5 ms·
> Most prosecutors fight requests for post-conviction DNA testing. Knowing human nature, this is understandable - there's a tendency to think that once a "figh
by barrkel 17y ago
> Most prosecutors fight requests for post-conviction DNA testing.
Knowing human nature, this is understandable - there's a tendency to think that once a "fight" has been won, it should stay won. But it's also disturbing: does this tendency cause people to actively want to imprison innocent people?
I've read of similar cases, where prisoners due to be executed have last-minute appeals due to new evidence / etc., but state governors press ahead with the execution so that they can politically appear to be "tough on crime". The problem being that the appearance of being tough on crime seems to come from killing someone, rather than actually ensuring justice is done.
- sliverstorm 17y ago> Knowing human nature, this is understandable - there's a tendency to think that once a "fight" has been won, it should stay won. But it's also disturbing: does this tendency cause people to actively want to imprison innocent people? It's not that they want to imprison innocents; it's a prosecutor's job to get the defendant convicted no matter what, whether or not they personally believe the defendant is guilty. They are simply acting as their job calls for (the conflicting prosecution and defense attorneys in theory bringing about the truth), because until now you could never be 100% sure. '100% sure' and 'our legal system' do not go well together. P.S. Don't invoke the argument over the ethically wrong claiming 'oh I was just doing my job'- this is different; we WANT the prosecutor to behave like that, even if he feels or even knows the defendant is innocent. It's what (in theory anyway) makes the system work.
- donaldc 17y agoIt's not that they want to imprison innocents; it's a prosecutor's job to get the defendant convicted no matter what, whether or not they personally believe the defendant is guilty. I think that in some cases, they want to imprison someone, and show that they are doing their job, even if they have serious doubts about the guilt of the person they are imprisoning. In any case, refusing to allow DNA testing that can categorically establish the guilt or innocence of someone seems to me to be unethical.
- joeyo 17y ago"Any prosecutor can convict a guilty man: it takes a great prosecutor to convict an innocent man." --Melvyn Bruder (http://www.errolmorris.com/film/tbl_transcript.html http://www.errolmorris.com/film/tbl_transcript.html)
- panotpon 17y agoIt's one thing to uphold an oath to zealously represent the state and the victim, but it's another to preemptively repudiate a fact finding effort. I feel it is much more about preservation of ego and judicial economy.
- sliverstorm 17y agoI don't agree on personal levels that what they are doing is right; I just believe it is them zealously representing the state and the victim- via the legal channels provided them. Of course you'll have bad apples, but... Legal system isn't always all that cut and dried, you can't always go straight for the throat. Many of the big crime bosses and such were apparently brought down on tax evasion! I'm sure there's been more than one time stymying a fact finding effort has helped send a guilty man to jail. It's not all cut and dried. I gather my views are unpopular, but hey, oh well.
- lmkg 17y agoI agree that an adversarial system is an effective system for truth discovery. However, in order for it to be an effective and unbiased truth discovery system, there need to be a couple of restraints on both parties, like fully sharing information and evidence. Because prosecutors are incentivized to achieve prosecutions rather than truth, they are encouraged to push (or break) those constraints. While the adversarial system is reasonably effective in theory, the fact that one side is encouraged to miss the forest (truth) for the trees (conviction) has degenerate effects on edge cases. The other major problem is advocacy gap. An ambitious prosecutor looking to jump-start his career will provide unbalanced advocacy compared to a pro-bono defense lawyer.
- nollidge 17y ago> the fact that one side is encouraged to miss the forest (truth) for the trees (conviction) has degenerate effects on edge cases You have to take into account the fact that the defense is encouraged to miss the forest (truth) for the trees (exoneration) as well.
- lmkg 17y agoTrue. However, rather than balancing out, in practice that doubles the number of edge cases.
- davidw 17y ago> we WANT the prosecutor to behave like that, even if he feels or even knows the defendant is innocent. Err... no. There are plenty of genuinely guilty people to go after without knowingly attempting to imprison innocent people.
