5 ms·
China’s Island Missiles Can Effectively Shut Out the U.S. Air Force
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoThe hard part about reading these kinds of things is that China is doing essentially what the United States has been doing since WWII. We put missiles everywhere... Right in China's doorstep even. I just pray that as China grows in military strength they'll also grow in a desire for peace. Right now they are behaving like someone that has something to prove.
- CamperBob2 11y agoRight now China faces an interesting social problem -- their population includes millions of military-age men who are demographically doomed to remain single. Unfortunately, from their leadership's perspective, that means that the lives of those young men are cheap disposable resources. If the Chinese want to become belligerent, expansionistic players on the world stage, right now's the best shot at it they'll ever have.
- smacktoward 11y agoIf you're interested in this subject, here's a post I wrote two years ago about how bad the U.S.'s strategic position in the South China Sea vis-á-vis China was even before these new missiles were deployed: http://jasonlefkowitz.net/2013/08/stovl-the-f-35-and-how-were-even-more-fed-than-david-axe-suggests/ http://jasonlefkowitz.net/2013/08/stovl-the-f-35-and-how-wer...
- bargl 11y agoOK just skimmed parts and read conclusion. Going to go back to later but this is an awesome piece I want to point every strictly "Grow Military" republican friends I have to as, no don't grow the military but be SMART about allocation of funds in order to strengthen military. Money doesn't make a good anything if it's mismanaged. One thing I've seen is that many government projects get their budget shrunk if they don't spend it all... So they use their entire budget even if they don't need to. That is only one small problem in a hugely broken system. A system that doesn't strive for their goal of "winning wars with minimal cost of life."
- kaybe 11y agoI've seen that a lot, and I've discussed it with quite a few people. I think that a lot of money could be saved if that was changed, though maybe organisation and allocation, making the next budget, could become harder. The sad thing is, most people don't seem to care. I even tried to discuss it with the Minister for Development (I'm in Germany) at some point, since I've been working in a place within his influence and saw people do ridiculous things with money near the end of the year, but he didn't even try to understand what I was talking about (he half-heartedly tried to get some names out of me though). Maybe he was too drunk, I hope he was. (Then again, that particular place I worked at measures their progress towards goals in money spent, and that is what the bosses fret over.) Maybe one of the reasons is that the government tries to stimulate the economy and thus keeps up the spending. Still, talking about austerity at the same time is a mismatch. I'm still trying to figure out this puzzle. Does anyone here have any clues to the situation? Is there a good reason for this rule to exist?
- fweespeech 11y agoFair enough but one thing you are ignoring is: > Technology failures. The American strategy for air superiority, not just with the F-35 but also with the F-22 and other modern aircraft, is based on two fundamental technologies. The first is “stealth“: using technology to help our planes to evade detection by radar. The second is “BVR”: using long-range missiles to shoot down enemy planes before the pilot can ever even see them. (The acronym stands for “beyond visual range.“) These technologies are the key to the plan for how a smaller, more high-tech force like ours can defeat a more numerous but lower-tech one like China’s. This also holds true for China and BVR strikes against US naval assets [particular Aircraft Carriers] are critical to China's ability to actually invade Taiwan. The truth is we simply don't know what the real outcome of a battle/war would be but things like the OP are pretty much useless unless China can hit us BVR because they are slow enough BVR strikes against them would be viable. US's BVR problem for is it is really limited to aircraft and they need to be able to stop China in the air/water because a protracted land war is untenable. China's BVR problem is the fact they can't stop us throwing as many missiles as we can afford/manufacture at them while maintaining a supply line. I know which problem I'd rather have and it sure as hell isn't supplying an invasion force while my opponent can throw effectively unlimited missiles from BVR at me. Sure, I might be able to stop 80% of them but the US can build basically unlimited quantities of them in a serious war.
