5 ms·
The PyPi download statistics are constantly being quoted as though the are some exact representation of the state of Python 3 takeup. I'm calling this as bulls
by andrewstuart 11y ago
The PyPi download statistics are constantly being quoted as though the are some exact representation of the state of Python 3 takeup.
I'm calling this as bullshit.
How much of these downloads are computers auto updating their configurations?
How, exactly, do these stats reflect the number of people developing current projects with Python 3?
The number of legacy projects written in Python 2 will be vastly higher than the number of Python3 projects currently in development. Maybe that's what is being updated.
When a statistician does an analysis of what these numbers really mean I will believe them but until then the numbers mean precisely nothing. Or more accurately, they seem to mean exactly what the Python 2 diehards want them to believe.
My assertion is that Python 3 is very actively and healthy and the PyPi stats are just lies, damn lies and statistics.
- creshal 11y agoI get my python 2 and 3 dependencies from distribution packages (Arch, Debian), and so do all people using my software. PyPi impact: Zero.
- hynek 11y agoHmm I’m not sure how to take this comment. The main point of the article is basically that those numbers don’t tell the whole story (even explicitly in footnote 1).
- andrewstuart 11y agoYour post gives the stats some level of credit when really they tell absolutely nothing, or more precisely they tell a tale that is so open to interpretation as to mean nothing at all. There's no gloom around Python 3. Lots of people support it. The highest ever upvoted post on Reddit/r/Python was a post asking to remove training material that asserts that Python 3 is irrelevant. https://www.reddit.com/r/Python/top/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Python/top/ There must be alot of people who feel positively about Python 3 to vote it up that high, presumably at the same time that the Python 2 diehards are voting the post down. The appropriate message regarding the PyPi stats is not to give gentle credence to them but to condemn them as a completely irrelevant measure of the success or otherwise of Python 3.
- DasIch 11y agoSomehow Python 3 projects don't require updates? PyPI stats are going to be massively inflated due to Continous Integration and such but I don't see why that would tip the scales in one direction or the other by any significant amount.
- hynek 11y agoThe newer a pip, the more likely it is that it caches things for example. There a more things, I had long discussions with dstufft about it in the past.