4 ms·

Why 90% patents are crap

5 points by nitin_flanker 11y ago

Grishnakh 11y ago
This article is clearly wrong, because it says 90% of patents are "crap". The truth is that 100% of patents are crap. The whole system should just be abolished. All it does is give monopoly rights to huge corporations and prevent competition.
- nitin_flanker 11y ago
  No, you can go specific and say that 100% of software patents are crap but that is not true for every industry. Plus, until someone doesn't own a patent,he is an anti patent and the day he finds something worth patentable, he go to a court to protect it and yeah to defend it too when someone else infringes it. Then, he never thinks that let him use. There is difference in approach you know. Until you don't own one, you are always like this. A patent, in essence, provides an inventor incentive for disclosing his invention. Nobody, otherwise, in this money centric world would be spending billions in R&D to invent something if there is no incentive in that. Saying that 100% patents are crap isn't a good thing, I believe. You can once give it another stance; by not looking at it through software lens alone. Try once.
  - Grishnakh 11y ago
    No individual can own a patent and successfully defend it in court. The barrier to entry is too high. Patents only benefit corporations which use them to prevent competition from smaller companies which can't afford the legal costs of patent battles. If you're in favor of patents, then you oppose small business, and you want to live in a world ruled by oligopolies.
maxxxxx 11y ago
Yesterday during a design meeting somebody mentioned there are patents about uploading log files from a device we would be violating with a solution we had cooked up in 5 minutes. Totally insane. Unless somebody comes up with a simple idea for determining whether a patent is real innovation I think we should give up on patents or make them very short term like 2 years for software. It would require changes to a lot of business models but I think in the long run we would be better off.
- nitin_flanker 11y ago
  Most of the software patents are crap. There is a patent on loading animation. Amazon has on one click payement. Apple has on slide lock. There is so much bullshit things in software patents. Then comes Pharma. Other than that, most of the industry file quality patents.

5 points by nitin_flanker 11y ago

This article is clearly wrong, because it says 90% of patents are "crap". The truth is that 100% of patents are crap. The whole system should just be abolished. All it does is give monopoly rights to huge corporations and prevent competition.

nitin_flanker 11y ago
No, you can go specific and say that 100% of software patents are crap but that is not true for every industry. Plus, until someone doesn't own a patent,he is an anti patent and the day he finds something worth patentable, he go to a court to protect it and yeah to defend it too when someone else infringes it. Then, he never thinks that let him use. There is difference in approach you know. Until you don't own one, you are always like this. A patent, in essence, provides an inventor incentive for disclosing his invention. Nobody, otherwise, in this money centric world would be spending billions in R&D to invent something if there is no incentive in that. Saying that 100% patents are crap isn't a good thing, I believe. You can once give it another stance; by not looking at it through software lens alone. Try once.
- Grishnakh 11y ago
  No individual can own a patent and successfully defend it in court. The barrier to entry is too high. Patents only benefit corporations which use them to prevent competition from smaller companies which can't afford the legal costs of patent battles. If you're in favor of patents, then you oppose small business, and you want to live in a world ruled by oligopolies.

maxxxxx 11y ago

Yesterday during a design meeting somebody mentioned there are patents about uploading log files from a device we would be violating with a solution we had cooked up in 5 minutes. Totally insane. Unless somebody comes up with a simple idea for determining whether a patent is real innovation I think we should give up on patents or make them very short term like 2 years for software. It would require changes to a lot of business models but I think in the long run we would be better off.

nitin_flanker 11y ago
Most of the software patents are crap. There is a patent on loading animation. Amazon has on one click payement. Apple has on slide lock. There is so much bullshit things in software patents. Then comes Pharma. Other than that, most of the industry file quality patents.