5 ms·
> What the court is ordering Apple to do, security experts say, does not require the company to crack its own encryption, which the company says it cannot do in
by mtgx 11y ago
> What the court is ordering Apple to do, security experts say, does not require the company to crack its own encryption, which the company says it cannot do in any case. Instead, the order requires Apple to create a piece of software that takes advantage of a capability that Apple alone possesses to modify the permanently installed “firmware” on iPhones and iPads, changing it so that investigators can try unlimited guesses at the terror suspect’s PIN code with high-powered computers. Once investigators get the PIN, they get the data.
I don't think there's much difference between a backdoor and that. A backdoor can be "just a vulnerability", and that's what the FBI is asking Apple to create - a vulnerability in its security system.
It's kind of like saying "we don't want Apple to break its AES-GCM encryption, we just want it to replace it with RC4." Or "we only want Apple to support export crypto protocols as well, so we can downgrade to them when we do our attacks".
Whether we call it a "backdoor" or "vulnerability" or "just don't make it that secure" thing, the end result is the same. The FBI wants Apple to weaken its security, and that weaker security can and will be exploited by malicious actors, too (even if you're assuming it won't be abused by the FBI and the police itself, which of course it will be).
- MCRed 11y agoAlso, the court isn't asking, its' demanding, and its demanding Apple create a vulnerability in a system designed to thwart such vulnerabilities. I'm not sure it's even possible. What if Apple didn't fight this yet failed to create a working vulnerability? After all the phone has protections against its firmware being replaced without the passcode! IF Apple were to fail would they be held in contempt of court? This is why I have contempt for our courts-- way too many judges who are never punished for their tyranny.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoAnother issue, tangential and not widely discussed, is the very fact that a court, at a federal agency's behest, is ordering a private company to do highly technical and difficult work, at its own expense. They have not demonstrated that Apple committed a crime, and yet they demand that Apple set up an internal project and commit employees and resources to, essentially, do the FBI's work for it. There has to be a violation of the Constitution in there somewhere. The government cannot compel private companies or individuals to surrender private property (in this case, intellectual property), it cannot restrict freedom of speech (in this case, software is an expression of speech), and perhaps there is also a tie-in to the Commerce Clause. In other words, at a certain point the U.S. government's power should be and must be limited. Unlimited power is dangerous and surely would violate the vision and foundational philosophy behind the Constitution. In this case, unlimited power means that a law enforcement agency can justify nearly any kind of forcible action with the vague reasons of "national security" or "criminal justice".
- btreecat 11y ago> at its own expense. I don't think that is true. My google-fu is failing me however. I think I remember the party being compelled to comply is entitled to charge the Gov a fee for this work.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoI'm curious what Apple would charge for this "service". If I were CEO, I'd request ten billion dollars. A million or so for the time and manhours, and $9.999 billion for the damage to the company's reputation, stock price, etc., that this will cause -- breaking of a promise that "even Apple can't retrieve your data". Suppose Samsung, a non-American company, jumps on this and says, their phones are truly non-crackable and Samsung would not be able to do it, even if they installed a hacked OS to work around the login failure limit. Boom. Apple has just lost millions of sales. Our heavy handed government hard at work, damaging America's best companies.
- venomsnake 11y agoApple put themselves in that position by being the only entity able to sign software on their systems. This is a wide open backdoor by design. If they provided ios devices with the capability to have their own master keys - it would have been moot. iPhone is as secure as the pk of the iphone owner. They cannot do anything to help FBI
- omegaham 11y agoI'm worried that the FBI could respond to the latter with "Well, that just means that you're not allowed to build something like that." That, personally, is far more terrifying than Apple giving the FBI one phone. Because it's a very short road from "You're not allowed to build completely unbreakable security" to "You're not allowed to build anything that could hinder FBI investigation efforts and must build a backdoor." The Supreme Court is going to have to hear this stuff, and I'm doubtful that the rulings are going to be friendly.
- plorg 11y agoMaybe there's a different piece of legal justification elsewhere, but in this particular case it rests on the "All Writs" act. That act does not say that you cannot create a system that the government can't get into. It says that courts are allowed to compel you to help the government in a legal investigation. The extent to which that act allows a judge to compel Apple to assist is what is in question. IANAL, but I suspect it would be a much larger jump to try to use this statute to ban the creation of an encryption system (as opposed to helping to defeat one). If they wanted to do that they would almost certainly have to go through congress or find a different statute.
- randcraw 11y agoPresumably any "backdoor" is a security hole that can be accessed on any phone. So far, this request asks that Apple remove only the part of one phone's security that 1) destroyes that phone's data after 10 failed tries, and 2) slows the automated entry of passcodes into that phone. So far, this case is specific to one phone and thus not about a general backdoor. As the case stands, unless Apple can show how compliance weakens security on other phones, I don't see how they can refuse to comply, unless it's technically impossible for them to do. If it is impossible, their refusal in this case may lead to a ruling that requires them to change iOS to comply with such requests in the future. But if they can comply now, only the security on one phone will be diminished. It's strongly in the company's interest to comply. If Apple does not (cannot) comply, and subsequently they are ordered to change iOS to comply with future requests, would this be a "backdoor"? Yes. I don't see how Apple can add this "feature" to iOS and assure that only authorized legal authorities could activate it in the future. Is this case about changing iOS to comply with future requests of this kind? Not yet.
- sandiegodave 11y agoIf Apple creates new software that removes a part of one iPhone's securty, that software can potentially be used on all iPhones. It's no different from what you said: " I don't see how Apple can add this "feature" to iOS [or in this case, create a tool to use on the current version of iOS] and assure that only authorized legal authorities could activate it in the future."
- ikeboy 11y agoHow is that different from "If I hand over this iCloud data, I'll need to create software to download iCloud data from a specific user, and that software can potentially be used on any iCloud account"? How is this not applicable to any warrant that requires technical ability to comply?
- sandiegodave 11y agoApple doesn't make the same promises about encryption and privacy on their iCloud service that they do their iPhones, that's the only difference. If you store information in iCloud and the FBI comes asking for it, Apple will hand it over. By the very nature of iCloud, Apple has access to your data. Not so with your iPhone. Apple says your device is encrypted and they cannot access it without your consent, end of story. Forcing them to create tools that invalidate this promise on one iPhone means creating tools that can invalidate the promise on any iPhone.