10 ms·
Interesting! This part got me thinking though: >And last summer a map compiling all the Sanders campaign happenings across the country, built by volunteer Rapi
by SilasX 11y ago
Interesting! This part got me thinking though:
>And last summer a map compiling all the Sanders campaign happenings across the country, built by volunteer Rapi Castillo, a Philippine immigrant living in Queens who isn’t an American citizen and can’t vote this November, became the official “eventslink on Sanders’ website.
So a foreigner is effectively giving an in-kind campaign contribution to a candidate? How come people (and the law) lash back at monetary contributions but not this kind?
- Zikes 11y agoIf the data is openly available I'm not sure how anybody could stop a foreigner from building whatever they wanted on top of it. You could question the decision to link to it in an official manner, but by that point it just becomes a freedom of speech issue, doesn't it?
- SilasX 11y agoYeah, but then (per sibling subthread) we're right back to Citizen's United: "So I can spend all the time I want promoting a candidate, but if I use that time to generate money to pay others to promote the candidate, that's prohibited?" Prohibiting "contributions" to candidates, has to infringe on a kind of free speech.
- Zikes 11y agoI disagree with the Citizen's United comparison, since donating time towards a campaign can't be pocketed the same way money is. You can't commoditize already-spent labor in that way. Regardless, I think the real solution would be campaign laws similar to the UK's. It's my understanding that each candidate is given the same hard cap on campaign spending, which encompasses everything from advertising to the cost of sleeping on a friend's couch while traveling. Every candidate's expenditures are diligently recorded and easily audited if necessary, and it creates a level playing field.
- SilasX 11y ago>I disagree with the Citizen's United comparison, since donating time towards a campaign can't be pocketed the same way money is. You can't commoditize already-spent labor in that way. But if it displaces another expense, it causes them to pocket the monetary savings from that expense. >Every candidate's expenditures are diligently recorded and easily audited if necessary, and it creates a level playing field. Even the independent expenditures? Like, if someone goes around buying ads because they just like Candidate X so much, does that count against X's budget? Probably not, hence why that approach doesn't quite resolve the Citizen's United issues -- the problem was the advocacy of people unrelated to a campaign.
- Zikes 11y agoSince the labor is an independent expenditure built on public data and the only thing Sanders did was link to it, the expense displacement is effectively nil.
- SilasX 11y agoSo then the UK system doesn't address this problem, because there is still potentially unlimited money from interested parties who can independently propagandize for a candidate or issue.
- gozur88 11y ago>It's my understanding that each candidate is given the same hard cap on campaign spending, which encompasses everything from advertising to the cost of sleeping on a friend's couch while traveling. And how do you deal with third parties who advocate for issues? If Candidate A and Candidate B have a different position on something, it's pretty clear who you're helping if you blanket the airwaves supporting Candidate A's side of the issue even if you're not explicitly addressing either candidate. Does that come out of his budget? Do we restrict unaffiliated groups? Those sorts of restrictions have been tried in the US, and each time they get circumvented by (officially) unaffiliated groups.
- 11y ago
- weatherlight 11y agoI'm not sure how you would enforce that, It boils down to free speech really.
- bmelton 11y agoAnd this is why ultimately I agree with the decision in Citizens United. If my bill rate is $200 an hour, then it's possible to put a financial amount on any activity I do in support of a candidate. If they did that, then we would just get the usual brinksmanship (assuming a cap), and I might be "too wealthy" to contribute time to the candidate I support. Contrarily, if I'm just as passionate about a candidate, and have more money than programming skills, I'm happy to contribute that instead. It was a long road for me before I accepted the argument that money equals speech, but if actions are, then it isn't a big jump for me to suggest that the payment for my actions ought to be as well, and if I made a short film in support of a candidate, I can't see any way possible of doing that for free.
- conical 11y agoEvery citizen has one vote and 24 hours in a day to allocate to supporting a candidate (bounded by the obvious). Speech has much more in common with time than it does money.
- weatherlight 11y agoCorporations shouldn't be people though. This is a dangerous precedent.
- ageek123 11y agoLegal recognition of corporations as people long pre-dated Citizens United: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood
- bmelton 11y agoI disagree 1) that they are, and 2) that they oughtn't be allowed to be for what you're intending. On 1) They aren't persons, but do have a limited degree of personhood. Among other things, that personhood is what allows us to sue them and such. On 2) I don't have a problem with it. If companies have to abide the law, then I can't imagine how it would be that they shouldn't have input into its making. I agree that corporate influence is a real problem, but would personally suggest that limiting the scope of influence available to lawmakers is a better alternative to fixing the problem than limiting people (who form corporations) of their first amendment rights. That said, this debate is getting into the 'purely political' territory, and is probably not a great fit for an HN discussion.
- tn13 11y agoVery interesting point. The only reason I have not donated to volunteered for Rand Paul is because I was foreigner. Also, I think candidates must show responsibility and least make everyone sign that they are US nationals.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rapicastillo 11y agoHi! I'm the immigrant in the story. For what it's worth I'm permanent resident, not allowed to vote. Furthermore, it's seen as an in-kind contribution, just like when you help building a stage for the campaign, only in online-terms. It's explained more in http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/04/us/politics/bernie-sanders-presidential-campaign-tech-supporters.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/04/us/politics/bernie-sanders...
- rbanffy 11y agoI wonder if, as someone who sympathizes with the Sanders campaign, a foreign citizen who is not a US resident, could legally get involved in this. I would, most definitely, not want to create any legal problems to the campaign.
- stephenboyd 11y agoI'm not anyone's attorney, but yes, you can legally volunteer. > The Commission has concluded herein that because uncompensated volunteer services are not considered to be a contribution under the Act, any individual, including a foreign national, may volunteer his or her uncompensated services to a candidate without making a contribution to that candidate. From the PDF linked from here: http://www.fec.gov/pages/brochures/foreign.shtml#Volunteer http://www.fec.gov/pages/brochures/foreign.shtml#Volunteer Whether the Sanders campaign actually wants foreign volunteers is a different issue.
- ild 11y ago
- fiatmoney 11y agoA lot of people actually do have a problem with non-citizens attempting to influence US elections.