5 ms·
And Google intends to compete with that using something with higher cost? The UK already has at least one mass-market grocery delivery company that is profit
by michaelt 11y ago
And Google intends to compete with that using
something with higher cost?
The UK already has at least one mass-market grocery delivery company that is profitable (albeit barely - a pre-tax profit of £11.9m on sales of £1,202.9m).
The CEO, Tim Steiner, believes in the long term they can be more efficient than bricks-and-mortar retailers by having a few large, automated warehouses fulfilling orders for the entire country. This leads to better power efficiency (no need for things like open-front refrigerators retailers need) and reduced waste (trying to keep an item in stock in 3 warehouses results in less over- and under-ordering than trying to keep the same item in stock in 300 walk-in stores).
There's a £40 minimum order, and a delivery charge (£0-£5 depending on time of day and day of week), but groceries themselves are price-matched to a major bricks-and-mortar retailer.
Of course, to get great prices from suppliers you need a large enough market share to get economies of scale / negotiating leverage. And to get that market share you need reasonable prices. Mark up the items a lot or charge too much for delivery and you'll always be a niche competitor getting poor prices from your suppliers.
(Disclosure: I work for them. And we're hiring! If you're near north London, or in Barcelona, check out https://careers.ocado.com/Search.aspx https://careers.ocado.com/Search.aspx )
- toomanybeersies 11y agoIt certainly does make sense if you're looking at places with expensive property, like London. A supermarket takes up a huge area, and usually in areas where land tends to be expensive. Nobody wants to go to a supermarket in the middle of nowhere. I think that's where online supermarkets are going to win out over conventional supermarkets. Personally, I prefer to go to supermarkets than shop online, even if it was cheaper, I'd still probably go to the supermarket, but that's usually because I decide what I want to cook for tea on the way home from work, so I'll stop by the supermarket and grab some stuff, I enjoy the experience.
- tfgg 11y ago> A supermarket takes up a huge area, and usually in areas where land tends to be expensive I think this is a particularly good point about their success, especially in London. In London, there aren't really many huge supermarkets (the closest one to me is about 5km away through dense built-up areas), and most people don't own cars. Hence, if you want to do a big shop, online delivery is pretty much the only way.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- SideburnsOfDoom 11y agoYep. even when I pass by a big supermarket (it is on my way home near the tube station), bulky items and lots of items are difficult when travelling on foot & crowded bus.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThat's an interesting counterpoint. I haven't investigated how successful companies are in U.S. if specializing only in those areas. However, they have to have economy of scale to get low prices on stuff people want. Or buy from groups like Costco as Google is with further markup. So, there's potential there but a lot of risk, too. Need more data on such things.
- simonbyrne 11y agoUK is a very different situation: online grocery shopping is very well established and very competitive, with most major supermarket chains offering delivery and supposedly 3 in 10 people buying their groceries online [1]. [1]: http://www.foodmanufacture.co.uk/Business-News/UK-is-biggest-online-grocery-market-after-China http://www.foodmanufacture.co.uk/Business-News/UK-is-biggest...
- puranjay 11y agoI don't know if this is a factor, but isn't parking a big problem in big UK cities? If you wanted to make a grocery store run, you'd have to fret about parking and traffic. Most American cities don't really have this problem
- infinite8s 11y agoCorrection - most American suburbs don't have this problem. Grocery stores in most major American metropolises (NYC, SF, Boston, DC) can't afford the real estate for parking lots.
- massysett 11y agoMost Americans do not live in cities anything like NYC, SF, Boston, or DC. Even in DC, the District of Columbia is is a relatively small jurisdiction of (generously) 700,000 people in a region of over 5 million. Even District grocery stores generally have on-site parking--perhaps over or under the store--and it is often free. So, no correction is in order and it is perfectly accurate to say "Most American cities don't really have this problem."
- cnorthwood 11y agoMost UK supermarkets have large out-of-town retail parks for exactly this reason - although the public appetite for this is declining.
- noir_lord 11y agoUsed to buy mine online but I got so sick of dealing with the websites (Tesco was by far the worst, ASDA a close second) I went back to doing a weekly shop and grabbing a taxi to get home. Now since I work in town I use the local market for all the fresh stuff (meat, fish, veg) and a variety of smaller shops for household supplies, it's actually cheaper (less waste since I mostly buy on the day of use and the market is way cheaper for most stuff than supermarkets with better quality).
