3 ms·
Lets put it a slightly different way, lets say you make safes for protecting valuables. And you make your safe so that any attempt to break into it without the
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Lets put it a slightly different way, lets say you make safes for protecting valuables. And you make your safe so that any attempt to break into it without the combination would destroy the contents, or make it so that the only way to open it, like cutting into the steel with a torch, would destroy the contents.
The FBI can (and does) hire locksmiths and safe crackers to get into safes where they believe there is valuable information inside, but they don't compel the manufacturer of the safe to create a capability of bypassing its safeguards, but if they did criminals would seek it out so they could rob those safes, and customers would stop buying that safe because they knew criminals could probably get their hands on the same tools the government could to break into and defeat its countermeasures.
So having the government able to order a safe maker to build a safe that can be broken into, the safe maker loses customers and business because their customers don't want a safe that can be broken into, they want one that protects their valuables from everyone.
- mikeash 11y agoIn this case, the government isn't ordering a safe maker to build a safe that can be broken into. The safe maker already built a safe that can be broken into. The government is just ordering the safe maker to take advantage of that fact and break into it. Many people equate this to demanding that Apple create a security vulnerability, and I don't get it. The vulnerability is already there. The iPhone 5c is already insecure against an attack by Apple. The government is just ordering Apple to exploit that existing insecurity. There are compelling problems with that too, but it's not the same as requiring Apple to build something insecure.
- vectorjohn 11y agoPerfect. To fix your analogy and make it more accurate, it's more like the safe making company has the ability to make a device that can disable the self destruct capability for a single safe. If the safe company simply hadn't built in that capability, there would be nothing the FBI could demand of them, because it wouldn't be possible.