10 ms·
I like it as competition to Intel in the desktop space for power users. Workstation market used to be fun with interesting machines from SGI, IBM, Sun, HP, Comp
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
I like it as competition to Intel in the desktop space for power users. Workstation market used to be fun with interesting machines from SGI, IBM, Sun, HP, Compaq, and so on. SGI's blew people away with graphics & NUMA architectures. DEC/Compaq's Alpha's could be microcoded for concurrency or performance using regular assembly via a scheme called PALcode. HP PA-RISC and SGI's Itanium systems have memory keying scheme for access control, originally in IBM mainframes, that constrains attackers a bit if used well. The RISC systems supported more programming models without the efficiency hit of x86's that assumed stacks and had little registers. Unfortunately, x86 was very good at running C and x86 code becoming more prevalent. Plus the Microsoft partnership. So, everything else pretty much disappeared.
Anyway, it would be cool to have options. Especially with security extensions for code in the CPU and/or open CPU's. Unfortunately, this really ain't it. People are better off licensing or directly using Gaisler's 4-core SPARCs with security extensions a la Cambridge's CHERI, SecureCore, or Hardbound. We'd have fast, open CPU's w/ open firmware w/ open OS's w/ support at CPU level for confidentiality and/or integrity. That is how you begin on a secure workstation. ;)
- nullc 11y agoI'm super excited about CHERI. ... But the fastest CHERI implementation now or likely in the next couple years is orders of magnitude slower than the offerings from AMD and Intel. (Not fundamentally-- but primarily as a product of maturity and development) There are many applications where I'd gladly take a 100 fold performance (or energy efficiency loss) for the kind of security improvement that CHERI gives. But there are also many applications where I (and importantly, other people who care less about security than I do) cannot afford those sorts of reductions. Meanwhile, the fast machines available to us all have opaque, cryptographically locked, and seemingly often vulnerable supervisory code running on them. To make an impact OpenPower solutions need merely be better in some respect (avoiding the secret supervisory code) and not too worse in others. It might be a tougher call if MPX were already a practical reality or if SGX weren't being held back by ridiculous licensing.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"But the fastest CHERI implementation now or likely in the next couple years is orders of magnitude slower than the offerings from AMD and Intel. (Not fundamentally-- but primarily as a product of maturity and development)" That's due to a lack of demand. The ultimate problem for high security. Gaisler's stuff is already implemented. The RISC-V Rocket core is 1.4Ghz. Basic checks like in SAFE's atomic groups have single-digit, percentage effects on performance. The mods can be tweaked to give desire performance. Worst I've seen was 70-80% loss on a prototype designed for research rather than performance on most memory-intensive stuff. Not 100x or anything. "Meanwhile, the fast machines available to us all have opaque, cryptographically locked, and seemingly often vulnerable supervisory code running on them." Definitely improvements to be had in things with open firmware and such. POWER and SPARC have had that for quite a while via Open Firmware standard. SPARC and MIPS have open implementations with SPARC not requiring an ISA license. Not sure about availability of server-grade POWER implementations or licensing costs. Definitely need more to work with in that area. "To make an impact OpenPower solutions need merely be better in some respect (avoiding the secret supervisory code) and not too worse in others." I hope that's true. What killed it before was legacy effect: key apps or capabilities that worked on x86 didn't on alternatives. Even Apple abandoned PPC. Only one doing it on desktops are the Amiga systems. For common use-cases, we need to port Flash, JS JIT's, ASM-optimized codecs... all sorts of things to POWER to achieve parity. I've always liked POWER better than x86. It's just that users use apps not ISA's. That's why x86 has holding power. So, it's literally gotta be users who don't need games, fast browsers, CAD, etc. It has to be people using native apps written in portable code leveraging components written similarly. Even better if it's multi-threaded or benefits from POWER's accelerated instructions. How many use-cases does that represent for desktop users?
- chei0aiV 11y agoFlash is dying, so ignore that. Debian has more than 96% of packages compiled for POWER and IBM is working on porting the reset and optimising things. https://buildd.debian.org/stats/ https://buildd.debian.org/stats/ https://wiki.debian.org/ppc64el https://wiki.debian.org/ppc64el It isn't hard to create new ports, you just have to have the source code, but everyone uses proprietary software so new ports have zero chance outside the open source world.