9 ms·
Venezuela president raises fuel price, devalues bolivar to tackle crisis
- joolze 11y ago"Putting these prices in perspective for western readers should result in laughter: the new price for 95-octane is equivalent to $0.11/gallon using weakest official Simadi FX rate of about 203 VEF/USD, and 5 times less using the black market FX rate. The price previously was 0.097 bolivar/liter or about one-fifth of a U.S. cent per gallon. And while the price is indeed laughable to western readers, price increases such as this one are all too tragic to the local population which is paid in local currency terms, and for whom this is merely the latest checkmark on the hyperinflationary wall." http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-02-17/venezuela-devalues-currency-37-maduro-announces-62-fold-increase-gasoline-prices http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-02-17/venezuela-devalues-...
- emartinelli 11y agoIt was (it is?) a common practice to smuggle gas from Venezuela to Brazil, where the prices are relatively high. [http://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/07/world/americas/07brazil.html http://www.nytimes.com/2006/12/07/world/americas/07brazil.ht...] - old article (2006), but the disparity, at least before this annoucement, persisted.
- mnml_ 11y agoRaising the price of fuels would stop oil smuggling
- mikeash 11y agoIf the price of gas in Brazil is anywhere close to the global market price then this price change will barely make a dent in the profitability of smuggling. From some random internet searching it looks like the price in Brazil is fairly high, $3/gallon equivalent or more.
- speeder 11y agoBrazil is absurd with prices, in the other direction than Venezuela, here everything is more expensive than in a first world country, except maybe meat. Brazil is the only country that is rising gas prices while oil price is falling. Also, Brazillian gasoline in Argentina is a third of the price of Brazil, this leads to Brazillians going to Argentina to smuggle Brazillian-made gasoline back into Brazil. Yes, this is "efficient" as it sounds. Also our gas prices are blamed by economists here as one of the biggest reasons we have a 11% inflation. And this is all effect of our extremely bizarre and byzantine taxation model (instead of having a single VAT like in other countries, we have multiple taxes that apply to transactions, with each one having a complex set of rules, many of them being mandatory to be included in the price AND be calculated from the price that include them, thus resulting in recursive calculations). Here is slighly outdated the list of taxes here, from the final product price (ie: a product that costs 100 and has tax of 30%, means that 30 go to the government, and 70 is distributed among the business involved). Gasoline: 53% Microwave: 55% Playstation 4: 72% console-ran software: 72% console dev kits: 72% Bank Interests: 26% (yep, when you pay interest to the bank you pay tax on it too!) Lamp: 48% Powdered Milk: 28% Clock: 53% Fishing Rod: 48% Toilet Paper: 38% Water: 38% Fish (to eat): 48% Cookies: 37% Chocolate: 39% Leather coat: 82% Beer: 62% Matress: 28% House: 48% (also, every time... if you buy a house, you pay 48% of its value in taxes, if someone buy from you, they will also have to pay 48% in taxes again, leading to a extremely rapid inflation in housing prices, leading to a extreme amount of homelessness, people needing to rent, and power concentration in the hands of the actual home owners... for example I once lived in a apartment I rented from a single person that owned 60 entire apartment buildings). Lowest tax I could find: Medicine and chemicals used by cattle ranchers: 13% (no surprise here, the most powerful politicians here are ranchers). Highest tax I could find: Vodka (and some other distilled beverages): 83%
- hathym 11y agoIt was almost 0 (from 0.097 bolivars to 6 bolivars)
- lucio 11y agopercentages used as click-bait... -How's the business? -Great! We've had a 100% increase in visitors in a single day! -Amazing, how many visitors today? -two!
- harperlee 11y agoThis is a knee-jerk response and doesn't really apply to the parent. The gas price raise was certainly not an artifact of having few data points or low resolution as in your example.
- mikeash 11y agoI read it as pointing out that if you take an extremely small number and increase it by a large percentage, the result is still pretty small. Here, the price of gas has gone up by 6,000%. That's a lot! Except that in absolute terms, the price has gone from $0.02/gallon to $0.11/gallon. I can see larger fluctuations than that just by crossing the street in many places.
