4 ms·
I know zealots are necessary to keep a balance. I've typically appreciated the utility of people like RMS to the free software movement. That said, Matt Garret
by unethical_ban 11y ago
I know zealots are necessary to keep a balance. I've typically appreciated the utility of people like RMS to the free software movement.
That said, Matt Garret's Captain Ahab-like zeal of keeping one of the most useful pieces of open-source code away from Linux, while taking potshots at Ubuntu, is really off-putting. I guess I'm not so pure.
Which is why I run my file server with BSD.
I'm really excited to see ZFS functional in 16.04, and in fact, that got me to install the pre-beta just to mess with it.
- davexunit 11y ago>That said, Matt Garret's Captain Ahab-like zeal of keeping one of the most useful pieces of open-source code away from Linux, while taking potshots at Ubuntu, is really off-putting. Your response to a large company violating the license that Linux is distributed under is to blame Matthew Garret for pointing it out?
- FireBeyond 11y agoThat's a little presumptuous. Violating? On one hand we have some opinions from people, some lawyers, some not, saying they think this could be a violation. On the other, there's equal opinions that this (or the way the did this) is -not- a violation. So I don't think it's particularly fair to reach for your pitchfork, either. Besides, his response had almost nothing to do with Ubuntu, it was "Garret's zeal in trying to keep ZFS off Linux" regardless of distro (which is true). "While taking potshots at Ubuntu" (which is also true, and on issues far wider than "including ZFS".
- ryao 11y agoCan you provide bar numbers of lawyers who would make that claim? So far, Matthew Garrett has yet to claim that any attorney said this is a problem. The only claim he has made (after I got him to clarify what was said) is that he met some attorneys who said that they were not absolutely sure that there is no problem. There are likely attorneys out there that make similar claims about the GPL software in general, so I really am not that concerned that he found a few attorneys that said that they were not sure.
- stubish 11y agoIndeed. ZFS, supported by Canonical. Its Canonical's considered legal opinion that there isn't a problem with ZFS, and if you disagree you can sue them. They put their balls on the table. Dare you to try cutting them off. You need a real lawyer to try that, not an armchair lawyer.
- pilif 11y agoI can understand how you disagree with Mathew (and I also would prefer for ZFS to be universally available under Linux), but that's not the point here. The GPL states in clear terms what's allowed and what isn't. It doesn't matter whether you believe a specific use case should make it ok to violate the license or not. It's like laws. Whether you personally believe they are just or not is not a reason why they should or should not apply to you.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The GPL states in clear terms what's allowed and what isn't. The GPL does not trump copyright law in determining what is a derivative work. > It's like laws. A little bit. But its less like laws than actual laws are, and it depends on the actual laws; it doesn't have the power to redefine them.
- unethical_ban 11y agoIn my heart, I know. As a user, it's just frustrating to see so much awesome technology artificially limited by silly licenses on both sides of this debate.
- ryao 11y agoThe GPL does not placed restrict non-derivative works. If it did, it would not be an OSS license by #9: https://opensource.org/osd-annotated https://opensource.org/osd-annotated