3 ms·
It's the best example we got. The case was overturned (after he spent quite some time in federal prison) not because it was found that he didn't violate the CFA
by zaroth 11y ago
It's the best example we got. The case was overturned (after he spent quite some time in federal prison) not because it was found that he didn't violate the CFAA but because the charges were brought in the wrong jurisdiction.
Again I think you're confusing the fact someone could trick the server into delivering the content for free with WSJ intending to deliver their content to you for free. Since WSJ clearly intends their content to be delivered to only Googlebot for free and to users only if they pay, it is likely a jury would consider this a violation of CFAA.
A web server returning 200 OK is not ipso facto a guarantee the person making the request is not committing a crime. To give a more obvious example, if the request header contains a stolen authorization token. The law does not require the access control be non-trivial to defeat.
I don't like it, and I think the CFAA is seriously problematic, but it is the law and the Feds have been known to enforce it.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoAs far as the law is concerned, he did not violate anything. You do not have to prove yourself innocent, the burden is on the prosecutor to prove a violation. In the example you cite, no violation has been shown. It is not at all clear that WSJ intends Googlebot to get their content for free while others must pay. Thus is actually against Google's policies, which would actually call into question whether WSJ's behavior is felonius. WSJ may not be entitled to be incorporated into Google's index, yet they are manipulating the Googlebot to the contrary.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoIf you will down mod, at least show how I am wrong!