- harperlee 11y agoYes but then again if I purchase a hundred gallons, I go from paying $2 to $110. So it is indeed such a big growth in price. They are fundamentally different dimensions, because a transaction value goes from negative infinite to positive infinite (from a specific point of view), and in it, zero is just a specific point in the scale (that could be moved by fees or other debts to be netted against); whereas number of visitors can't go negative, and in such a scale zero is absolute (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_scale https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_scale). This makes the comparison dangerous. But it seems that pointing that deserves downvotes...
- rawTruthHurts 11y agoDeserved downvotes not for missing the math, but missing the click-baity-ness, I presume.
- 11y ago
- JumpCrisscross 11y agoThis is a positive development. Too little, too late, but a better direction than the "vice president for the economy" Maduro appointed last month who, quite literally, does not believe in inflation [1]. Venezuela owes $15.8bn in debt payments in 2016, has less than $1bn of cash, and holds most of the rest of its reserves in gold [2]. Between 2011 and 2013, fuel subsidies cost Venezuela 7.1% of their GDP on a pre-tax basis [3]. (Note that this "measure of subsidies constitutes a lower bound, as it does not include forgone tax revenues or the cost of negative externalities".) This costs its government more than $1.7 billion a year [4]. Similarly, when one can buy a dollar for 6.3 bolivars from the government and sell it for 500 to 1 000 on the market, it should not be surprising that dollars are seldom to be found. This places an implicit but extreme tax on imports, creating shortages. Curiously for the socialist republic, this tax is levied by private interests as access to dollars at the official rate is rationed to the regime's friend. This was one way Chavez controlled the army. It is also why reducing the market-to-official gap of 100x is so difficult. [1] http://www.reuters.com/article/us-venezuela-economy-idUSKBN0UL27820160107 http://www.reuters.com/article/us-venezuela-economy-idUSKBN0... [2] http://money.cnn.com/2015/10/29/news/economy/venezuela-selling-gold/ http://money.cnn.com/2015/10/29/news/economy/venezuela-selli... [3] https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/wp1530.pdf https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2015/wp1530.pdf [4] https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.abc.es%2Finternacional%2F20130515%2Fabci-venezuela-gasolina-201305142039.html&edit-text=&act=url https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&pr...
- cubano 11y agoMaduro is an idiot, and his crony socialism is destroying a once-great and proud country. None of these stop-gap measures are going to save things down there, and while Maduro and his fellow party leaders will ride off into the sunset as billionaires (if his people don't kill him first), the poor Venezuelian people will suffer for many years to come.
- spikels 11y ago"suffer for many years to come" Unfortunately it will probably take decades to bring the Venezuelan economy back to a normal. Almost every local industry is in shambles and foreign investors will need at least a decade to resolve all the claims from past nationalizations and settle all the debts. Perhaps the worst economic problem is that any entrepreneurial spirit in the country has been crushed. For more than a decade the way to get ahead was to manipulate the system or leave. Lastly the political institutions are completely broken. Another charismatic strongman could come along or the military could simply take over. None of this is a quick fix. Things can - and probably will - get worse for years before they get better. An analogy: If a well functioning economy is like a rain forest with thousands of interacting systems and species in a complex dynamic equilibrium, Venezuela is crappy zoo with most of the animals sick or gone, incompetent and cruel zookeepers and no money for feed.
- pluma 11y agoWorded differently: fuel is no longer practically free in Venezuela.
- rtkwe 11y agoCloser to: fuel is slightly less practically free in Venezuela, but still unbelievably cheap.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoIt's not quite so "unbelievably cheap" when the minimum wage is $13/month. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-10-16/venezuela-raises-minimum-wage-30-it-s-still-only-13-a-month http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-10-16/venezuela-... The minimum wage in the U.S. is somewhere around $1,200/month, so a rough comparison (gallon of gas as proportion of income) might be if gas cost $10.00/gallon here.
- flubert 11y agoAnyone know more about Cuba's $20 a month maximum wage? https://www.google.com/search?q=cuba+maximum+wage https://www.google.com/search?q=cuba+maximum+wage
- neves 11y agoWhen I went to Venezuela years ago, gas was cheaper than water. Now at least they will have desincentives to use their cars. That's good for the environment.
