6 ms·
Senator drafting bill to criminalize Apple’s refusal to aid decryption
- droithomme 11y agoThis concept of retroactive back doors seems a new awareness. Actual, non-retroactive, backdoors are built into a design. The idea you can take an existing design and insert a backdoor that works retroactively really is not a backdoor but is a complete security failure and a bug in the original design. "My design is completely secure as long as no one issues a retroactive backdoor." means the design is not secure at all.
- jhanschoo 11y agoFor certain notions of secure. Let's use the analogy of a house to describe the OS. Most organizations may trust Apple to provide the service of updating their OS when new bugs (some security) are discovered, that is, they are comfortable giving Apple "maintenance door" access to the non-sensitive parts of their iOS device, to perform janitorial and construction services, and plugging holes in the house; and only Apple has the keys through the maintenance door.
- beedogs 11y agoAh, the GOP. Keep this in mind when they carry on about being the party of personal liberty.
- rhino369 11y agoTaken narrowly, there is no personal liberty at stake in this situation. Searching this phone is clearly permissible under the 4th amendment. I guess making Apple--a huge corporation--assist is somewhat against liberty, but I wouldn't call it personal liberty. They get compensated for it. The slippery slope argument everyone seems to be pushing doesn't quite make sense to me. How is forcing Apple to help get past security after a valid court order going to hurt third parties privacy? Nobody is asking for Apple to introduce a backdoor into their products for sale. Only to exploit a backdoor into one specific phone.
- skywhopper 11y agoThe backdoor does not currently exist. Creating it leads to a slippery slope because the FBI will not only ask Apple to unlock phones from known dead terrorists who killed multiple people, but it will cascade to suspected terrorists, and then families of suspected terrorists, and then drug dealers and drug users and then speeders and loiterers and people of the wrong color, just like every other police abuse of power. And then if Apple gives into the FBI, it'll have to give into the UK and France and Germany and China and Russia and anywhere else they want to sell their phones. And once the capability is created and exists, it can leak, and then no one's phone is safe anymore. That's the slippery slope.
- noonespecial 11y agoAnd unlike many of the "slippery slope" arguments that seem to involve hand-wavy-ness and no-reasonable-person-ness, this one is straight, slick, steep and you can see right to the bottom. Don't get in the tube and push off if you don't want to ride this one all the way down.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoNote that the purpose of this case is not to get the data, the FBI have other options for this specific example. The purpose is to set a precedent, and to get the backdoors they want created. This isn't some haphazard accidental "oops, we didn't mean to go so far" situation, this is the FBI getting out the hose and the slip-n-slide and pointing a gun at Apple to get on.
- rhino369 11y ago>The backdoor does not currently exist. This is pretty much semantics. Apple can load a modified firmware without the password. That is a backdoor. >Creating it leads to a slippery slope because the FBI will not only ask Apple to unlock phones from known dead terrorists who killed multiple people, but it will cascade to suspected terrorists, and then families of suspected terrorists, and then drug dealers and drug users and then speeders and loiterers and people of the wrong color, just like every other police abuse of power. The fact is that each time this tool would be used would require a federal district court to specifically order it. That eliminates the slippery slope risk. The courts would absolutely allow it for murder cases. In fact, any federal crime. But that's what is supposed to happen. And if you really think that a district court would let the FBI search a phone because they are the wrong color (or any other blatantly illegal purpose), well that court would also force apple to help them. So it ordering this now doesn't increase the likelihood of it happening. >And then if Apple gives into the FBI, it'll have to give into the UK and France and Germany and China and Russia and anywhere else they want to sell their phones. I am not arguing that Apple should give the FBI the power to do it independently. The FBI isn't asking for it. And the court didn't order Apple to do that. Apple already has the capability to do this.
- stvswn 11y agoPlease, Dianne Feinstein is equally supportive. This doesn't align well with the parties -- hawks in both parties are bad about it, while each party has factions that are pro-liberty on this issue. Ted Cruz, for example, took a lot of heat from Rubio and Christie over his pro-encryption stance. Hillary is pretty weak on the issue.
- beedogs 11y ago> Please, Dianne Feinstein is equally supportive. She's an anomaly among Democrats. She may as well caucus with the Republicans, given her abysmal record in this area.
