20 ms·
Yes, that's the tradition part. I certainly don't object to using whatever notation you like when you're at a whiteboard or scribbling on paper. But math papers
by skybrian 11y ago
Yes, that's the tradition part. I certainly don't object to using whatever notation you like when you're at a whiteboard or scribbling on paper. But math papers are carefully formatted and published using LaTEX, not by taking pictures of whiteboards. This isn't because it's easiest. It's supposedly to benefit the reader, and yet fails in practice.
It seems like coming up with a format that at least allows definitions and usages to be hyperlinked might be pretty nice, instead of a format whose primary benefit is looking pretty when you print it on paper.
- shasta 11y agoGo to definition (for symbols or notation) would certainly be helpful in reading a mathematical paper, but how is that related to choosing good notation? Do you have an example of mathematical notation that "fails in practice"? In my experience, mathematical notation becomes established because it works well enough in practice.
- skybrian 11y agoI don't have any specific example, but I've read that many (most?) math papers are incomprehensible to outsiders, even mathematicians in other fields. I also seem to remember an article about a proof that's gone unchecked for years. So, from the outside, it seems like there are big problems with communication in the mathematics community, and it's simply accepted that it has to be that way because math is hard.
- kaitai 11y agoGood notation certainly aids understanding, but math is a vast endeavor where the details matter. In switching from one programming language to another, often a rough understanding of corresponding concepts is enough: how to print has different details in different languages but it's not that different, and the details are easy to look up. On the other hand, just switching from topology to symplectic geometry involves asking entirely different questions -- having different values and pursuing different goals. Maybe it's more like switching from web dev to scientific computing as well as switching languages. Yes, a lot of mathematical papers are incomprehensible to others in the field. But it's not just because of notation. You wouldn't ask a content marketer who is great at A/B testing to deal with tweaking something in the linux kernel because it's all "computers".
- shasta 11y agoThis is like saying that the Windows codebase is incomprehensible and thus C / C++ must need better syntax.
- magicalist 11y agoFWIW internal links between equations and figures in LaTeX is pretty easy and should be supported by most readers. Poor mathematical writing is pretty rampant, but that's partly due to the fact that it's not taught well and there's definitely some cultural biases towards jargon. I don't think that negates the fact that even within a typewritten document a human needs to read and understand what's going on, so often terseness is desired, as long as the reader understands the notation enabling it.
- j2kun 11y agoI think papers are primarily aimed at other expert researchers, who actually do prefer brevity.