3 ms·
Let's say the FBI wins the first case. Then they request a warrant that requires future iOS versions to permit similar access. By what argument would Apple fi
by snowwrestler 11y ago
Let's say the FBI wins the first case.
Then they request a warrant that requires future iOS versions to permit similar access.
By what argument would Apple fight that warrant? The previous case would have already established that such access is necessary, that Apple can provide it, and that the court has the legal power to force them to.
In terms of the burden on Apple, the staff time burden to write software that will run on 50 million iPhones is no greater than software that will run on one iPhone. Code is code.
In terms of damage to the Apple brand, the FBI has already argued that that should not matter:
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/20/business/justice-department-calls-apples-refusal-to-unlock-iphone-a-marketing-strategy.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/20/business/justice-departmen...
- vectorjohn 11y agoI don't buy that. "By what argument would Apple fight that warrant?" By what argument can Apple use to fight this current demand? They clearly can break into the phone.
- mikeash 11y agoThat warrant isn't targeted and affects Apple customers who are unrelated to any criminal investigation. I see no reason why it would be granted. Consider more traditional warrants. The police ask for a warrant to search your house. They get that warrant. Then afterwards they ask for another warrant, this time to enter everybody's house. Does the precedent set by the first warrant make a judge likely to grant the second one? I don't think so. Certainly I've never heard of any such warrant being issued by an American court (excluding the ridiculous FISA court, anyway), even though police would surely love to have one, and the precedent of search warrants for individual houses is extremely long standing.