they have a wish list in wait for every tragedy
That's not even remotely debatable, unless you believe the 350+-page Patriot Act was written within a month after 9/11.
- paulddraper 11y agoThat's not unbelievable.
- nullc 11y ago> The Patriot Act is huge and I remember someone asking a Justice Department official how did they write such a large statute so quickly, and of course the answer was that it has been sitting in the drawers of the Justice Department for the last 20 years waiting for the event where they would pull it out. -- Richard Clarke (former National Coordinator for Security, Infrastructure Protection and Counter-terrorism) Often political changes are artifacts of opportunity. I don't personally think that its evil that the justice department had a laundry list of civil rights violations waiting for an opportunity to propose them. It's the responsibility of the public and earnest lawmakers to be aware of efforts to exploit sentiment and resist bad law regardless of when it's proposed.
- tunap 11y agoBiden submitted the virtually identical bill shortly after the OK City bombing 6 years prior... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Counterterrorism_Act_of_1995 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Counterterrorism_Act_o...
- CamperBob2 11y agoYes, it is. Can you imagine how different life would be if the rest of government worked at that pace?
- marcoperaza 11y agoAnd there'd be nothing wrong with that. From their perspective, these are powers that will help them do their job of keeping us safe. I often disagree with their proposals, but I don't question their motives. You see it as them taking advantage of fearful people. They see it as people getting a dose of realism when disaster strikes. It's no different with any perennial political issue. People forget about problems until some event reminds them. Activists use this opening of awareness to push for change.
- jMyles 11y ago> but I don't question their motives ...really? Isn't this among our foremost duties as effective, responsible, mature citizens?
- marcoperaza 11y agoBetter phrasing of what I meant: I think the authors of the Patriot Act had pure motives.
- ptaipale 11y agoIndeed. Much of the time, what we perceive as "that person proposes a bad thing because he has bad intentions and bad motives" is wrong: people have good motives and they mean well, but they should see that what they propose with good intentions will eventually have bad outcomes. See "unintended consequences".
- ptaipale 11y agoOf course different people have compiled different "wish lists" and other proposals which will then pop up when some news event (etc) gives the opportunity. It's not really any evidence of conspiracy, or such. Simply that different organisations and people have ideas that they prepare, and put forward when there is an opportunity. Similarly, the fact that e.g. Russian or American army has written a plan for how to go through Fulda Gap or capture Kiev or close the Bosphorus is not really evidence that the said army is actually about to do such thing. They are simply doing their job by preparing for scenarios.
- ionised 11y agoNo, the Patriot Act was ready to go long before 9/11.