3 ms·
I think people are also missing the point when they say "newer iPhones wouldn't be affected by this anyway". I think what's more likely to happen is that in a
by mtgx 11y ago
I think people are also missing the point when they say "newer iPhones wouldn't be affected by this anyway".
I think what's more likely to happen is that in a future case, the FBI will tell the judge that Apple has already complied with such a request before, and now "suddenly" it doesn't want to anymore. Then the judge will probably agree with the FBI that Apple is in the wrong here, and tell Apple "hey, do that thing you did with the previous iPhones, too".
And what that will mean is that Apple will have to make it so the Secure Enclave can be tampered with. That would affect all devices, because Apple would have to cripple every single device like that if it wants to be able to comply with all future orders, and you can also say bye-bye to secure storage of fingerprint data and credit card data on iPhones.
It's all about the precedent here and it's an extremely dangerous one. As Apple said, too, if the FBI succeeds in getting Apple to push malicious updates to their users, who knows what kind of other similar requests will come from the FBI - not just to decrypt local storage, but also to break end-to-end encryption for communications and so on.
FBI's fight is literally a fight against good security.