- coldcode 11y agoSo all of Apple will go to jail? Or just the shareholders?
- sirmiller 11y agoThey will just move all business and all assets out of the country. Having quite a big impact on US economy. Or: Govt will seize control of Apple ... and destroy it within six month. Throwing technology back by 10-15 years.
- EvanPlaice 11y agoLegally, corporations are people so I'd assume they have some sort of secret squirrel digital prison for imaginary people. /s
- stvswn 11y agoNo, they're not "legally people," they're "legal persons," and that was true before Citizens United. They are capable of suing and being sued, and capable of committing crimes. Under the doctrine of respondeat superior, a corporation may be held criminally liable for the illegal acts of its directors, officers, employees, and agents.
- Outdoorsman 11y agoI believe you are correct: The legal doctrine of respondeat superior is recognized in both common law and civil law...it translates, from the Latin, as "let the master answer"... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Respondeat_superior https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Respondeat_superior
- bsder 11y agoWhat the real problem is is that the TLA agencies don't have anything to lose with this. Is there no way to go: "All right. We'll do that. HOWEVER, if we don't find anything on this phone, we want this held up as a prime example of government overreach and we want all further attempts on this judicially banned." If the TLA agencies had a downside to losing the case, they'd drop it in a flash.
- jacquesm 11y agoResults based reasoning for things like this is a deadend. Whether or not anything is found on the phone should not factor into deciding whether or not this is a prime example of government overreach.
- sbose78 11y agoThey'll probably never agree that they didnt get anything. They'll claim they got evidence related to "suspicion to X " which could be entirely based on a conversation where someone was expressing opinions. And yes, they might also say that the information is classified!
- runamok 11y agoYeap. "Parallel construction".
- shawn-butler 11y agoI think it's funny it would be illegal for Apple to comply with the order under federal law and now they want to make it illegal not to comply with it. Kafka would be proud.
- snowwrestler 11y agoThis is a positive development. The central question in Apple's case is "what are the limits of the All Writs Act authority?" Can a court use the All Writs Act to compel any behavior that the FBI says would be helpful to an investigation? If so, it would seem to obviate the need for legislation. No need to bother Congress--just get a warrant for any encryption back doors you want. At least a bill submitted to Congress will follow a public, democratic process.
- mc32 11y agoWe'll likely see more developments like this from other large iPhone markets. It's a noble but ultimately untenable position for a manufacturer to take. If the courts, the owner and let's suppose the majority of the people of a jurisdiction (in this case US law) legally make this request I don't see how a company can get from out of complying by saying "we made it impossible". The courts will say, fine, in the future make it possible and not complying will forfeit the right to sell such a device. Either the US, the EU or China will make their case economically and Apple will capitulate or exit a market --and I don't see them exiting large markets. There is also no historical precedent where the notion of privacy has meant "secret forever" so this is new territory and where it ends up will probably depend on how society values new notions of privacy versus providing legal access to information for the purposes of crime investigation. In the US, and China, people have typically sided with the state, so I don't see this changing.
- snowwrestler 11y ago> There is also no historical precedent where the notion of privacy has meant "secret forever" Sure there is: a private verbal conversation. There are plenty of ways for the government to record such a conversation if they know in advance that they want to do so. But if they don't know that in advance--as they did not with the San Bernadino shooters--then the only people who will ever know what was said in that conversation are the people who held it. Historically, privacy meaning secret forever was the norm! It is only in the last few years, with text-based electronic communications, that law enforcement has come to expect retroactive access to all conversations. It's a very dangerous concept that should require careful consideration and votes to create. Instead it got created by default because no one knew how to do info security well 10 years ago.
- dang 11y agoIn the hierarchy of unsubstantiveness, "announcement of an announcement" definitely comes first, but "drafting a bill" could well be second. Most proposed bills go nowhere, let alone bills that haven't been written yet. If anything comes of this, we can discuss it then.
- wantreprenr007 11y agoJust goes to show you can't legislate morality, but a crooked politician can try to make scruples illegal. (I so hope Bernie wins and has the DoJ investigate folks for corruption and racketeering, starting with Cheney.)