6 ms·
And it most definitely is! From the privacy perspective, Apple was foolish to contest the order since this phone is vulnerable to Apple - a storage unit owner u
by mindslight 11y ago
And it most definitely is! From the privacy perspective, Apple was foolish to contest the order since this phone is vulnerable to Apple - a storage unit owner unlocks the unit for the police, what legal basis does Apple actually have to resist? Our values are driven by visions of ideal systems that can only be unlocked by their owner, but that is not what Apple has created!
Unfortunately, Apple is peeing in the pool for all of us that actually care about digital freedom. This case will set a terrible precedent, and prime government to preemptively address hypothetical devices that are secure.
- jonknee 11y agoUm, what? If they didn't take a stand all their claims would be worthless. Their new phones are vulnerable as well, though I would not be surprised for upcoming products to make more use of private keys. (It's a tradeoff between usability and security.)
- mindslight 11y agoTheir claims are worthless. In order to be secure against USG, Apple needed to eliminate the privilege of their own signing key, at least when the phone is locked. A vulnerability to Apple is a vulnerability to every country where Apple has a physical presence. It's hard, but you actually have to throw the ring into Mount Doom. You can't just put in your pocket and promise to never use it.
- leonatan 11y agoGood allegory at the end!
- zepto 11y agoTheir claims are not worthless. Let's imagine that they plan on eliminating that privilege when the phone is locked. If the FBI establishes that it can force code to be written using the all writs act now, then it will also be able to prevent them from throwing away the key.
- mindslight 11y agoThere's a difference between writing code to open one specific device on a legitimate investigation, and restricting what type of security Apple can implement on all devices sold. But you're right, it's a similar activity. Which is why the ideal move this iteration would have been to nicely go along and avoid setting a precedent until Apple was actually shipping a secure phone.
- zepto 11y agoThe precedent is the use of the all writs act for this broader purpose. If it is not challenged now, then it will be established that Apple can be forced to create code to the design of the FBI. This is why it must be resisted now.
- mindslight 11y agoAll Writs is a red herring. Sure the right to not be forced to take on certain paid projects is important, but that isn't the main principle which Apple is defending. Even if Apple prevails, then the FBI subpoenas technical documentation and the signing key, and gets an independent party to write the code. The signing key would be another legal battle (and at least Apple is well funded unlike Lavabit), but that ultimately comes down to Apple having the only key to a container for which there is a warrant. Do you see this ever being decided in favor of the key holder's non-involvement, especially in such an unsympathetic case?
- zepto 11y agoThat key is a key which unlocks every single iPhone. There would be an extremely strong case that revealing that key would be a threat to national security. I think you'd find the case would be harder than you think. That's precisely why all writs is not a red herring. If all writs is not limited at this stage, it will be used for exactly what you are most afraid of.
- 11y ago
- skolos 11y agoStorage unit owner has keys with which s/he can unlock the unit. Police does not ask storage unit owner to demolish his building at his own expense to get access to the unit if owner does not have keys. Apple already "unlocked storage unit" to police where they had keys by providing police iCloud backups. Now police is asking Apple to "demolish the building".
- mindslight 11y agoYes, police don't ask the storage unit owner to break open the door - they just do it. In this case they're even asking first and willing to reimburse Apple, which is nice for a change. If you think anything more than one phone's security is being "demolished", then you've been mislead by Apple into thinking their devices have security properties that they don't actually have. If their reputation takes it a hit, it will be due to their negligent design and marketing, not from the inevitably resulting correction. Security does not suffer politics.
- zepto 11y agoIf the FBI could break into the phone without asking, they would have.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vectorjohn 11y agoThis analogy is garbage. No building is being destroyed. The FBI is asking for a key to this one unit, and the fact that Apple even has the ability to make the key should be evidence that the system isn't as secure as you think. Inside the storage unit is yet another invincible locked container, but the FBI is betting on the key being easy to guess.
- csandreasen 11y agoThis is more like the FBI asking the storage unit owner to turn off the security system that he installed that incinerates the contents of the storage unit when someone tries to pick the lock, but only on the unit that the FBI has a warrant to search. The storage unit owner then responds that although he could put an off switch on that particular unit, it's an outrage and sets a horrible precedent that the police should ever ask him to turn off his security incinerator.
- vectorjohn 11y agoYeah, I'm with you on this. Apple really does have to help, and they're reluctant purely because they know they made a vulnerable device. Helping would make them look bad because it would bring to light that they have the ability to help. It sounds like they could have made a device that even a firmware update couldn't break, but they didn't. I really don't see how they can refuse. Your analogy is good.
- bdhe 11y ago> It sounds like they could have made a device that even a firmware update couldn't break, but they didn't. I really don't see how they can refuse. Your analogy is good. This is nearly impossible because the development lifecycle and end-user usability almost necessitates there be software or firmware updates that would be authenticated (to either fix dev bugs or help users).
- mindslight 11y agoThe solution is to only allow firmware updates when the device is already unlocked. To avoid bricks, a full device reset puts the security chip into an unlocked state after erasing the encryption keys.