9 ms·
I find criticism of Canonical interesting. They are one of the most freedom respecting software companies out there. But people don't compare them to almost a
by bryanlarsen 11y ago
I find criticism of Canonical interesting. They are one of the most freedom respecting software companies out there. But people don't compare them to almost any company, they compare them against Red Hat. It seems that Ubuntu gets criticized not so much because they are really bad but because Red Hat is so awesome.
- pessimizer 11y agoRed Hat is energetically criticized on many fronts. I think early growth in Ubuntu on servers was entirely due to Red Hat hatred.
- Shorel 11y agoThey are so awesome they basically took over the OS by creating systemd.
- digi_owl 11y agoI think its because most people do not notice the RH behavior. they used to release patch sets for the kernel along with its source. this made it easy for CentOS to roll a "clone" of RHEL. but that changed when Oracle did the same as CentOS and produced Oracle Linux. And now CentOS is part of the RH "family". frankly i think Canonical is trying to avoid a "Oracle Linux" scenario happening to Ubuntu.
- bonzini 11y ago> this made it easy for CentOS to roll a "clone" of RHEL This makes no sense. Having patch sets or a single huge tarball is exactly the same as far as CentOS is concerned. Also, the patch sets for RHEL6 would be around four times the size of the kernel itself so there are also practical reasons to stop distributing them (of course Oracle _is_ a reason, I'm not denying that). The delay in CentOS 6 was due to personal reasons, not to the change in the distribution policy for kernel patch sets. CentOS was acqui-hired because Red Hat needed CentOS as the base for community development of its RHEL-based products (oVirt for RHEV, RDO for RH OpenStack, and so on).
- valarauca1 11y agoYou raise a solid point. The Red Hat/Canonical comparison paints them bad. Yet the Apple/Canonical comparison on the other hand...
- cwyers 11y agoExcept Apple isn't trying to subvert the intention of the GPL, it's just using code not covered by the GPL.
- vacri 11y agoTorvalds explicitly said he doesn't like the GPLv3 because the GNU people tried to subvert the intention of the GPL and lied to people about what it meant. The GNU people are the same ones as the main article refers to when looking for a definition of 'Free Software'. So we find ourselves in a situation where the article author is apparently arguing against group X because they're trying to subvert the intention of the GPL, and using as evidence a definition provided by group Y, who tried to subvert the intention of the GPL.
- michaelmrose 11y agoYou can start by defining what the intention and purpose of the GPL is and move on to explaining how Canonical's uncooperative and unclear stance towards the community whose contributions enable it to exist serves to further those purposes.
- vacri 11y agoWhich version of the GPL? Because there are several, and in the Torvalds talk linked above, he points out that the different versions have different intentions. > Canonical's uncooperative and unclear stance towards the community Uncooperative and unclear? The 'flat refusal' linked in the main article is pretty clear and cooperative. "Do this thing at this link and we'll be cool with it, and we have a track record of being so". Sounds clear and cooperative to me. > whose contributions enable it to exist This is the kind of shit I mean above when I say pissing on allies. You're painting ubuntu as a parasite rather than an ally. Ubuntu has done plenty to help the community and is part of that community - in particular, they took making a non-techie friendly desktop and driving that goal forward as their specialty. Do they do everything perfectly? No, but none of the major players do. I mix debian and ubuntu in my work, and the debian/FSF purists really puzzle me sometimes. One friend of mine read mjg's comments on the same issue on lwn and bought it hook, line and sinker. Started arguing with me that there was zero difference between Apple and Canonical, simply because although Canonical provide you with their source code, you need a little more elbow-grease to make a derivative of their whole integrated environment (which is a violation of a very liberally-read 'freedom 2', apparently). You're free to make that derivative, but it's just not as simple as removing one package. Apparently this makes them the same as a corporation famous for it's industrial secrecy and lockdown of user capabilities, and who has had the police raid someone's home because they thought one of their prototypes was there. It's a ridiculously binary view of the world.
- michaelmrose 11y agoFoo is less bad because bar and baz are so much worse is a terrible line of reasoning
- philh 11y agoIn a world where there are pressures on foo, bar and baz to be bad, and foo is fighting those pressures and bar and baz are not, it seems to me that foo should be praised for being less bad than bar and baz. (There are probably also situations where that would be a terrible line of reasoning.)
- im3w1l 11y agoWhen it comes to freedom and privacy, Linux is a luxury brand. This can be a blessing(if you want that userbase), and a curse (if you don't want to live up to the expectations).