37 ms·
I've been explaining this case to others and I've come up with a good way to make them understand. "Instead of the FBI making this request, how would you feel
by grecy 11y ago
I've been explaining this case to others and I've come up with a good way to make them understand.
"Instead of the FBI making this request, how would you feel if the Government of China were asking? or Russia, or Syria? Do you want them to have the ability to read your encrypted data off your iPhone?"
- harryh 11y agoAren't there lots and lots of things that you would feel comfortable with the US doing but not those other governments? What makes this particular issue different from all of those other things?
- mc32 11y agoThere is no reason why a China, Russia or India cannot not make this request from Apple in order to allow them to legally sell their product in those markets. And as sovereign nations they have a right to demand such, provided that's their law and in turn violates no international law they've subscribed to. Countries in the ME and India[1] demanded such from RIM/BBM. [1]http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2013-07/11/blackberry-india http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2013-07/11/blackberry-in...
- grecy 11y agoAnd knowing that once they have that ability, there would be nothing stopping them using it on any iPhone in the entire world? Including yours? You're OK with that? After what Snowden has told us, we know with certainty the FBI/NSA/CIA will use this ability on the phones of citizens of other countries, so I think it's safe to assume other countries would do the same.
- ikeboy 11y agoThey're willing to hand the phone over to Apple and have the entire process take place on Apple's premises, locked to this specific phone. That's what the court order says.
- vectorjohn 11y agoHow would that give them the ability to use it on any iPhone in the world? You think they put the same software on all phones in the world? Same hardware?
- mc32 11y agoFor purposes of discussion I have no opinion on it. I'm only stating the obvious possibilities. Just like I can discuss the possibilities of a meteor striking Earth, I don't have to like it to discuss it and entertain the idea of what could happen.
- rayiner 11y agoWith a warrant, the government can look through my sock drawer. What do I care if they can look through my phone?
- salgernon 11y agoI've honestly never met an actual "you don't have to worry if you have nothing to hide" person. Under which religious or political umbrage do you reside? What if you had something on your phone that isn't illegal now, but is tomorrow? (3D printed gun plans, source code that is found to have been published without consent, an ebook on sexual positions that are still illegal depending on which state and county you are standing on??) 15ish years ago, certain states might have pressed charges if you had a dildo in your sock drawer. What is in your sock drawer?
- tptacek 11y agoYou didn't just totally miss Rayiner's point, but also wrote an extremely creepy comment that would have been inappropriate for civil conversation even had you been right about what he was saying.
- chillingeffect 11y agoFraming mainstream sexuality as "creepy' is outdated, as evidenced by the following: Over three years ago, a newspaper as everyday as USA Today reported "CVS, Walgreens, Kroger, Safeway, Target and Walmart are among major national chains that now include vibrators on store shelves" [1]. IOW Saying the world dildo no longer qualifies as creepy. [1] http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/health/wellness/story/2012-05-29/vibrators-and-sex-toys-sales/55289424/1 http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/health/wellness/story/20...
- tptacek 11y agoNo, that wasn't the creepy bit.
- logfromblammo 11y ago
- venomsnake 11y agoYes I will be fine - if you want security - don't buy ios apple. Buy device you can properly secure. Don't base your security on someone not cooperating with LEO.
- rayiner 11y agoAnd my answer would be: but it's not the government of China, or Russia, or Syria? It's our elected government of the United States asking for help with the investigation of terrorists.
- salgernon 11y agoYou shouldn't be down voted because you're wrong :) and what you say is in no way detrimental to this discussion. That being said, you are wrong because if the ability to backdoor these devices is required by us law, that backdoor will be exploited by anyone with the cash for the exploit, which means Syria, China, Russia, or republicans. It'd be better to remove the encryption entirely from these devices, so at least you're guaranteed of the safety of your data. (I.e., no security) There is nothing about this device that hasn't already been swept up by mass surveilence programs, which I guess is fine because it's done by our elected government and its for catching terrorists, and not say, abortion providers or clinic bombers.
- rayiner 11y agoWe're not talking about backdooring everyone's device. We're talking about Apple helping the FBI exploit a weakness already on the device, to access data on a specific device pursuant to a warrant.
- learc83 11y agoOnce enough people have access to the software, it could be eventually leak. Then everyone's device will essentially be backdoored. Right now we assume no one has developed the capability to exploit this weakness. By forcing Apple to develop this capability, the security of everyone's device is compromised. This assumes that Apple is uniquely positioned to develop the exploit, or at least they are the only ones who can do it quickly/cheaply enough to make it worth it. At the very least, forcing apple to do it publicly demonstrates the feasibility of the exploit to third parties.
- csandreasen 11y ago
- enjo 11y agoIf any of those governments were attempting to track down accomplices to a known mass murderer and terrorist??? At least a little part of me would support it.
