9 ms·
ReactOS 0.4.0 Released
- flz 11y ago10 years since the previous release ... I'd really like to know how many people are actually using ReactOS for another purpose than testing or developing it.
- xenophonf 11y agoDude, this is _Hacker_ News. Who cares? This is cool! Also: Their latest release was 0.3.17 in 2014, with the 0.4.0 release candidates coming out late last year. So it hasn't been 10 years between releases, but around 1.5 years.
- gedrap 11y agoWhile usually I'd agree with your snarky comment, I am genuinely curious about this too. It's not some yetanother.js hacked together in a night but years (decades!) of man hours. What's pushing them and stopping from giving up?
- Sir_Cmpwn 11y agoI've done similar projects myself. The thing that pushes people like us is that it's fun and challenging work! There really doesn't have to be anything else.
- stryan 11y agoI believe the Russian Government has considered/is giving them support so that probably helps. Otherwise, a passion for the project and love of the craft most likely.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIt's almost all a volunteer effort. They get the odd donation from time to time, and they had a crowdfunding campaign, but they really don't get that much money.
- zem 11y agoi think once you get a critical mass of developers, the shared enthusiasm for the project is motivation enough to keep it going.
- ma2rten 11y agoReactOs is still in alpha stage, so I don't think it's ready for everyday use. Also it has not been 10 years since the last release, it has been 10 years since the last mayor release.
- mhd 11y agoI'm quite impressed that they can load graphics drivers now. Those generally seem to be arcane as heck, delving deeply into the internals of not just the applications they support (e.g. games), but the operating system itself. Although I guess this is a more basic level, i.e. not using Nvidia drivers to run 3DMark...
- m45t3r 11y agoAFAIK, Windows has a very defined model for display drivers (WDDM: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Display_Driver_Model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Display_Driver_Model) so it should be a matter of implementing the WDDM specification + bugs.
- creshal 11y agoStable driver APIs (WDDM for graphics, IFS for in-kernel file systems, and others for other areas) are one of the big differences between NT's (micro-)kernel and Linux' (rather monolithic) kernel with no API commitment. Of course, "stable" may vary. Microsoft introduced a new kernel graphics API with every OS after NT4 (XDDM, XPDM, WDDM 1.0, 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 2.0; I wonder which ReactOS uses?) because of how significantly GPU capabilities changed over the years; while Linux changes its APIs more often than that, the changes are usually minimal enough that neither Nvidia nor AMD are complaining significantly about it. (The X¹¹ API, on the other hand…)
- gh02t 11y agoMy understanding is that NT is more of a hybrid kernel than a true microkernel. Is that still true or has it moved more towards a micro kernel in recent years? I remember reading an interesting article about the influence of Mach on NT, but that they ended up having to put a lot of stuff (including the Executive) into kernel space for performance.
- userulluipeste 11y agoIt's hybrid indeed, but far more modular. The driver code is running in kernel mode to avoid costly switching from kernel to user mode and back. This imposed requirements on driver code quality as it is critical for the entire system, but it can be replaced (with another version) as a component. For a monolithic kernel like Linux changing a driver like the one for video card means recompiling the entire thing.
- exizt88 11y agoPlease don't hijack scroll on web pages.
- adam12 11y agoThe scrolling seems fine to me.
- davydka 11y agoThere's something non-standard going on with it for me. It snaps to certain sections at the bottom and I can't swipe to navigate back and forth like I usually do.
- tpaksoy 11y agoexizt88 is correct. I can't swipe to go back a page. And if I swipe up, the page seems to want to continue scrolling at the same speed, it feels different and not fluent.
- cstrahan 11y agoThey're using kinetic/smooth scrolling, which is included in theme they're using from Okler. If you look in the JS, you'll see: Plugin Name: smoothScroll for jQuery. Written by: Okler Themes - (http://www.okler.net) And here's a forum where a customer asks to disable it: http://www.okler.net/forums/topic/disable-scrolling-effect/ http://www.okler.net/forums/topic/disable-scrolling-effect/ Another offender: https://www.astralgameservers.com/ https://www.astralgameservers.com/ Inertial/kinetic scrolling is incredibly frustrating when implemented in JS. On my Mac, sure, if I swipe my fingers and let go, I expect the OS to emulate a free-spinning scroll wheel. But when it's emulated in JS, there's no way for the code to know whether I lifted my fingers, so it defaults to making the page skid around uncontrollably, when I intend to quickly swipe - while keeping my fingers down at the end - to go to a precise offset in the page. It's visually a cute a effect, but I have no idea how anyone thinks that it makes for anything other than an utterly infuriating user experience.
- speeder 11y agoI am using Windows 8, chrome, Microsoft mouse with scrollwheel. The scrolling is absolutely broken, it is jumping around all over the place, and made the page impossible to read.