- smacktoward 11y ago> Sure, I might be able to stop 80% of them but the US can build basically unlimited quantities of them in a serious war. I'm not sure a U.S./Chinese war that came down to raw industrial production capacity would be as favorable a scenario for the U.S. in (say) 2020 as it would have been in 1990...
- fweespeech 11y agoMissiles are ~$1.5-2 million for the top end for this role. They are substantially cheaper than even China can build amphibious transport ships for, let alone the munitions & troops they'd carry. Even China's manufacturing capacity isn't enough to handle the massive cost difference of a transport vs. sinking it.
- arprocter 11y agoCool piece. Do you have anymore about the RAF's cold-war Harrier plans?
- smacktoward 11y agoThis 2006 history of the Harrier and its precursor projects (warning, PDF) from the Royal Air Force Historical Society goes into detail on the subject: http://www.rafmuseum.org.uk/documents/Research/RAF-Historical-Society-Journals/Journal-35A-Seminar-the-RAF-Harrier-Story.pdf http://www.rafmuseum.org.uk/documents/Research/RAF-Historica... The chapter titled "The Cold War Concepts of Operation for the RAF Harrier Force" (p. 55-63), written by Group Captain Jock Heron, will be of particular interest.
- arprocter 11y agoThanks!
- curt15 11y ago>The American strategy for air superiority, not just with the F-35 but also with the F-22 and other modern aircraft, is based on two fundamental technologies. The first is “stealth“: using technology to help our planes to evade detection by radar. The second is “BVR”... While the F-35 does rely entirely on stealth, the ATF program that gave birth to the F-22 emphasized both stealth and extreme performance. High speed and high altitude complement stealth by reducing the adversary's reaction time while increasing the reach of one's own weapons.
- jessaustin 11y agoThe problem in the Taiwan Straits scenario, the report points out, is that the U.S. has exactly one air base within 500 nautical miles of the strait — Kadena Air Base, on the Japanese island of Okinawa. There are other air bases in the region (in Korea, northern Japan, and Guam), but they all range from 800 to 1500 nautical miles away. Something I remembered while reading this, is that Philippines is thawing a bit to the idea of the presence of USA war matériel. There aren't any bases open yet, and Subic Bay would still be 500 nm away from Taiwan, but if China continues as they have, a number of new opportunities might come up.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoPhilippines is thawing a bit Fuck 'em. We had a big air base and a big naval base in the Philippines, and they kicked us out. But, as Henry Kissinger frequently reminded us, we don't have friends or allies, we have "interests". And I'll grant you, right now it is very much in the US's "interest" to have an expanded presence in the area.
- jessaustin 11y agoAs a taxpayer, I wish that many more nations would kick us out. Actually what was lost during the 25 year hiatus? ISTM nothing? Now that China's actions provide a reason for a USA military presence, there can be such a presence again.
- skywhopper 11y agoConveniently for defense contractors, only the F22, F35, and B2 are immune, according to a completely unsourced assertion!
- curt15 11y agoIf, as the article asserts, HQ-9 incorporates Patriot missile technology given to them by Israel, conventional aircraft would certainly not be safe.
- exhilaration 11y agoWhy would the Israelis do this?? Here's the line from the article: "According to Missile Threat, the Chinese developed much of the HQ-9’s technology from a Patriot battery Beijing acquired from Israel" Is this true?
- throwaway21816 11y agoYes the israelis sell lots of US tech directly to China and Russia in exchange for cash Inb4 a bunch of downvotes
- skywhopper 11y agoIncorporating Patriot technology does not mean it's as good as a Patriot. Nor that they have enough of them to seriously threaten our non-stealth fighter fleet.
- arprocter 11y agoThe F117s are quietly gathering dust in Nevada It can't operate from a carrier though
- gaius 11y agoWell the F35 certainly doesn't belong on that list, being fictional an' all.