- rafaelm 11y agoJust to put things in perspective, filling up a gas tank here is still cheaper than buying a two liter coke bottle. 30 liters of gas will cost Bs. 30 or Bs. 180 depending on the type you use. A 2 liter coke costs Bs.500. A McDonalds meal costs around Bs.1000 (Add Bs. 500 if you want fries fries. Fries are imported for some reason. I might be off on the price, I haven't been there in a while.) And this will not stop the smuggling of gasoline to Colombia and Brazil, since the price differential is still so big. It reduces profits a bit, but it's still worth it for those that can do it (mostly military mafias that control the border). EDIT: just to expand a bit on the subject, the price has been fixed since 1996 I think. The govt subsidies on gas are ridiculous. The country was losing around US$12500 million a year through the subsidy. Add to that, Chavez started PetroCaribe as a way to "sell" cheap oil to caribbean nations (in exchange for loyalty) that was never paid , or paid with beans,etc. Now that the oil prices are so low, we have no income.Most of the money that came in to the country was stolen by govt officials (composed mostly of military men) and we have a huge debt obligations and low international reserves. Now it's time to tighten our belts. Lines to buy food are enormous. You can only buy certain things twice a week if you can find them (according to the last number of your national ID). Medicines are dissapearing. Maduro is looking everywhere he can to find some money, but there's not much he can do really.
- JumpCrisscross 11y ago> the country was losing around US$12.50 million a year through the subsidy Try $1.7 billion as of 2013 [1]. [1] https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.abc.es%2Finternacional%2F20130515%2Fabci-venezuela-gasolina-201305142039.html&edit-text=&act=url https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&pr...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rafaelm 11y agoYeah , I realized I missed a zero there! Edited. This Forbes[1] article has even worse numbers. Filling up the tank here is something people don't think about. People even tip the gas pump attendant two or three times the cost of the full tank (that's obviously over now). The reason we are angry is not because we now have to pay a very low price for gas. The reason is that this country had a huge bonanza and it was all stolen and now the govt says its because of the "economic war" the US and allies are waging against Venezuela. Apparently, the fact that the US is extracting shale oil is all just a plan to topple Putin and Maduro. And now that OPEC wants to break the shale oil companies is another evil plan. It's everyone elses fault that after 18 years of the highest income we've ever had, we now have no money for the rainy days. [1]http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2015/01/26/that-venezuelan-economic-experiment-gasoline-isnt-just-cheap-its-free/#73ba1f193c41 http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2015/01/26/that-vene...
- mangeletti 11y agoThis is a very sensational title, and I'm sick of media companies exploiting: 1) the natural tendency for people to read "by X,XXX%" as "X,XXX times" and 2) the fact that raising something from nearly 0 to anything that's not nearly zero will naturally be a large percentage increase, even if it is a small absolute increase Guardian, here's a better, albeit, less apocalyptic and click-bait title: Venezuela raised gasoline prices from nearly free ($0.02) to about 1/12th of what the rest of the world pays ($0.20), because government oil revenue is down.
- gruez 11y ago>1) the natural tendency for people to read "by X,XXX%" as "X,XXX times" Is that actually a thing? I understood it just fine.
- Vraxx 11y agoEven if it's not to that extent, the bigger number leaves a bigger impression without giving it much thought, even in a relatively trained mind. Once you parse that it says percent, sure, you can deduce that it's describing it proportionally and infer that the price was probably pretty low to begin with, but why do we need to have titles that require this to get the gist of it when we could describe it in a more clear manner from the beginning? edit: changed punctuation mark.
- CydeWeys 11y ago> The official exchange rate used for food and medicine imports will weaken to 10 bolivars per dollar from 6.3, as of Thursday, while a second rate will be allowed to float. How can you have multiple exchange rates on the same currency? That makes no sense. And seems like it would lead to rampant cheating, e.g. shipments of food not being classified as such, or vice-versa, whichever is advantageous at a given time.
- rafaelm 11y agoThat's precisely the problem. The govt decides who gets dollars at rate #1 (Bs.10/$) and who gets the other rates. Of course, only govt officials and friends get rate #1. They establish a company in say, Panama. Their venezuelan company imports food from Panama at rate#1. They claim they imported 1 ton of food, for example, while they only actually bring in half a ton. Or they buy the food at a certain price and they overbill the govt. Expand that to every facet of an economy where EVERYTHING is imported: food, medicine, appliances, cars, tires,etc. The black market rate is at Bs.1000 per dollar. That's a Bs.990 difference. It's practically a money printing machine! Buy dollars at Bs.10, sell them at Bs.1000, restart the process. Over and over until there's no money left, which is our current situation.
