4 ms·
Big banks have horribly dated systems and are bureaucratic to the extreme, but I doubt peer to peer lending will make more than a small dent in the consumer len
by cm2187 11y ago
Big banks have horribly dated systems and are bureaucratic to the extreme, but I doubt peer to peer lending will make more than a small dent in the consumer lending market. For a simple reason: banks can lend that much money that cheaply only thanks to a large, cheap and stable source of funding: bank deposits. And there are two types of deposits: current account and savings account.
Current accounts come with the capacity to make payments, and for that you need to be a bank. So the only way the p2p lenders will access this source of funding is by becoming big bureaucratic and highly regulated banks themselves.
Then you have savings account. It sounds like an investment but it's not. It's really a risk free, lazy investment. If the bank makes a loss on its loans, it is not passed on to the depositors. Even if the bank goes bust, and unless you have a very large deposit, your deposit is insured by the State. People who keep money on savings accounts aren't the type who are looking for risk and high returns.
P2p relies on investors actively investing in these vehicles. I don't see how this will be nowhere as large as the deposit base in a country.
On the wholesale funding market, things are different. Investors are active investors and it is much easier to shortcircuit banks and lend to corporations directly. Initially the banks were arranging the transaction, but I expect the investors to increasingly cut the middle man.
And all these articles miss what makes the biggest barrier to entry to the banking market: regulations. A bank would typically employ dozens of people just to read and follow all the regulations that apply to them. Regulations kill their profitability (they have to operate with 3 times the capital base they had in 2007), but also shields them from competition.
- trgn 11y agoI think the whole point of a savings account is that it's not an investment. Thankfully. Banks don't use deposits when lending out money. They create the loan amount out of thin air. There are regulations as to how much they can do that relative to their assets. Thankfully.
- cm2187 11y agoNo they do lend the proceeds of the deposits. What the economists mean by "creating money" is that people treat deposits as cash, and therefore have the feeling they have cash when they have a positive balance on their bank account, where in reality all they have is an IOY from a bank. But their cash is not in the bank anymore.
- smaddox 11y agoThis is a common misconception. The reality is that banks lend money at interest rates above what the central bank offers them, meaning they can lend as much as they want irrespective of deposits, and then borrow reserves from the central bank at a lower rate.