5 ms·
So mixed messages again. Is 'Inbox' the next-gen Gmail interface or a hobby project that will get closed down in a year? Momentum has slowed and I've become so
by andybak 11y ago
So mixed messages again. Is 'Inbox' the next-gen Gmail interface or a hobby project that will get closed down in a year? Momentum has slowed and I've become so dependent on it's workflow I'd be gutted if this was the case. However - I don't believe Google will maintain two email clients in perpetuity.
On past experience - they'll fold the functionality of one into the other - partially and imperfectly leaving users irritated once more.
Still - it's not like I'd be safe from this anywhere else. Products from smaller companies are in constant danger of aquihire shutdowns or similar.
And open-source has still yet to produce UX that's much better than 'parity with the mainstream from a few years ago'.
- collinmanderson 11y agoThe only feature Inbox has that I need in Gmail is "snooze". If they bring that over I will stop needing to use inbox.
- jastanton 11y agoI got a toast notification in gmail that asked me to permanently redirect Gmail to Inbox. I believe that answered the questions for myself what direction that are heading.
- yohui 11y agoOnly if you've already used Inbox, correct? It's just a reminder to existing Inbox users. The reverse is not necessary since anyone using Inbox is already familiar with Gmail and using Inbox on purpose.
- bradstewart 11y agoRemember when Google was toasting away to get everyone to use Hangouts for SMS? A few weeks ago, I got a toast in Hangouts asking me to use their new SMS-only Messenger app. You never know.
- dheera 11y agoCan we kill SMS already? Seriously, what's wrong with e-mail? Everyone has data plans nowadays, if not data-only plans, and e-mail is cross-platform. Stop making me have to carry my phone around. I already have my SMS forwarding to my e-mail automatically, and now I'm just waiting for SMS to die.
- Iburinoc 11y agoI'm not sure about the US but in Canada it's certainly not true that everyone has data plans (in fact as far as I can tell unless you have a company sponsored phone, data plans are in the minority), and SMS remains a cheap communication method that is more or less guaranteed to work.
- aceofspades19 11y agoI live in Canada, and I don't know anyone who lives here that doesn't have a data plan of some kind, although I'm sure they definitely do exist and there are definitely people without a ton of data.
- Iburinoc 11y agoI'm not sure where you are but I find it quite uncommon for university students.
- aceofspades19 11y agoReally? I don't know many university students that don't have the latest smartphone(or at least a fairly recent one) which usually implies they have a data plan of some kind since most of them don't have $800+ to pay outright. But to be fair at my university there are also a lot of students that drive brand new or fairly new cars too and I've parked beside too many Porsches the student parking lot.
- Tepix 11y agoIt's a good idea to have two separate channels. SMS will also work when you're in another country without a data plan. Every phone has SMS. The OTT instant messaging solutions are fragmented (I wish all my contacts had Signal!)
- livingparadox 11y agoIts my understanding that they are trying to merge gmail into the new Inbox.
- Numberwang 11y agoI have the same fears but from the opposite end. I need gmail in my life, and cannot understand why anyone would want Inbox at all. It shows my emails (fewer than in gmail) and combines it with a subpar task manager (in a world of subpar task managers) and wrecks on this "smart" categorization system which is just there for devious purposes and most importantly I cannot trust to do it's job properly. I fear for gmail. I still hurt from google reader being removed. I would have paid £10 a month for google reader had they just asked.
- e40 11y agoMe too, and I'm still stinging from My Tracks being shutdown because it doesn't allow Google to monetize my fitness data (all the apps they recommended in the notice were social/cloud apps). Thankfully, I just the other day found a replacement app (Locus Map Pro). I cannot see myself ever using Inbox. I tried it and I just did not like it.