- floppydisk 11y agoIt's the same strategy the Japanese tried using in WWII to turn islands into stationary aircraft carriers. So long as you can keep them resupplied, it works to a certain degree. The moment the supply line gets into trouble, the island starts losing its ability to project power. Replacement parts, supplies for the ground crews, etc. all start disappearing. As a deterrent, they make a great show piece, as a practical matter, it's possible to either exhaust their supplies and bypass or take them out via other means. Realistically, in the event of hostilities, we wouldn't send in the air force to take the islands out. We'd launch a bunch of sea skimming cruise missiles from a submarine or a special forces raid onto the island to punch a hole in the air defense grid then let the planes through. We did something similar in Gulf War I & Gulf War II. Planes only went in after other forces ensured the air defense grid wouldn't be defending much.
- Someone 11y agoSo, what's your opinion on Diego Garcia (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diego_Garcia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diego_Garcia)? Waste of effort, too?
- nickff 11y agoDiego Garcia is not part of a defensive line, it is a force multiplier. The problem with using an island chain to defend yourself is that you must keep all the islands supplied, and this is a logistical nightmare. A single island is much easier to supply and defend. Diego Garcia is a single island, more like Malta than the Japanese islands and islets. Diego Garcia's capacity for basing large strategic bombers close to potential conflict zones is a huge force multiplier, much like basing aircraft in Malta allowed the Allies to disrupt axis resupply efforts to North Africa.
- dsp1234 11y agoWaste of effort, too? As an air defense base, yes. As a FOB for non-wartime activities, no. As a defensible base in an all out war, yes. That said, I can't imagine Diego Garcia's primary role is to act as a buffer/barrier so the two aren't really comparable in that way. After all, it has: "two parallel 12,000-foot-long (3,700 m) runways, expansive parking aprons for heavy bombers, 20 new anchorages in the lagoon, a deep-water pier, port facilities for the largest naval vessels in the American or British fleet, aircraft hangars, maintenance buildings and an air terminal, a 1,340,000 barrels (213,000 m3) fuel storage area, and billeting and messing facilities for thousands of sailors and support personnel." Is this comparable to what the is being done by the Chinese?
- 1stop 11y agoI'm wondering if it has been reported everytime the US has deployed some defensive missile batteries around the world... Pretty much US aircraft carriers have more fire power then these batteries. Do we report their movement as hard as this? Like is this just agg-prop to some anti China sentiment?
- kgrizzle 11y agoFrom the international perspective, china unilaterally declared the islands sovereign territory, and specifically claimed there were no military intentions for the island. China has contradicted its previous claims, and alienated the neighboring territories by claiming disputed territory. The international community is understandably displeased with china.
- bendykstra 11y agoThis is newsworthy because the island exists within an area of overlapping territorial claims. The installation of the missiles is an escalation in an ongoing dispute.
- vacri 11y agoSo is NATO putting missiles into ex-Soviet states bordering Russia, but we don't see much on the new cold war with Russia on these pages.
- aeturnum 11y agoDeploying missiles onto land that everyone agrees you own is one thing. Deploying missiles onto land that other people think they own, which could fire on planes flying over more land people disagree about, is clearly a different situation. That said, I agree that the media under-reports provocative actions by groups we like.
- personjerry 11y agoWell you say "land that everyone agrees you own" and yet that point of view was not unanimous (for example the Russians didn't think so). From the Chinese point of view, perhaps it seems like it is "land that everyone agrees [they] own".
- pinaceae 11y agoNo, it won't. In all out conventional warfare you bring out the tactical nukes via various deployment mechanisms. If the batteries form a big threat, they'll get wiped.
- jacquesm 11y agoConventional warfare does not include 'tactical nukes', that's nuclear warfare. By definition conventional warfare does not include bio, chemical and nuclear weapons.
- pinaceae 11y agoboth WW so far have been labeled conventional, saw use of those weapons. full out thermo-nuclear warfare with the intent of wiping out the enemy completely has not been done, obviously ever. yet. US vs. USSR was at this stage. US vs. China is not due to China's smaller arsenal.