- sremani 11y agoBut who is selling the government USD for 10 Bolivars? I guess they are swindling from foreign investors trying to do business in VZ.
- CydeWeys 11y agoNo one is lending them money anymore. They're swindling from their own citizens now, some of whom have incoming USD from out of country.
- slv77 11y agoThe government nationalized their oil companies which, even at these prices, is still a reliable source of USD that is converted to Bolivars at the official exchange rates of 6.3 to 1. Importers could then bid for these dollars at different exchange rates to buy medicines and raw materials. As long as US companies like Kimberly Clark, Clorox, PepsiCo, Goodyear and airlines had access to import raw materials at the official exchange rates they could, on paper, be profitable but couldn't expatriate any earnings. They were also motivated by the threat of nationalization. Recently many of these companies have started to write off these earnings by marking down bolivar holding and writing down assets.
- edpichler 11y agoPoor Venezuelans! I hope your corrupt and dictatorial government shall fall, like happened with Argentina.
- kolme 11y agoNot sure if you're being ironic, but the "dictatorial" government of Maduro already lost the election. So it already fell.
- edpichler 11y agoI am not being ironic, no. I just want the best for our neighbors.
- rafaelm 11y agoThat was just the election for the National Assembly, which is our congress. But now that the government lost control of the Assembly, they decided that everything that they decide must be approved by the Supreme Court. Guess who controls the Supreme Court? Guess who removed and appointed members of the PSUV (govt party) to the Constitutional area of the Supreme Court in December, right after losing the Assembly elections? One clue: it wasn't the opposition. Not very democratic is it?
- ptaipale 11y agoIt lost an election, but has entrenched its influence by selecting civil servants and doing other things to keep power. As Wikipedia puts it: A little over a week after the elections on 15 December 2015, the outgoing National Assembly created the "National Communal Parliament" with President Maduro stating "I'm going to give all the power to the communal parliament ... This parliament is going to be a legislative mechanism from the grassroots. All power to the Communal parliament".[67] The move was described as an attempt "to sideline and leapfrog the incoming opposition-controlled National Assembly" and that such actions could possibly lead to more destability and polarization in Venezuela for the future.[68]
- rafaelm 11y ago
- edpichler 11y agoPeople, forget about the gas being cheap on Venezuela even still after this arise. That country is with serious problems for years. For instance, citizens need to be on slow and humiliating lines to buy food, that is limited by government. Recently, government also said that the prices of milk increased because people are drinking it too much.
- MCRed 11y agoFor those olde enough to remember, this is very much what things were like in the USSR. I remember not 10 years ago a liberal friend of mine (With a Masters in economics!) supporting Chavez and complaining about Obama not supporting Venezuela. This is not a liberal paradise.
- edpichler 11y agoAre you following the tidings and the changes happening fast on Argentina? It's amazing.
- ativzzz 11y agoDo you have a link to an article?
- edpichler 11y agoI have this text, that could give you an idea, but just in Portuguese, sorry: - http://bit.ly/macript http://bit.ly/macript and - https://twitter.com/bradpickler/status/700363764261130241 https://twitter.com/bradpickler/status/700363764261130241
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y ago> Recently, government also said that the prices of milk increased because people are drinking it too much. Isn't that literally how supply-and-demand is supposed to work.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mixmastamyk 11y agoThe cheap gas in Vz sounds great but has many horrible effects. In Brazil you'll zoom about in clean, small alcohol-compatible cars. But in Caracas, people are driving around in 1980 Chevy Impalas spewing thick black smoke. They only recently stopped producing leaded gas. I was reacquainted with the "black boogers" I had not experienced since a trip to India in the 90's. It's disgusting really, and a shame for country that should have so much going for it.
- rconti 11y ago> But even with the rises, Venezuela’s petrol will still be the cheapest in the world, allowing Venezuelan’s to fill their tanks with high-octane gasoline for the equivalent of the price of three beers. Whose idea was it to compare gasoline prices (heavily subsidized or taxed, depending on regime) to beer prices (heavily taxed, depending on regime)? Big Macs are a much better indicator of PPP.