3 ms·
Why don't we have remote take-over capability built into airplanes? People have certainly crashed them intentionally. Why don't we have remote kill switches in
by snowwrestler 11y ago
Why don't we have remote take-over capability built into airplanes? People have certainly crashed them intentionally.
Why don't we have remote kill switches in cars? Think of the high-speed chases that could be prevented.
Why don't we have surveillance cameras in private homes? Think of all the crimes that could be solved.
Even if these are all off by default, and the law requires a court order to turn them on, Americans would not accept them. Encryption is no different, except that most Americans don't understand it well enough to see the parallels.
But these are just arguments against backdoors.
The even more fundamental argument is about the All Writs Act. Can the FBI require companies to develop new capabilities just with a court order? Shouldn't that require legislation? Why did we bother to pass CALEA, if the government could have just said "All Writs Act" and gotten what they wanted that way?
- danjoc 11y agoIt is easier to understand if the same task is rephrased. "Apple ordered by Chinese government to disable lock on phone seized from undercover CIA agent." The act is the same. Being a multinational company, the result is no different for Apple. A government is legally requiring Apple to make decryption possible, but suddenly the people crying for Apple to unlock this phone will take an extremely different stance.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoEverybody I've seen here saying that Apple should assist the FBI in unlocking the device takes the same stance in both cases. If Apple doesn't like it, they should either secure the device in such a way that it isn't easier for themselves to compromise than it is for a third party or stop doing business in that country if they believe the requests are unreasonable.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoUnlike telephone operators affected by CALEA, Apple is free to develop a phone with security that is as hard for them to circumvent as it is for the FBI. When they do, the All Writs Act won't apply to them.