- geofft 11y agoAnd when China or Russia or Syria decides that an American is a mass murderer or a terrorist? Do you want them to compel Apple to unlock Francis Gary Powers' iPhone? I'll be honest, if somehow Apple could sign a software update that merely disabled encryption for phones belonging to actual mass murders and terrorists, and didn't work on the rest of our phones, I'd be supportive. It's just that there's no possible way for such a thing to exist. The best you can do is a software update that works on everyone's phone, in the hands of people who promise to only use it on mass murderers and terrorists. That's far riskier.
- vectorjohn 11y agoThis simply isn't true. if (deviceUid = 12345) { openBackDoor() } Cryptographically sign code. Done. We know it's secure and will only work on devicd 12345 because we trust cryptography.
- salgernon 11y agoThere could be an exclusion in the EULA: this software may not be used in the furtherance of terrorist, anti social or illegal activities. Or any activities that might be deemed illegal in the future. Then the EULA police would have the ability to really nail them, like Al Capone for tax evasion.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lern_too_spel 11y agoThe FBI isn't asking for Apple to give them the update to apply themselves. They're asking for Apple to apply the update. To brute force another phone, the FBI will have to go back to Apple.
- rhino369 11y agoFor a similar situation sure. Why not? The court isn't asking to give the FBI access to all phones. Just one phone they have physical control over. Do you really think Apple would tell the Chinese government to fuck off if the Chinese threatened to ban apple unless Apple opened a single phone. I have ten billion reasons to believe they would do it. If those countries were using it to crack down on political prisoners then I'd suggest Apple pull out of the market rather than comply. But generally corporations should not be allowed to pick and choose what laws to follow. If a company doesn't want to subject itself to the authority of a government, don't do business there.
- mirkules 11y agoIf the person with whom you are debating is ex-LEO, ex-military or a conservative, you can easily compare this erosion of the 4th amendment to the erosion of the 2nd amendment. Both the 2nd amendment and the 4th amendment were designed to protect the American people against abuse of power by the government. Supporting the 2nd but not the 4th, therefore, makes little sense. The argument boils down to "if your family members were killed in San Bernardino, you would not support Apple". The rebuttal is that first we should firearms because that is what the SB shooters used to actually commit the crime. Encryption never directly killed anyone.
- snerbles 11y agoIt's closer than you think. Until 2000, strong crypto was classified as a munition under US export rules. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_th...
- mruniverse 11y agoI think if China required Apple to let them read data off iPhones, Apple would do it secretly.
- incepted 11y agoIf there is a subpoena against that phone, I don't really have an issue with the government gaining full access to it. But there needs to be a subpoena and that backdoor can't be activated without one. It's a similar, albeit stronger, idea as "probable cause": giving law enforcement a temporary waiver of rights that regular citizens are usually afforded.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>If there is a subpoena against that phone, I don't really have an issue with the government gaining full access to it. Say the year is 2000 and the US government has a subpoena to access the phone because they want to collect evidence to prosecute a homosexual couple for having consensual sex (which back in 2000 was illegal in some states). The reasoning behind the subpoena matters, and 'OMG TERRORIST' has been so abused that I take issue with it by default.
- incepted 11y agoThen take issues with illegal subpoenas. Siding with Apple on the current Apple/government discussion is trying to cure a symptom instead of a cause.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>Then take issues with illegal subpoenas. There was nothing illegal in my example. Maybe now it would be after Lawrence v. Texas, but not before. Saying one should support the law because it is the law is supporting the tyranny of the law.
- incepted 11y agoI never said that, I recommended to address the cause (unjustified subpoenas) rather than the symptom (the government asking for access to phones owned by criminals or alleged criminals).
- jpgvm 11y ago
- lern_too_spel 11y agoChina and Russia already have this ability. They use it to make iCloud data requests. In what way is that different? If a government is too shady to deal with, Apple has the option of not doing business in that country, which is what those countries would enforce if Apple didn't comply. The other option is to make security that even Apple can't circumvent. They might have achieved this with their newer phones, but it has now become clear that they did not with the iPhone 5C.
- daemin 11y agoChina and Russia make iCloud data requests the same way the FBI already has in this case. Nothing different. The main thing is the FBI wants a free back door to any ones phone.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoNo, they want to circumvent security on this phone with a court order, just the same as the 70 phones that Apple circumvented security on in the US previously.
- daemin 11y agoFrom my understanding in the previous cases the passcode only limited access to using the phone, not to the data inside. This is the same situation as having a password protected PC but not having your disks encrypted. You need to know the password to be able to use the computer, but anyone that has physical access to your machine can just take the disks and read your data using another computer. From reading the article this is how Apple has helped law enforcement previously. Now in more up to date versions of iOS the passcode limits access to using the phone, in addition to limiting access to the data contained inside. This limits what Apple can do to help law enforcement in the previous scenario, since any data they could copy off the phone would still be encrypted.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoThat technical description does not change Apple's legal obligation, which is exactly the same in both cases.