- smacktoward 11y agoThe Chinese have nukes too. You bring out your nukes, they bring out THEIR nukes, and then you're on the slippery slope towards Armageddon.
- true_religion 11y agoIn the case of tactical nuclear weapons, I don't see what gain there is versus traditional bunker busters using depleted uranium warheads.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoDU is not a "nuke". It's kind of the opposite. It's the byproduct of the process of separating the more active isotopes from the almost non-radioactive one, U-238.
- deleted 11y ago
- ck2 11y agoMakes you wonder if China maybe has a 20 year plan towards something very bad out there. I mean why do they even want that space?
- mastax 11y agoUseless islands are good for expanding Exclusive Economic Zone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exclusive_economic_zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exclusive_economic_zone
- unethical_ban 11y ago$5 trillion a year in cargo passes through.
- johngalt 11y agoIt allows china to press economic claims in the surrounding waters. Such as exploitation of resources, and interfering in commercial shipping. Overall it's a chess move. It allows China to exert pressure on the region. Similar to Iran and the strait of Hormuz.
- throwaway21816 11y agoThe minerals, fish and shipping of the area makes up most of the other countries economies. With control of this area china could exert pressure directly onto these other countries.
- fweespeech 11y ago> The addition of the HQ-9 — which was first reported by Fox News on Feb. 17 — would greatly increase the People’s Liberation Army’s air defense capabilities in the region. Like the Russian-made Almaz Antey S-300 air defense system, the HQ-9 has the ability to render vast swaths of territory into virtual no-fly zones. Only the Lockheed Martin F-22 Raptor, F-35 Joint Strike Fighter and Northrop Grumman B-2 Spirit stealth bomber can safely operate in the vicinity of an HQ-9 for any length of time. The title is simply wrong. 1) B-2, F-22, and F-35 can all be used to throw missiles at these sorts of targets and then exit the area. The HQ-9 / Patriot can't track stealth aircraft at extreme range effectively. Or you throw sea skimming / low altitude cruise missiles with jamming to provide EW cover. http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/american-f-22s-b-2-bombers-vs-russias-s-300-syria-who-wins-13905 http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/american-f-22s-b-2... > The Raptors “kick down the door” using their unique combination of stealth, high altitude and blistering speed to target the nodes of the integrated air defense system so that the B-2s can proceed to their targets unmolested. It’s a mission the F-22s have only gotten better at with the Increment 3.1 upgrade that allows the jet to geo-locate emitters much more precisely than before. And that capability will continue to improve with the Raptor’s forthcoming Increment 3.2B upgrade. > The other option to take down an integrated air defense system is to use a combination of standoff weapons like the JASSM and JASSM-ER cruise missiles together with electronic attacks from a platform like the EA-18G Growler. The Growler can not only jam the enemy’s radar, but can generate an ellipse to target the missile site. The problem there is precisely updating the cruise missile with current track data before the enemy moves during the incoming weapons’ time of flight. 2) HQ-9 [if based on Patriot] is actually less effective than the modern Russian systems. Without the ability to move substantial distances, HQ-9 isn't a serious threat to the US. However, pretty much every US ally in the region isn't capable of standing up to that sort of thing. Given the region is largely divided into the US / Chinese spheres of influence at this point it doesn't really matter because there aren't neutral parties. 3) I'm honestly more concerned about China sparking a major war than I am about their ability to create no-fly zones. ------ EDIT: Since I'm rate limited: Realistically, whether you realize or it, China is in that position and has been for 20 years. A missile base in Hainan would have the range to hit anything transiting to Vietnam via the sea. Short of taking Hainan away from China, Vietnam can be closed to ships by China at any time. China isn't interested in provoking a military conflict but rather guaranteeing its security and a world position equal to the US in all theaters. Similarly, its why Hainan has a semi-covert submarine base: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yulin_Naval_Base https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yulin_Naval_Base
- anon987 11y agoHow the fuck does this story have 28 points? What is happening with Hacker News?
