4 ms·
America's 250th DNA exoneration: How often is wrong person sent to prison?
- asolove 17y agoI always wonder about this and chimera. Anyone know of cases where the right person was set free? http://www.thetech.org/genetics/ask.php?id=23 http://www.thetech.org/genetics/ask.php?id=23
- ellyagg 17y ago> The certainty of DNA testing means we can be positive the 250 cases listed in the Innocence Project report didn't commit the crimes for which they were convicted This is simply not true. Matching DNA against the defendant is basically 100%, but that doesn't take into account the circumstances of the case and where that DNA fits into the evidentiary chain. All the DNA has to do is provide reasonable doubt. It does not prove innocence. Indeed, contrary to the claim, it is virtually certain that some of the convicted in the overturned cases did commit their crimes. Because of the political will behind resurrected DNA cases, the circumstantial link doesn't need to be very strong to have a case overturned via DNA.
- barrkel 17y agoAnd of course, there is always Bayes to take into account. If a jury hears that there's only a "one in a million" chance that a DNA match would happen randomly, they may overweigh this fact, when put up against e.g. a city of 3 million people - which, assuming no other evidence and that the criminal is known to be from the city, would make the chance of this guy being the guilty party only 1 in 3.
- Estragon 17y agoThat reasoning would only hold if you surveyed the DNA of everyone in that city, which is never the case.
- barrkel 17y agoNo, you don't need to survey everyone in the city. Assume you instituted a DNA search, whereby you went from district to district and tested DNA until you got a match, the chance would still be only 1 in three, under the same assumptions. And government policy here in the UK seems to be to retain the DNA of everyone that comes into contact with the state, so I expect it's only a matter of time until there will be chance collisions resulting in incorrect convictions.
- Estragon 17y agoOK, it only applies if you survey everyone in the city until you get a match. Same difference. Yes, things may be heading in that direction. That was not the original argument, though.
- eru 17y agoAnd if the DNA was every hint you had.
- btipling 17y agoIsn't it true that using Bayesian inference one should conclude that given a positive DNA match that it is more likely you have a false positive than an actual match? That isn't there are greater likelihood that there was a mistake in the DNA testing result than you actually find a match? :/
- gjm11 17y agoIf the person who was tested was chosen at random from the population, then yes. But -- and this is an important point that somehow almost gets omitted when the usual examples of DNA evidence, medical tests, etc., are brought up -- when you're testing someone's DNA against samples from a crime scene, or testing whether a person has a rare disease, it's almost always because you already have evidence that brings Pr(they did it) or Pr(they have the disease) way above the baseline level. And in that case Pr(they did it | DNA evidence), or Pr(they have the disease | test result), may well be quite large. (Of course that's not true if the person with matching DNA was found by some kind of search of a Vast DNA Database, or if the positive result on the medical test was the result of a mass screening exercise that tests everybody.)
- barrkel 17y ago> Most prosecutors fight requests for post-conviction DNA testing. Knowing human nature, this is understandable - there's a tendency to think that once a "fight" has been won, it should stay won. But it's also disturbing: does this tendency cause people to actively want to imprison innocent people? I've read of similar cases, where prisoners due to be executed have last-minute appeals due to new evidence / etc., but state governors press ahead with the execution so that they can politically appear to be "tough on crime". The problem being that the appearance of being tough on crime seems to come from killing someone, rather than actually ensuring justice is done.
- sliverstorm 17y ago> Knowing human nature, this is understandable - there's a tendency to think that once a "fight" has been won, it should stay won. But it's also disturbing: does this tendency cause people to actively want to imprison innocent people? It's not that they want to imprison innocents; it's a prosecutor's job to get the defendant convicted no matter what, whether or not they personally believe the defendant is guilty. They are simply acting as their job calls for (the conflicting prosecution and defense attorneys in theory bringing about the truth), because until now you could never be 100% sure. '100% sure' and 'our legal system' do not go well together. P.S. Don't invoke the argument over the ethically wrong claiming 'oh I was just doing my job'- this is different; we WANT the prosecutor to behave like that, even if he feels or even knows the defendant is innocent. It's what (in theory anyway) makes the system work.
