3 ms·
I am not sure why the parent comment is being downvoted, but for one I'd also like to know why selling insurance requires licensing.
by riffraff 11y ago
I am not sure why the parent comment is being downvoted, but for one I'd also like to know why selling insurance requires licensing.
- minimaxir 11y agoThe consequences of bad actors in insurance issuing are much more severe than bad hairdressers or bad cooks.
- lpsz 11y agoOnly because of incredibly confusing pricing schemes with copays, deductibles, lifetime limits, out-of-pocket limits, in-network limits, and so on and so forth. This should be addressed by making information transparent to all buyers, not through middlemen. A bad hairdresser can slice off my ear and a bad cook can poison me.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoIt's rare for hairdressers to act in bad faith, because acting in bad faith - slicing off ears for fun - is a bad way to make living. In finance, it's incredibly easy to make a living by acting in bad faith. You can offer insurance with no serious intention to pay out, and tie up claims in bureaucracy and legal loopholes. Good regulation should go some way to minimising bad faith actors. In fact the industry seems quite scammy anyway. But it would be much, much more scammy - to a criminal extent - with no regulation at all.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 11y ago"bad hairdressers or bad [personal] cooks" Both of which require licensing.
- dkarapetyan 11y agoAs is the case with most mandatory licensing it is a combination of risk mitigation by the state and barriers to entry by the incumbents. Existing insurance brokers would like to maintain their turf so most that have a license are in favor of the requirements and the state can say it did the right things when something goes wrong and divert the blame to "cheaters" that bypassed the regulatory requirements. In an ideal world everyone would do the right thing, in the real world some level of bureaucracy and regulation is a necessity.
- shagie 11y agoThere was a recent 538 article on rent-seeking (the use of licenses as a hurdle to keep competition out): http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-rent-seeking-is-too-damn-high/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-rent-seeking-is-too-...
- Arnt 11y agoInsurance is an odd product. As a buyer, you want to get nothing in return for your money, and mostly that's what happens too: Your house doesn't burn down. When the vast majority of customers can't tell (even after years) whether they've been had, that creates an unusually strong argument for having someone else check whether the seller is being honest, such as a licensing authority.
- prostoalex 11y agoYou're describing the underwriter. I think he was inquiring about the broker - why do they need to be licensed?
- Arnt 11y agoI'm describing brokers too. Brokers are in a fine position to lose a little bit of paperwork and take a few customers' money for themselves. (Which is an argument for mandatory auditing, not for licensing. Yes.)