7 ms·
I would not mind the problem as much if Banks worked like banks of old rather than opinionated service provides. Banks today limit how much cash is withdrawn an
by belorn 11y ago
I would not mind the problem as much if Banks worked like banks of old rather than opinionated service provides. Banks today limit how much cash is withdrawn and for what purpose, and any transaction is added to a permanent record. This record is then turned into precious customer data which can be used for any internal purposes, shared with partners (like insurance providers), and given to several government departments like tax collection, social security, the local police, secret police, national spy agency, foreign police and spy agencies, and so on. The customer has zero control and is barely recognized to be a stake holder at all.
It is possible to create the cashless society without the above problems, but no governments or banks are interested.
- witty_username 11y agoCould you elaborate on how the "banks of old" were better?
- themartorana 11y agoI was the customer, it was my money, they were required to have cash on hand, I made money when my money was loaned, there were no fees, like - NO FEES - and so on...
- forgetsusername 11y ago>there were no fees, like - NO FEES There were also no services. I don't understand the bank hate around here. There are plenty of low/no fee banks. It's a competitive business, and if you're half-way assertive you can get favourable terms on nearly everything they offer. I just received a $100 gift card for sitting down and discussing the potential to be a customer at a major Canadian bank, and I don't do anything but the basics. They want your business.
- tertius 11y ago> I don't understand the bank hate around here. They limit what you can do with your own money. The reason for getting deposits is so that they can loan 10x or 100x (or whatever your country allows) on the deposit and earn interest/fees. That doesn't benefit me, only them. The reason I use a bank is so that I can have "security" and "ease" in transfer/payment. They make a lot more off of me than the utility I describe above.
- fennecfoxen 11y ago> The reason for getting deposits is so that they can loan 10x or 100x They can loan out 90% of your cash, if that's what you mean. (In the US.) They give you both security and liquidity as well as payment processing options. If you think they're overcharging, you could always buy government/corporate bonds yourself (or through bond funds, maybe.)
- logfromblammo 11y agoThe money multiplier is the inverse of the reserve requirement. If the requirement is 10%, the bank loans out 10x the deposit. This is because from each $1 you deposit, the bank keeps $0.10 in reserve, then loans out $0.90 to a debtor account. Of that, they keep $0.09 as reserves, and lend $0.81 out to another debtor account. Of that, they keep $0.081 as reserves.... Get it now? As long as the same dollar is present in the vault, it qualifies as reserves for $10 in electronic circulation.
- fennecfoxen 11y agoYes, I understood to begin with; I did grow up with a PhD economist in the house and read the textbooks in middle school while bored. This description you've just picked is no longer quite as misleading, except I'm not sure what you mean by "electronic circulation" (making loans off deposits long predates electronic record-keeping). Are you trying to impugn the value of the money in question with the adjective in order to facilitate outrage? If not, I still don't understand why the existence of a money multiplier is a reason for Bank Hate as indicated before. It's a trivial property of any system which permits lending.
- saiya-jin 11y agowell to many they need a single, simple enemy they can blame for their failures in life. why not pick banks who rob everybody and steal everything, control whole world and are worse than worst dictators? simple solutions to simple people (almost no pun intended) (and lets face it, some sometime behave badly, and their missteps can be costly to their customers. but if any bank behaved like for example apple or microsoft did in past, they would be shut down immediately by regulators).
- themartorana 11y agoI like being called simple. It's like the jerkiness of insults. And you're right, if banks ever brought the world to financial ruin like Microsoft and Apple did they would be regulated out of existence. But stupid Microsoft and Apple instead got bailouts by the same regulators and continue to exist with even more power than before they did that thing. Unless I'm missing the sarcasm, so tell me if I am.
- jcrawfordor 11y agoIndeed, at least in the US the massive increase in credit union membership has had a huge impact. Virtually all credit union personal accounts are completely fee-free (and many reimburse ATM fees and other perks), and now the commercial banks need to fight for customers. I keep getting offers from Chase and Discover for checking accounts that are fee-free and have silly perks on top ($300 opening bonus and such), and the suspicious part of me wonders if the frequency of these offers has to do with them knowing from my credit card payments that I mostly use a credit union for checking right now.
- theandrewbailey 11y agoIndeed. A lot of big bank behavior is due to their shareholders demanding more profit. When you open an account at a credit union, you literally ARE one of those shareholders. I can't say enough good things about them.
- ancap 11y ago>Indeed. A lot of big bank behavior is due to their shareholders demanding more profit. That seems a bit silly, don't you think? As if when presented with two options the executives are going to choose the less profitable one unless otherwise pressured?
- Alupis 11y ago> I don't understand the bank hate around here. There are plenty of low/no fee banks Just use a Credit Union.
- st3v3r 11y agoThis post is nothing but rose-tinted glasses toward the past.
- belorn 11y agoThey used to be custodian of money deposited in their care. Ownership was clear, as was the role of the bank. At no point could they refuse a withdraw, as doing so would ruin the precious trust they needed in order to be a bank. The few times that trust was lost, we have a historical records of a bank crisis where people rushed to the bank to get back their deposited money. A bank today can just declare a maximum withdraw limit and act as if it is normal operation (most banks in Sweden have today a continuously maximum of $1500 limit per week on cash withdraws).
- jdblair 11y ago"Banks of old" had no insured deposits. Regular financial panics meant that runs on banks meant most depositors sometimes lost all their money. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_banking_crises https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_banking_crises
- jdblair 11y ago"Banks of old" had no insured deposits. Regular financial panics meant that runs on banks meant most depositors sometimes lost all their money. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_banking_crises https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_banking_crises
- vitd 11y ago> most banks in Sweden have today a continuously maximum of $1500 limit per week on cash withdraws Wait, what? Are you seriously saying that if you want to pay cash for a $3,000 notebook computer, you have to make 2 different withdrawals a week apart to do that? How is that workable? What happens when you have an emergency and need more cash than that all at once? I mean, it doesn't come up frequently, but it comes up from time to time. Does writing a large check count? Or only physically withdrawing the money at a teller?
- st3v3r 11y agoNo, it means you go into the bank itself and explain your situation. The limits are to stop someone who steals your bank card from going to an ATM and draining your account.
- jesperhh 11y agoWell if you made a cashless society like that you would just have "digital cash", and then there would be no reason for banning "analog" cash :-) The whole idea about banning cash seems to be to avoid tax avoidance and money laundering, and you can't do that if the goverment & police is not allowed to watch your bank account.
- tertius 11y ago* Tax evasion.