- coltonv 11y agoSo I've heard the name ReactOS several times on here but never really been drawn in by the posts about it. Can someone explain why they would use it over Windows/their preferred Linux distro? i ask out of curiosity not criticism. it seems like a cool project so I'm wondering it's benefits over existing OSes.
- pavlov 11y agoIt's a binary-compatible Windows clone. If you don't need to run Win32 binaries, you probably don't want ReactOS.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIt's free, it's open-source, it's Windows-like, and it can run Windows applications. It's very lightweight and has a live CD.
- alkonaut 11y agoThose are all good of course, but how long before it is significantly better (faster, more compatible, easier) than e.g. doing the same with Wine? is it already?
- cookiecaper 11y agoIt doesn't do the same thing. ReactOS is a full reimplementation, including the Windows kernel. You can boot your system with it. One of the main goals is to provide for the loading of Windows drivers. ReactOS and WINE share code for userspace to the extent possible.
- alkonaut 11y agoI see. Is the reason it wants to use Windows drivers that it hopes to get better performance in comparison to Wine or VMs?
- 11y ago
- mmastrac 11y agoThe longevity of this project is really impressive. I remember seeing it in the early days of Wine and thinking that it was a monumentally difficult challenge.
- gosukiwi 11y agoVery interesting project. I'll make sure to test it when they release 1.0 :)
- alexandre_m 11y agoAt this pace it'll be your grandchildren that will test it.
- eloisant 11y agoThey're having a heated race with GNU Hurd to be the first on your grandson's desktop!
- wagglycocks 11y agoThey can enjoy the 1.0 version of Dwarf Fortress while they're at it
- AstralStorm 11y agoUnlike GNU Hurd, most of the OS is actually working. Including GUI.
- chris_wot 11y agoExcept it seems to be progressing exponentially, not linearly.
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y ago2116: Year Of The ReactOS Desktop!
- an4rchy 11y agoI came in thinking this was something related to React Native (i.e open source OS for Android etc), but was pleasantly surprised to learn about this new OS, quite an achievement, seeing as they've been going on for 10 years.
- arturhoo 11y agoGenuine question: is there a reason for the downloads to be hosted at source forge?
- userulluipeste 11y agoIt is an old state of things, but the data is not an executable installer (that is usually the problem, as SF has a bad habit of infect them with malware), it's a ISO image. For nightly (trunk) builds ReactOS uses its own servers, so I guess it's about the maximal bandwidth that may be of concern here especially when the new version are released, and SF may address exactly that.
- themodelplumber 11y ago> (that is usually the problem, as SF has a bad habit of infect them with malware) SF is under new ownership as of last week, and they've already removed the most problematic behavior. If you find malware you should let them know, as the new ownership seems much more on the ball.
- flxn 11y agoTwo weeks ago the new owner of SourceForge terminated the controversial "DevShare" program. https://sourceforge.net/blog/sourceforge-acquisition-and-future-plans/ https://sourceforge.net/blog/sourceforge-acquisition-and-fut... So it should be safe again.
- arturhoo 11y agoI wasn't aware of that, thanks for sharing.
- Piskvorrr 11y agoNah. Reputation is hard to build, but eeeeasy to destroy; saying "trust us that you can trust us again" doesn't magically revert it to previous version (at least a suspicion remains of "...until we have another Wonderful Idea at an indeterminate point in the future").
- 11y ago
- mixmastamyk 11y agoAwesome, I'd love an updated (traditional) Windows 2k/XP GUI with windows and linux tools in it. :) Interesting... I appreciate the faithful reproduction, but they've also copied the outright bad designs like the tiny environment variable window in the system control panel I always hated. ;) Noticed they used a source-forge download instead of a torrent. :/
- ConceptJunkie 11y agoYeah, and that tiny environment variable window lasted at least through Windows 7. You would think with 10s of thousands of developers, they could fix these kinds of things.
- zackify 11y agoscroll hijacking....
- pippy 11y agoI've often thought there's a massive market for ReactOS in legacy support. There's so many platforms (ATMs, flight controllers, banking software) that use unsupported windows versions. Many of these platforms would pay an arm and a leg for ongoing support and security updates.
- chris_wot 11y agoActually, I'm curious, but for slightly different reasons. Windows can still technically support other architectures than x86; if ReactOS is truly compatible (which it evidently is!) then I wonder how hard it would be for them to port the HAL layer to things like SPARC.
- slipstream- 11y agouh, Windows does support other architectures than x86: currently, it supports x86, x64, ARM and ARM64. (and as Windows Server 2008 R2 is still supported, the IA64 version is also still suppored)
- chris_wot 11y agoYeah, I know. But it will never support SPARC. Or anything other than the architectures you mention. Windows can still support these other architectures, I'd love to see it happen. ReactOS might be the way that it's made to occur.
