3 ms·
I'm pretty sure it wasn't the "doctors get to be gatekeepers" problem that held back Theranos here. Rather, it was the "they don't have an actual working finge
by SilasX 11y ago
I'm pretty sure it wasn't the "doctors get to be gatekeepers" problem that held back Theranos here. Rather, it was the "they don't have an actual working finger-prick test and have avoided numerous cheap ways to prove they have one" problem.
In contrast, 23andme can legitimately claim to have been held up in that respect. They did have a working product, which correctly identified the patient's genes, and correctly reported the state of the literature on each gene; no one claimed otherwise. It's just that the combination of those two services counts as a medical device under current law, and they didn't get regulatory approval first.
- goodcjw2 11y agoI tend to agree with you on Theranos. I wasn't trying to say that Theranos is doomed from the beginning because they are about to disrupt a well protected industry. Instead, I feel the problem is that we as general public are not educated well enough to make a reasonable judge on whether Theranos is actually working.