- mbesto 11y ago> The UK already has at least one mass-market grocery delivery company that is profitable (albeit barely - a pre-tax profit of £11.9m on sales of £1,202.9m). I just checked Pitchbook and in 2014 Ocado has a ~3% EBITDA margin. This is hysterically low for a "technology" company.[0] For reference, Alphabet operates at ~30% EBITDA margin. The problem with food delivery profits is that they are hysterically thin and underpin last-mile problems (specifically in the US where population density is much lower than UK/EU). Side note - Why the heck are PE ratios so high on the LSE? Ocado is trading at over 220x earnings...
- Dwolb 11y agoIt's not that low... Amazon appears to do about 7B in EBITDA on about 100B revenue. I'd bet AWS is propping that up a bit with its really high margins. If you compare them to another grocer (which they kind of are), their numbers seem more reasonable - the industry profit margins are typically single digits.
- mbesto 11y agoThe point is that all retail is super low margin (in this case < 10%) which is made up for in volume. For Google the only incentive is to go towards a volume play because the margins will _never_ be great. The OP's point stands - this seems odd that Google would go after such a low-margin area, considering almost everything else they do has super high margins (30%+). The challenge in the US is that volume is hard to get because of last-mile economic restrictions.
- Dwolb 11y agoAh good point. I missed he was saying it was low from Alphabet's perspective. Personally I believe it's a play to keep Google's search intact - as more people go straight to Amazon to find products, it could move people away from using Google first for everything (meaning fewer searches and less effective paid ads).
- noir_lord 11y agoIf google cracks self driving vehicles then the margin would likely increase quite a bit by not paying drivers, if they applied similar technology to automate as much of the process at every part they likely could increase the margin again. I've worked for large retailers (Staples in this instance) and they are not remotely efficiently run, bad warehouse management, bad stock management (old dated broken software), incredible lack of intelligence on stock ordering etc. A company with the programming ability to manipulate data the way Google does could get a decent headstart on the competition in the short term (eventually others will catch up but that's the way the game is played in retail). Hell throw in viable electric vehicles for the deliveries and you could eliminate driver costs and 2/3 of your fuel costs, that'd be a hell of a saving. You'd also be able to offer a faster turn around time (multiple small vehicles vs multiple orders on a single van). Throw in some nice UX stuff, real time alerts when you delivery is on the way drawn on a nice google map rather than "It'll arrive between 7-9" which means anywhere from 6:30 to 10pm in my experience and I'd sign up.
- Retric 11y ago1% margin is actually fairly healthy in that industry.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThe good ones are all 2-5%. Anything below that is underperforming, a no-frills shop (eg dollar store), or trying to crush competition with a growth strategy. In any case, talking to people that work at most of them show they barely function if they're near 2%. We must also note that this is the final profit. That's after executives, shareholders, employees, real estate, etc have been paid. The markup over the price of goods is still often around 30-50% to cover above costs. So, there's plenty of potential for competitiveness by eliminating some of that. Branding, variety, psychological manipulation, and cost due to volume deals give advantages hard to beat. The big players also tend to acquire any company that is in the process of doing that, too.
- Retric 11y ago"According to a paper published by the CDFI Fund, the average profit margin for the supermarket industry was 1.9 percent in 2010. The profit margin varies by sub-classification. According to analysis of Yahoo! Finance data, the average net profit margin for publicly traded US-based grocery stores for 2012 is close to 2010's 1.9 percent average. Sagework's research shows that privately owned grocers had average profit margins of 2 percent in 2010 and only 1 percent in 2011." http://yourbusiness.azcentral.com/profit-margin-supermarket-17711.html http://yourbusiness.azcentral.com/profit-margin-supermarket-... Upmarket you can get ~3.5 to 6 percent which helps boost the average to 1.9, but for bulk goods 1% is not actually bad. PS: Natural and organic food markets have some of the highest profit margins. For example, in 2012 Whole Food's net profit margin was 3.79 percent and Fresh Market's was 5.58 percent. Traditional grocery stores have net profit margins ranging from 1.96 percent for Harris Teeter and 1.91 percent for Kroger's to 1.77 percent for Safeway.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoKey phrase: " the average net profit margin" The abuse of statistics is rampant. An average tells you either what the middle player makes or is only used to identify trends. The average means nothing for individual players. An average of 1.9 might mean one company makes about nothing with many making 2-3% or a bunch of companies around 1.9. Btw, Kroger is one using an aggressive growth strategy to undercut competition. Their stores stay having empty shelves around ehre. They own Harris Teeter, too. Safeway went bankrupt at that rate. So, what are these numbers proving again? ;)