3 ms·
Sure, but the legal precedent will make this a rubber stamp in future, and will mean that Apple can't reasonably resist such orders from other governments.
by zepto 11y ago
Sure, but the legal precedent will make this a rubber stamp in future, and will mean that Apple can't reasonably resist such orders from other governments.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoThis case does not establish any precedent. This is a well-established power that has already been used to access iCloud data and extract unencrypted data off iPhone running older versions of iOS.
- zepto 11y agoAlmost all legal experts who don't work for the FBI who have expressed an option this disagree with you.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoSuch as? For an example to the contrary, see rayiner's comments on this issue. The only people I'm seeing that think this case is precedent-setting are tech bloggers who don't know any better and lawyers who were given a short time to respond and didn't know what the FBI was actually requesting. The only restriction on this law that Apple could claim (aside from legally out-there options like equating writing software to forced speech) is "unreasonable burden," but this is something that almost any of us could hack up in a day given access to Apple's release build system.
- vectorjohn 11y agoThe precedent is already set (the FBI can demand information about a person from a company). In the future, Apple could make a phone that is actually secure. For example, requiring the phone to be unlocked before updating firmware.
- zepto 11y agoWhat are you taking about? Apple has no information about Farouk.
- vectorjohn 11y agoWhat are you talking about? Where did I say Apple has information about Farouk?
- zepto 11y agoYou said that the FBI can demand information about a person from a company. What person are we talking about?