6 ms·
1: Yes. 2: Yes. 3: No, but they will probably be the ones asked anyway, and then yes, they would be legally required. 4: Apple. 5: What's the question? Is t
by ars 11y ago
1: Yes.
2: Yes.
3: No, but they will probably be the ones asked anyway, and then yes, they would be legally required.
4: Apple.
5: What's the question? Is the question will they be compensated? Then yes.
6: They can't. They don't own their stock. Bad PR is not a good enough reason.
You are treating the court like a mathematical proof and finding edge cases. I used to as well. But courts don't work that way at all - they don't care in the slightest about your proof. They analyze things on a human level, not a mathematical level.
- philip1209 11y agoSpecifically regarding question 5 - how does the burden of proof work? How do statues of limitations apply?
- ars 11y agoThere is no burden of proof. Apple says it's corrupted that's about it. I'm sure the other party will ask for details. If they don't believe Apple they'll explain that to the Judge and he'll go from there, but otherwise no one will demand proof of anything. I don't see how statues of limitations is connected to the question.
- philip1209 11y agore: statue of limitations - if we are talking exponential levels of difficulty to crack vs. exponential increases in computing power (Moore's law) I wonder whether "we won't have the computing power to crack this for X years, so a statute of limitations of (X-1) years to solve this means that we are functionally unable to answer the question within the allotted time" becomes defensible as a reason to call something "impossible", i.e. it's improbable to solve during the statue of limitations
- alcari 11y agoA statute of limitations prevents you from charging someone with a crime once some period of time elapses. It says nothing about how long you have to prove your case in court. That's more likely to run afoul of the right to a speedy trial.
- ars 11y agoStatue of limitations is only until the court date. Once that starts there is no statue of limitations, even if the case takes years. The closest I can think of is a right to a speedy trial, but that has so many exceptions (for example if the person is out on bail) that I couldn't say how a judge would rule in this scenario. Especially if it was the defendant causing the delay by refusing to reveal the password and making the prosecutor get it the hard way. (Not applicable in this case, might be applicable in another.)
- avs733 11y agospecifically in this case, the only non-John Doe defendant I am aware of is dead so those provisions do not apply. The FBI is not doing this for proceedings related evidenciary purposes but instead for investigative purposes. No one has been charged here (from what I know) so the issue of speedy trials is moot while the statue of limitations on the crimes under investigation are likely extremely long if they exist at all.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bitJericho 11y agoThat would be terrible
- trentmb 11y agoWhy?
- tdaltonc 11y agoBecause incompleteness.
- gopalv 11y agoEven ignoring Godel - take the stuff that's been legal in the past & not anymore. Slavery? Restricted Suffrage? Genocide? Witch trials? Heroin? Or stuff that's been illegal before Inter-racial marriage? Hemp? Gay marriage? Due process isn't enough for a legal system to work - the law has to change & revocable Axioms aren't exactly a thing. In fact, my sister goes on and on about Jurisprudence in such discussions - letter of the law and the spirit of it.
- trentmb 11y ago> revocable Axioms aren't exactly a thing Aren't revocable axioms why there are different geometries?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoBecause designing a law that makes sense when interpreted strictly formally is a friendly-AI-equivalent problem, i.e. it requires figuring out what values humans actually care about and then implementing it in a system that can outsmart anyone trying to game it. Failing that, people will get hurt by corner cases in such a law, or suffer abuse from people gaming the system.
- bsbechtel 11y agoThe fact that courts don't have ways to handle edge cases is a huge problem with our case law style legal system.
- harryh 11y agoYou ever get in a fight with someone? You ever get in a fight where it wasn't 100% clear who was right and who was wrong? You were both a little bit right and a little bit wrong? Welcome to the problems our legal system has to deal with. The world isn't a mathematical equation. It's fuzzy. So is our legal system.
- bsbechtel 11y agoI think my comment was misinterpreted. Our legal system is a part of our government, which is a representative democracy. Part of the idea behind a representative democracy is that it is designed to protect the minority from majority mob rule. By definition, edge cases are cases that fall outside of the normal majority. Our legal system is fuzzy because it is operated by humans, not silicon. The design of a case law system however, which the U.S. operates under, is intended to minimize fuzziness by looking at case precedent for guidance on issues moving forward. So in a sense, case law is intended to be the legal equivalent of mathematical proofs in the courtroom. Obviously this analogy isn't 100% correct, but the main reason it can't be is because of the thousands of edge cases that come up in real life...edge cases that are minority cases intended to be protected by representative democracy, but the case law legal system has difficulty actually doing so because of the design of the case law system. See the conflict? Completely lost yet?
