4 ms·
So, why not fix these problems? Go through the RFC process, if it doesn't collide with anything, it'll make it into the standard, IPv6.1 or whatever, and eventu
by pas 11y ago
So, why not fix these problems? Go through the RFC process, if it doesn't collide with anything, it'll make it into the standard, IPv6.1 or whatever, and eventually things will support it. Sure, it might take ~10 years for all freezers and forgotten L3 switches to support it, but why not start at all?
We can chance these things easier than our visual pattern matching engine. (Not that we can't train it to perform better, but that just means we'll still make more mistakes and will be less efficient than with this small change.)
Fixed width fonts and indentation are good things, the majority of programmers use it for some reason, why not go for sane ergonomics in network related stuff?
- teddyh 11y ago> Sure, it might take ~10 years for all freezers and forgotten L3 switches to support it, but why not start at all? I seriously doubt that any change in notation would be beneficial enough to be worth the 10 years of work, incompatibilities and bugs. You don’t see people making this kind of fuss about MAC addresses; that’s because people know that they aren’t supposed to memorize them, and we treat them accordingly. That’s the thing about IPv6 - you have to realize that you have to let go of the notion of memorizing IP addresses, just as it would never occur to you to know your MAC address by heart. Use the DNS; eliminating the need to memorize IP addresses is what the DNS is meant for.
- toast0 11y agoMAC addresses are actually worse, some software displays uses colons to separate, and some uses dashes. IPv6 addresses are ungainly, and have two forms (canonical short, and canonical full), but you can usually put either form wherever you need an address, and there's good library support. I guess that's a benefit of a multiple decades adoption; by the time I get to use it, everything works already. :)
- jsz0 11y ago> So, why not fix these problems? They're individual preferences not problems. We can't realistically have a bunch of different notation standards to make everyone happy.
- prewett 11y agoTrue, so why not make a good notational standard so that everyone is at least not unhappy?
- jsz0 11y agoI'm a network engineer and I work with IPv6 often these days. I think it's a good notational standard. I don't care about the difference between dots and colons. That's much more of a programmers fetish type of thing. As a general rule I think network engineers, who actually have to work with this stuff, just want consistency. If IPv8 wants to replace colons with middle finger emojis sure OK. Whatever I don't care. Just let me know. I'll figure it out.