- chungy 11y agoDefinitely. Microsoft doesn't see commercial value in supporting, eg, a SPARC version, especially when it won't run existing x86 apps. It'd be a huge lost cost in development just to make one. ReactOS isn't driven by the same market forces. Anybody with enough determination can port it to SPARC and fly away :) Windows NT 4 supported x86, MIPS, PowerPC, and Alpha. All but one were dropped with Windows 2000... and it wasn't until XP that non-x86 returned (initially IA-64, and x86_64 in three more years after initial release).
- 11y ago
- dingdingdang 11y agoCongratulations to the team :). Personally I'm really happy that someone is doing this work.. although I wish they would aim for baking in a per-app-sandbox-environment - in short order user empowerment is going to define successful computing projects (just look at the rise of Qubes OS and I bet this is still in its pre-viral state - if Apple get compromised by gov and are vocal about it then it will educate a generation of users about the importance of storing data safely!)
- ericmuyser 11y agoAlways a little disappointed when I remember ReactOS does not mean React.js OS.
- chris_wot 11y agoReactOS has been around for a lot longer than React.js. However... if there was a React.js OS, then I'd love to see ReactOS run on React.js OS. At that point, I'd love to see this run on ReactOS.
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y ago> ReactOS has been around for a lot longer than React.js. It'll probably still be around long after React.js has faded into obscurity, too ;)
- chris_wot 11y agoI really wish they had pointers to the source commits in their bug tracker. That would be fascinating :-)
- andersonmvd 11y agoThe project is neat, but they should not be proud of "9,000,000+ lines of code And growing!". Less is more. A security audit for example would be very slow already, given the number of lines.
- exadeci 11y agoWindows XP had 45 Millions lines of code, the Linux kernel has 20 Millions lines of code. So it's pretty small. http://www.wikiwand.com/en/Source_lines_of_code#/Example http://www.wikiwand.com/en/Source_lines_of_code#/Example
- eatonphil 11y agoDoes this run internet explorer? This would be interesting for Koreans wanting something easier than Windows but still needing online payments [0]. On a different topic, does this run any IIS software? Does anyone use this to run any servers? [0] http://betanews.com/2015/04/03/south-korea-looking-to-scrap-activex-payment-requirement-bad-news-for-internet-explorer/ http://betanews.com/2015/04/03/south-korea-looking-to-scrap-...
- rchowe 11y agoI wonder if ReactOS could target the same APIs as the upcoming Nano Server [1] in Windows Server 2016. They'd have to make it entirely 64-bit and implement some closed Microsoft protocols like WMI and DISM, but it could be a pretty cool drop-in replacement for any server apps that people decide to target to Nano Server. [1] https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/windowsserver/2015/04/08/microsoft-announces-nano-server-for-modern-apps-and-cloud/ https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/windowsserver/2015/04/08...
- userulluipeste 11y agoOn IRC the developers have mentioned (as wishful thinking) a minimal (i.e. a stripped-down) version, with only kernel, drivers, and a few other small miscellaneous parts over which dedicated applications could run. This would be something for embedded systems and other specialized machines (basically servers) unlike the all-encomprising common version of ReactOS. That having been said, it's important to understand that one of the reasons for nano is... well, OS size, which for a "normal" version got to tens of GBytes! Currently, ReactOS is (and I think that's a lot --) under 200 MB with all its bells and whistles.
- donlzx 11y agoKudos to the ReactOS team. I've tried the 0.3.x release about ten years ago and was a little disappointed. However, after a decade I've got a new perspective to appreciate their work. I've kept several of my used laptops (Toshiba Satellite laptop, IBM Thinkpads, Lenovo Thinkpads, etc.) mainly for commemorative purpose. However, they can still boot and works fine with outdated OS's and extinct software. A potential very good use of them is to open my old archived documents, but I'd rather not to mess with these fragile machines. When I checked my old archives, usually only plain texts and JPEG photos files are fine with current OS's and softwares. Nealy all my old software projects (mostly with Visual C++) no longer compile or run, or missing dependencies (DLLs, component libraries, tools, etc.). Even though I've backup most of the tools I used at that time, most of them would be a huge pain or impossible to reinstall correctly with right system dependencies. Therefore I've come to think that the only meaningful archives are data with executables, i.e, documents with related spec, contemporary software and OS. In this aspect, a good Internet archive methodology should be like this: 1) data; 2) Fully installed and working software packages; 3) Running free OS such as Linux and ReactOS; 4) OS emulator on available hardware such as Virtualbox and KVM. The importance of ReactOS here is that we will have a working OS on modern emulator or hardware for archiving purpose. I'm omitting the hardware platform here, but it should be the other important aspect of archiving our knowledges.