- derefr 11y agoEmail is a task manager by default; you're kind of forced into it by the fact that people will send you emails that are "actionable" in some way or another. Adding metadata about those emails into some other task-management system would just be redundant. Inbox takes the more sensible approach: presenting the actionable stuff from your inbox as tasks, so you can manage them. Certain emails are tasks either way; Inbox just lets you deal with those using a UX that fits their task-ness. Personally, I think it would make a lot more sense if there was a clearer separation: emails only showing up in Inbox or Gmail, but not both. Any email that Inbox thinks is/was an actionable "task" should be tagged by Inbox's algorithms as such, and this should hide it from Gmail's default views. Then, you scrub your Inbox for what people want of you—and check your Gmail every once in a while to see what's piled up, but otherwise generally don't worry about it. Gmail would then just contain your non-actionable emails: the stuff where seeing it would never give you an anxiety attack. (It'd still let you do bulk operations to all your messages including the actionable ones, though.) I think that "messages AI-sorted into separate bins, and then viewed through separate apps, but all in one email database" is actually quite a flexible architecture, and could be taken even further. For one example: email newsletters are another thing that's discrete from regular email†, and has different viewing needs and associated verbs. You could have a Google Reader-like interface that was really just plucking all the newsletters out of your email and displaying them cleverly. But do note that Gmail would still be there, and still be actively maintained, even if you managed to create fancy abstracted email viewer apps covering the complete gamut of emails people receive. There are many "generic email" tasks that right now only Gmail performs, that Inbox has no plans to add support for: creating filters, adding forwarding accounts, etc. Effectively, Gmail is the "file manager" for your email database, the thing that deals with the unabstracted objects and lets you do maintenance tasks. You can't really throw it away any more than you can throw your file manager away. --- † You know why Google Reader was killed? Because RSS engagement and opt-in and open-rates are much lower than the same metrics concerning email newsletters. Anyone who wanted to make money publishing some regular piece of content cared about these metrics, and so ended up pushing their content as an email newsletter, leaving RSS to be solely the province of amateur personal bloggers. So, more and more, the people with power at Google who cared about consuming content just got it in their email, and generally forgot that RSS was a thing. (There's a whole rant I could go on here about the fact that RSS was intended to be a supplier-side microformat from the start—a way to ease the burden of syndication to encourage custom blogging software to expose syndicated data—and there was never intended to be such things as "RSS Readers", but rather a much more active ecosystem of plumbing—like, for example, gateways to consume and transform feeds into things like emails. Such plumbing was intended to be employed by the website author, in the same way they'd employ e.g. a reverse-proxy like CloudFlare. RSS was meant to be the internal protocol between the blog and such infrastructure software: like FCGI/WSGI is between web servers and application servers. Picture a world before webhooks, where web servers are dumb and you can't expect to be able to "dial out" a server-side request from your app's crappy VPS; picture the architecture you'd use to hook e.g. Mailgun up to your website in this world. That's RSS.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sdrothrock 11y ago> Momentum has slowed Has it really? I get update notifications literally every day, sometimes multiple times a day, so it seems like development is still very, very active. > Is 'Inbox' the next-gen Gmail interface I feel like Inbox and Gmail are separate long-term interfaces working on the same data set that serve completely different sets of users.
- ryanmonroe 11y agoJudging from the fact that Google automatically redirects gmail.com to inbox.google.com once you've visited inbox, I'd guess they view it as the next-gen Gmail interface.
- e40 11y agoThere's an option to stop the redirection. For people that try but do not like the new interface.
- dheera 11y agoInbox still sucks for me because * It doesn't show full messages on Android Wear devices. You know, Google's own product. Gmail does. * I can't figure out how to set up a filter in Inbox. The settings page is incomplete. I still have to go back to Gmail to change settings. So I might as well just use Gmail. * The pins in Inbox don't sync up with the stars in Gmail. Pins, stars, tabs, automatic Gmail categories, automatic Inbox categories, seriously, can we just have one system?
- socket0 11y ago> I can't figure out how to set up a filter in Inbox. > The settings page is incomplete. I'm a huge fan of Inbox, but this still gets me all the time. Inbox was pushed as a kind of advanced application to advanced users, yet I have to go back to Gmail for any kind of advanced settings or configuration. That makes absolutely no sense at all.
- dheera 11y agoYeah, exactly. If Inbox's feature set were complete, I'd probably switch to it. It does have some nice features, including better icons and action buttons for package tracking and such. I just don't want to have to simultaneously deal with 2 websites/apps to access e-mail. If it were still in alpha, i.e. "what do you think of this idea", I would understand that some things are missing and gladly provide my feedback about the concept. But once the concept is verified and being pushed as a kind of "ready for consumer use" beta, it really needs to be complete in features before I would make the switch for real life usage. Especially for a mission-critical product coming from a large company with enough developers.
- krisgenre 11y agoI find Inbox to be good on mobile and Gmail good on desktop browser. Even if they do close the Inbox website, hope they'll let the mobile client stay.
- sangnoir 11y ago> So mixed messages again No mixed messages here, Google has a penchant of making 2 of everything[1], and they can keep at it for years at a time. ChromeOS & Android, Google Maps and Google Earth (and Waze!), and so on. There is cross-pollination of ideas, and some products eventually coalesce. > Is 'Inbox' the next-gen Gmail interface or a hobby project I think the answer is 'neither', just like the iPad wasn't the next-gen MacBook. Inbox is just another email client that is certainly not for everyone, it holds a little too strongly to the inbox zero philosophy to be mainstream. Having both Inbox and Gmail as separate products makes sense because at their core, Inbox and GMail are different beasts, I use both for different contexts. Inbox is great for organizing my personal email, GMail is great for work email. I wouldn't trust Inbox to properly organize my work email, and I don't have the energy to manually organize my personal email. 1. http://arstechnica.com/business/2014/10/googles-product-strategy-make-two-of-everything/ http://arstechnica.com/business/2014/10/googles-product-stra...
- richardboegli 11y agoLook longer term, Inbox will win. Gmail is a mail client, inbox is so much more. I don't use it as the ability to only apply a single label to an email is a feature regression. Chrome and Android will reach feature parity, but will always remain as separate entities due to branding. Running Android on top of Windows just doesn't sound right, but it is what is effectively happening with Chrome supporting Android apps.