- donaldc 17y agoIt's not that they want to imprison innocents; it's a prosecutor's job to get the defendant convicted no matter what, whether or not they personally believe the defendant is guilty. I think that in some cases, they want to imprison someone, and show that they are doing their job, even if they have serious doubts about the guilt of the person they are imprisoning. In any case, refusing to allow DNA testing that can categorically establish the guilt or innocence of someone seems to me to be unethical.
- 17y ago
- indiejade 17y agoAccording to a new report by the Innocence Project, those 250 prisoners served 3,160 years between them; 17 spent time on death row. Remarkably, 67 percent of them were convicted after 2000—a decade after the onset of modern DNA testing. My guess: more often than not, it's simply an issue of legal politics. Investigators or prosecutors have pressure put on them to lock up somebody . . . anybody as a means to close a case or re-direct media attention. Getting the actual culprit almost seems to be of secondary importance. Loose killers/rapists demand much more media attention than those who've been put behind bars, and having such people on the loose means that people might portray their local law enforcement officials as "not doing their jobs". @asolove: Well, there's that Florida man who was exonerated after 35 years in prison, thanks to DNA evidence: http://crimesandjustice.com/james-bain-freed-35yrs-prison-innocent-man http://crimesandjustice.com/james-bain-freed-35yrs-prison-in...
- khafra 17y agoAlso, by all accounts I've read, forensic science isn't exactly held to scientific standards--they use so many tests that have never been experimentally evaluated, it could more accurately be called forensic folklore. Since judges and lawyers are seldom clueful about the natural sciences, often very strong evidence is ignored in favor of the word of an "expert."
- eru 17y agoOr witnesses.
- cjbos 17y agoI'm taking the intro to Criminal Justice course this semester at my local community college at night, I've had 2 classes so far, so take this with a grain of salt. But in our last class we were told that the majority of wrongful convictions have been due to incorrect eye witness identification. Whether this was due to a actual mistake on behalf of the witness, or due to mistakes in how the photo selection or lineup was conducted by the law enforcement officer.
- rauljara 17y agoThis article details not only the wrongful conviction, but wrongful execution of a Texan man accused of arson. It's a little long, but worth the read, as it really puts a human face on what a wrongful conviction can mean for someone. http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/09/07/090907fa_fact_grann?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/09/07/090907fa_fact_...
- tomjen2 17y agoFar too often, but it could be prevented by requiring that conviction can only happen if DNA evidence tides the subject to the scene.
- natrius 17y agoIn Texas' next execution, the state is refusing to allow the remaining evidence to be DNA tested. You'd think we'd want to be as certain as possible that innocent people aren't getting executed... http://www.texastribune.org/stories/2010/jan/28/dead-man-balking/ http://www.texastribune.org/stories/2010/jan/28/dead-man-bal...
- bediger 17y agoI believe you should be careful about pronouns. The "we" in "we'd want" must mean "the people of Texas", and when considered like that, isn't true. Polls show Texans overwhelmingly in favor of the death penalty, even when we (as in all of the US citizens) know that panalty is applied very unequally along racial and economic class lines.
- natrius 17y agoTexans favor the death penalty, but I sincerely doubt that they favor executing innocent people. They may not want this guy to get any more chances to prove his innocence, but that would be due to broken logic, not the desire to execute innocents.
- nfnaaron 17y agoConvicted in 1976. My entire adult life, buried under a prison wall. So many kinds of people I've been, lives I've lead, so many people I've known, things I've done.
- otakucode 17y agoThe one fact you will never hear when DNA results are being discussed: 1 out of every 100 DNA tests are bungled by the testing lab. Either through mistake, contamination of samples, whatever. So that "1 in X billion" odds they toss around should be viewed with that fact in mind. Oh, and you're not allowed to mention it in court. Ever. They're too afraid the jury will get confused. (The book "Drunkard's Walk: How Randomness Rules Our Lives" contains all the details.)