3 ms·
That key is a key which unlocks every single iPhone. There would be an extremely strong case that revealing that key would be a threat to national security. I t
by zepto 11y ago
That key is a key which unlocks every single iPhone. There would be an extremely strong case that revealing that key would be a threat to national security. I think you'd find the case would be harder than you think.
That's precisely why all writs is not a red herring. If all writs is not limited at this stage, it will be used for exactly what you are most afraid of.
- mindslight 11y agoWhat I'm most worried about is a prohibition on software which implements government-unbreakable encryption, and after that, a prohibition on selling consumer devices with government-unbreakable encryption. This has nothing to do with All Writs, since 1. it wouldn't be forcing anyone to write backdoored software and 2. wouldn't involve a specific ongoing court case. If revealing Apple's key for the iPhone's backdoor is a national security threat, then Apple can avoid this by simply using the key to open the one specific door a court asks (that's how the argument would go).
- zepto 11y agoSo why do you think Apple is adopting the strategy that they have chosen? Your line of reasoning is quite straightforward. Do you think nobody there has considered it?
- mindslight 11y agoCompanies have an extremely hard time opening up platforms and removing their special privileges. The market friction caused by their closedness is what makes them money, and Apple is no exception. Plus, they ultimately don't care whether proper crypto is outlawed or not. Sure they'll lobby for it not to be. But if they end up losing they'll just modify their products and still be the least-surveilling company - they're not particularly worried about Free software eating their market share.
- zepto 11y agoHold on - what has any of this got to do with openness? How is that in any way part of the argument? Also, I believe you just called Tim Cook a flat out liar, since he has repeatedly, publicly talked about his and the companies beliefs about crypto.
- mindslight 11y agoAn open design for a trusted computing platform would not contain an arbitrary fixed signing key. It would instead allow modifying the trust root subject to some time delay or proof of work. It would be thoroughly documented, giving the manufacturer no special insight into the use or working that any other developer did not have access to. It would thus not be specifically vulnerable to attacks by Apple, and by extension, USG. Apple believes that proper crypto can be used to provide the best security for their users, and Tim Cook may personally believe that crypto provides the best rights to individuals. But corporations operate in terms of what is legal. If proper crypto were made illegal, that just shifts the playing field for everyone. Apple would still exist and try to provide the best security they legally could - they don't have a mortal stake in this fight.
- zepto 11y agoSo basically it has nothing to do with what we're talking about. You just think a completely hypothetical system which has never existed, let alone been subjected to any kind of attack, would be a better alternative, and so you think that what Apple is doing is in error.
- mindslight 11y agoIt has everything to do with what we're talking about. We can analyze the security properties of systems in advance. It's called engineering. This attack isn't some discovered flaw, but an explicit property of their system design. There are widely-used systems that hold up to the attack in question. For example, Linux's LUKS/dmcrypt does not have this vulnerability. Apple wishes to use lower entropy passcodes, necessitating the use of trusted hardware. Few have gone down this road, so I've detailed properties of a hypothetical design that could be free of manufacturer backdoors. Apple needs to either stop marketing their devices as secure against nation state attackers that can compel Apple, or actually build trusted hardware that's secure from manufacturer as I'm describing. Cryptography is not a "best effort" endeavor.