- jongraehl 17y agoWe want the prosecutor to decide which cases to prosecute, and which to abandon because it's not likely that the accused is guilty. What you say you want is actually horrible and unnecessary, unless you just mean that the prosecutor should proceed if his personal certainty of guilt is only say, 80%, before having encountered all the available evidence; that's fine, because trials should have some truth-finding value, and make all the available evidence known to the prosecution and defense (even if judges can rule out some evidence). At the end of a trial (after all the evidence and testimony is known), in theory, the prosecution and defense should have a pretty good idea of the likelihood of guilt, but we excuse them for playing the game to its conclusion - playing to win even when they suspect their side is wrong: either lying, or deluding themselves with biased/self-interested thinking. In the event a prosecutor is pretty sure the defendant is innocent AND that they can probably get a conviction, I'd like to see them abandon their case (I don't know if this allowed, but they could certainly argue to a jury or judge that the person is innocent), but I understand that it's not required, and I don't consider them evil unless they go further and try to block appeals, or conceal exculpatory evidence.
- sliverstorm 17y agoYou realize what you're asking for here is that the prosecutor decide who is innocent and who to fully prosecute, i.e. who is guilty. That completely, or at least partially, negates the idea that the jury of your peers should do the deciding. As soon as the lawyers start making those kinds of choices, it's not (all) in the jury's hands anymore. Perhaps you might suggest the prosecution is in the best position to know. Perhaps you might suggest that if the prosecution is 80% certain of innocence, that clearly the defendant should be found innocent. But, according to our law, (unless I grossly misunderstand them) it is not his choice to make.
- anamax 17y ago> The problem being that the appearance of being tough on crime seems to come from killing someone, rather than actually ensuring justice is done. Innocent people die in prison every day, typically in the infirmary. If you're innocent, you're better off being given the death penalty because that's your best chance for decent review.
- metamemetics 17y agowhat's more disturbing is that states allow people to be executed based on circumstantial evidence in the first place
- Retric 17y agoIf 17 people on death row out of less than 4000 were innocent, then clearly we executed innocent people prior to DNA testing. So, perhaps we should increase the level of evidence required to kill someone.
- boredguy8 17y agoOr, you know, not kill them.
- JshWright 17y agoOr... y'know... stop killing them...
- Nelson69 17y agoWe've pretty clearly executed the wrong people since there has been DNA testing too. Grisham wrote a non-fiction about it "The Innocent Man." There is some heavy stuff in it. I guess I'm kind of torn, I think we want prosecutors to be aggressive when they go to court. One the case is over, it seems like they need to be removed, their opinion on DNA testing or other things should no longer be needed. DNA or not, how do you convict an innocent man of a crime he didn't do? Just incredibly bad luck and circumstantial evidence? I don't buy that, not if he has a good defense which he's entitled to. The other thing in this Grisham book is that a lot of the mis-convicted folks are poorer, maybe not the most emotionally balanced, and often kind of outsiders in their communities (like the black guy in the all white town, or the dark haired gothic guy in the rural community) and there is more than just DNA evidence that have been perverted. To have any reasonable oversight or feed back into the system, you'd have to remove the prosecutor once his job is done.
- protomyth 17y agoI've gotten to the point that I think the death penalty should be abolished and substituted with life / guaranteed no parole. I am not morally opposed to the death penalty, but I believe that we are not perfect and shouldn't 'accidentally' execute anyone. Plus, it is a whole lot cheaper to keep someone in prison for life then the cost to governments for a full run through the appeals process. In short, its a badly designed, error prone, high cost process.
- otakucode 17y agoThe average person is, for no good reason whatsoever, certain that they will never be falsely accused of a crime. They also believe that anyone who has drawn the attention of the police must have done something to deserve it, and are fine with a few 'innocent' people slipping through the cracks if it means more safety overall. Anti-intellectualism is dangerous, and it is global right now. The principles the US justice system were built on - innocent until proven guilty, acknowledging the possibility of fallibility on the part of the prosecution, etc - are viewed by the general public as loopholes that keep criminals on the street. The simple idea that we would operate based upon principles, regardless of what they are, is viewed as wrong. There is no way to reason with these viewpoints because they reject reason as their basis.