- willvarfar 11y agoI should think the batteries would be themselves targeted by stand-off missiles as soon as any situation deteriorated to a shooting match. > the very fact that the HQ-9 could compete for an international missile tender against American, Russian and European systems — and win — is an indication of just how capable the Chinese weapon is. The odd-one-out in that list is Russia. Turkey might be very reluctant to deploy a Russian system, however cheap it might be up-front. Although relations were much warmer back in 2015, Turkey even then would not want to be dependent on Russia's good-will to keep a missile system running. So shouldn't that quote read "cheap" rather than "capable"? Almost all defence acquisitions are really about backhanders and trade deals etc.
- gozur88 11y ago>I should think the batteries would be themselves targeted by stand-off missiles as soon as any situation deteriorated to a shooting match. Yep. As usual, warisboring is wrong. These kinds of bases will be ignored in peacetime and quickly destroyed in wartime.
- SEJeff 11y agoI doubt they'd shut out an A team of Navy Seals with C4 however. War is boring is one of the better military blogs out there, but this is a silly article. If the US really wanted the islands, a few anti-aircraft weapons will not stop them.
- alkonaut 11y agoAA/AD isn't done by one thing. They need anti ship ballistic missiles and submarines to make sure no carrier group would ever go anywhere anywhere near (i.e. near enough for standoff weapons that would hurt the anti air weapons) and so on. You need all the different pieces of the puzzle to have effective area denial.
- tomjen3 11y agoI can't see how a Chinese vs US war is in either parties interest. Surely China knows they can never take the US mainland and the US can't take China proper, so even if they win they get, what exactly? Other than deep hatred for their biggest trading partner?
- jessaustin 11y agoNeither party you mention is a monolith. Don't consider China's interest or USA's interest. Rather, think of the interests of decision-makers and of those who can influence them (including those who can do so indirectly through a gullible public).
- hga 11y agoSee e.g. WWI. I've read that world trade didn't return to pre-WWI levels until quite recently, 2-3 decades ago.
- smacktoward 11y agoIt's not unusual for rising powers to flex their new muscles by claiming new rights and privileges at sea; the U.S. did it in the 1890s and early 1900s, establishing its power in the eastern and central Pacific by overthrowing the government of Hawaii, driving the Spanish out of the Philippines, establishing bases on Midway Atoll and Wake Island, etc. (Note that all of these locations would become key flashpoints in the war between the U.S. and the Japanese Empire a few decades later.)
- sandstrom 11y agoThe original article is here: http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/look-out-america-chinas-missile-deployment-only-the-15236 http://nationalinterest.org/blog/the-buzz/look-out-america-c... (great if an admin would like to update the url)
- ufmace 11y agoThis is a bit concerning, though the title of "Shut out the USAF" is kinda clickbait-y exaggeration. It's certainly an escalation in the little island "cold wars" of the pacific. Many countries have competing claims on the island and play a little military "chicken" every now and then, usually with minor ships or handfuls of troops. This is the first I've read of any country putting major semi-fixed military hardware on any of these contested islands, though. Clearly missiles like this are a concern for the USAF, but the technology and tactics are in place to deal with them. They certainly do limit the kind of operations that any opposing AF would be willing to undertake without carrying out a strike against the missiles. Like sure, we could probably take them out with the latest fighters and missiles on a well-planned mission, but how willing would we be to send transport or recon aircraft or lone fighters wandering around where they might be in range of these things? What might we, or any other nation, be willing to do around them without attacking them and thus possibly triggering a much larger war? That's the level they're operating at here. I wonder if any other nations will start basing their own high-end hardware on contested islands, or ask the US to do it?
- x5n1 11y agoIt's a matter of time until China has total dominance of the region. It's inevitable.