2 ms·
This is a positive development. The central question in Apple's case is "what are the limits of the All Writs Act authority?" Can a court use the All Writs Act
by snowwrestler 11y ago
This is a positive development.
The central question in Apple's case is "what are the limits of the All Writs Act authority?" Can a court use the All Writs Act to compel any behavior that the FBI says would be helpful to an investigation?
If so, it would seem to obviate the need for legislation. No need to bother Congress--just get a warrant for any encryption back doors you want.
At least a bill submitted to Congress will follow a public, democratic process.
- mc32 11y agoWe'll likely see more developments like this from other large iPhone markets. It's a noble but ultimately untenable position for a manufacturer to take. If the courts, the owner and let's suppose the majority of the people of a jurisdiction (in this case US law) legally make this request I don't see how a company can get from out of complying by saying "we made it impossible". The courts will say, fine, in the future make it possible and not complying will forfeit the right to sell such a device. Either the US, the EU or China will make their case economically and Apple will capitulate or exit a market --and I don't see them exiting large markets. There is also no historical precedent where the notion of privacy has meant "secret forever" so this is new territory and where it ends up will probably depend on how society values new notions of privacy versus providing legal access to information for the purposes of crime investigation. In the US, and China, people have typically sided with the state, so I don't see this changing.
- snowwrestler 11y ago> There is also no historical precedent where the notion of privacy has meant "secret forever" Sure there is: a private verbal conversation. There are plenty of ways for the government to record such a conversation if they know in advance that they want to do so. But if they don't know that in advance--as they did not with the San Bernadino shooters--then the only people who will ever know what was said in that conversation are the people who held it. Historically, privacy meaning secret forever was the norm! It is only in the last few years, with text-based electronic communications, that law enforcement has come to expect retroactive access to all conversations. It's a very dangerous concept that should require careful consideration and votes to create. Instead it got created by default because no one knew how to do info security well 10 years ago.
- mc32 11y agoHistorically the world was gossip and telling "secrets" people lived in close quarters so keeping secrets was generally pretty difficult. With written communication, secrets ended with the death of the recipient where upon people would read letters and such --not that with most people illiterate there would be many people writing secret things. I don't think the courts, the electorate or congress would allow or condone wholesale warrantless access to "private messages", however, I think what will happen is people will decide discrete, lawful access for investigative purposes with oversight will be tolerated. Most people are not binary about this issue. Most people are more nuanced about the topic and most people, I believe, will decide that there are circumstances where they believe "the government" has valid reason to have access to that kind of data from specific kinds of people who conduct specific kinds of acts.