- avs733 11y ago>The design of a case law system however, which the U.S. operates under, is intended to minimize fuzziness by looking at case precedent for guidance on issues moving forward. Sorry if this comes out as pedantic but I think it is important. Case law is not intended to minimize fuzziness but to address occurrences of fuzziness.
- 11y ago
- ouiyaaa 11y agoThanks for answering. And original question was great too. Are you a lawyer, not trying to dismiss your answer because it seems logical, but asking so that I can ask something else
- ars 11y agoI am not a lawyer. There was a time when I spent a lot of time reading verdicts from Judges. (The higher the level of Judge the better the writing, and they are really surprisingly very readable, not full of legalese as you might expect.) Anyway, I used to think that law was mathematical, but after reading lots of verdicts I realized it was not. > but asking so that I can ask something else Ask. If I don't know, I'll tell you that.
- ouiyaaa 11y agoI was going to ask what happens if Apple says no! I don't know what the next step of FBI will be. What do you think? Can Apple be sued over this? Can they say okay give us the device and we will give you the data but not the actual 'modified os'? (Or we'll just have to find out?)
- ars 11y ago> what happens if Apple says no. They would be fined, or executives charged with contempt of court and possible jail time. That would also make the Judge mad at them, and not likely to agree to anything they ask. The Judge has a LOT of power - he can impose some really high fines, and that's just to start with. Apple will not mess with him. > I don't know what the next step of FBI will be. Not FBI. If the Judge says to do it (so far he has not), he will be the one making sure they do it. The FBI will just complain to the Judge if necessary, not actually do anything. > Can they say okay give us the device and we will give you the data but not the actual 'modified os'? They can ask the Judge if they can do that. It's up to the Judge to say yes or no. They'll probably have to explain why it's better that way, and that the end result would be the same. The FBI can then argue against it, (or accept it). The Judge will listen to both sides and explain his reasoning in a paper. You might want to try to read all the stuff the Judge writes in this case. Ignore what the lawyers for Apple or FBI write, read just what the Judge writes (he will summarize what the lawyers wrote, so you won't miss anything).
- phyalow 11y ago6. Wrong, Yes they can, a company can suspend public trading of its stock any time it wishes. https://www.sec.gov/litigation/suspensions.shtml https://www.sec.gov/litigation/suspensions.shtml
- ad_hominem 11y agoMy understanding is that it's the SEC who suspends trading on a stock, not the company itself.
- zajd 11y ago> The federal securities laws allow the SEC to suspend trading in any stock for up to ten trading days when the SEC determines that a trading suspension is required in the public interest and for the protection of investors. > allow the SEC to suspend
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>They analyze things on a human level This (and the job prospects) are the reason I choose computer science/software engineering over being a lawyer even though most people who commented on what I should be say I should be a lawyer. The law requires not just thinking like a human, but accepting such thought as valid. To me the logic is exactly the same behind any racist who makes special exceptions for all minority people they know while still holding their view in general. In effect the system is built on a mix of emotion and logic, and in doing such it is insanely unjust to those who fall on the unpopular side. A President who admits to smoking pot leading a government that ruins the lives of people who use pot... it is just as bad as some older men I know who admit to having tried pot but who think anyone currently trying it deserves to be put in prison. Analyzing something on the human level is always a horrible standard when viewed outside the context of our own emotional fallacies.
- eibrahim 11y agoYou NEED human emotion not just logic when making laws. Pure logic is like 100% free markets with zero oversight and government interference, it looks good on paper but not in practice. Human emotion in laws add things like forgiveness, understanding and compassion, things that mathematics can't help with. I know that it also adds greed, unfairness and discrimination hence the reason it is a constant struggle to find the right balance.
- DickingAround 11y agoThis is an amazing meta-point here; the people on the other side of this debate seem to have no need for logical cohesion. I might extend that a bit to ask 'what is the consequence of such lack of cohesion'? Perhaps first that getting agreement on anything needs to be done at a close to case-by-case basis since there is a weaker adherence to standards. This can introduce favoritism (e.g. some people get hit for pot and others don't). Another consequence might be up-front costs. Not needing to think too deep about edge cases and whatnot is clearly less time-cost to run first-time-seen cases. This in turn means people won't hesitate as much in setting new precedence because they won't notice when they do. Another consequence would be inability to get consistency across and entire system since not everything can be debated by all and there's not clear rules.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> They analyze things on a human level, not a mathematical level. Courts analyse things on a political level. It has less to do with what normal humans think is right and more to do with causing the outcome the judge wants to occur. The result is that the better judges are more consistent (and then get celebrated when the outcome in a specific case is politically popular but pilloried for creating "loopholes" when it isn't), whereas the worse judges find a way to make the politically popular thing happen no matter how tortured the logic it takes to get there is. And the existence of the second class destroys the rule of law, because you get in front of one of them and it doesn't matter what you did, it only matters if the judge likes you.