4 ms·
European Debt Worries: Why Greece Matters
- alexandros 17y agoJust to make a factual correction, Greece has not 7, but close to 11m population. I expect the economist to get these things right.
- yungchin 17y agoWell, in their defence, they're quoting an external source verbatim (of course, a footnote pointing out the error would have still been nice).
- eru 17y agoI just checked if it could have been the size of the workforce. But that's seems closer to 4M. (Using http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Greece#Maritime_industry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Greece#Maritime_indu... as a source.)
- proemeth 17y agoEurope (with ECB's support if necessary) won't let Greece default.
- gaius 17y agoCan you say moral hazard much? The EU really doesn't need to set a precedent for the mismanaged economies of the south dumping their debt on the strong economies of the north.
- cabalamat 17y agoI'm sure the ECB have that uppermost in their minds. OTOH, I'm sure many Greek politicians would like the Germasn and French to pay their debts.
- eru 17y agoThat's forbidden by the EU treaties (probably Maastricht treaty, or so). The IMF could help. But it would be humiliating.
- yungchin 17y agoThat's nice rhetoric, but the fact is that there's no us and them, there's only us. We've had a monetary union for about a decade now - we opted-in on sharing each others pains. Krugman thinks the euro was a bad idea to begin with, you might find that interesting to read: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/05/the-spanish-tragedy/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/05/the-spanish-trag...
- gaius 17y agoTrue, but the Greeks opted in on fiscal discipline too... Oh, wait.
- euroclydon 17y agoSo banks everywhere are sitting on a bunch of assets that scare the hell out of them, or have the potential to scare the hell out of them; they don't feel the assets have enough intrinsic value, without the guarantee of some government or central bank backing them up. If that government or central bank doesn't come through, then these banks will all race to dump these assets. I'd like to see an article sort through one of these jittery bank's assets and place them into the two categories: 1) scares_the_hell_out_of_me, and 2) I_feel_pretty_good_about_this. I wonder if we'd find the scary ones are strip malls in underpopulated areas, MLM schemes, sub-prime mortgage debt, and that the good ones are core manufacturing, agriculture, minerals, etc. If so, what's wrong with the banks dumping the crap?
- loganfrederick 17y agoThe problem is that most of these assets, on an individual level, are small enough to not have to be explicitly disclosed publicly, making such an analysis near impossible for an outsider.
- dean 17y ago"The real damage [from the collapse of Lehman Brothers] was the message the failure sent--that the government might not do everything it could to prevent struggling firms from failing chaotically." Does this mean the capital markets knowingly take extraordinary risks fully expecting a government bailout if they fail badly enough, but pocketing the profits if luck goes their way? Are the ultimate free market advocates on Wall Street secretly non-believers in free markets?
- jerf 17y agoThere's nothing "secret" about it. Large players don't like free markets, because they have the resources to capture government regulators and jump over hoops that lesser competition can't, thus preventing the lesser competition from ever being formed. An intrinsic part of getting the benefits of free markets is to make sure you don't end up with single companies that are too large. Beware the "socialism" that is just a cover for consolidating entire industries into one company.
- turkishrevenge 17y agoAs it stands, only an entity as large and powerful as the government is capable of busting up said combines, cartels, and monopolies. My question is this: if officials at all levels of government are working in collusion with big-business, e.g. former finance executives making key decisions about fiscal policy and spending, who does the actual breaking? Those people will never be voted out, as those positions are usually filled by appointments. The irony is the government, as it stands, is the only entity capable of enforcing the "fair-play" necessary for a free market to function. Yet, if I recall, the government is the bane of free markets in the first place.
- jerf 17y agoWhat does the size of the government have to do with breaking up monopolies? Does a multi-billion dollar expenditure on the Department of Education somehow make it easier to break up monopolies? It needs power to break up monopolies, and a certain minimum size to be able to function effectively in this capacity, yes, but performing this function does not require massive staffs of bureaucrats making tons of regulations on every conceivable industry and thus being susceptible to capture in so many places. These two things are totally orthogonal; you can easily have either of "massive regulation" and "monopoly busting actions" without the other. Minimum size for monopoly busting would not be very large; monopolies aren't that tricky to detect.
- patrickgzill 17y agoAgain, the Economist is a tad late to the party, see this thread, started November 22nd, 2009 (from an article in the UK Telegraph): http://goldismoney.info/forums/showthread.php?t=426217 http://goldismoney.info/forums/showthread.php?t=426217