3 ms·
Ok someone murders a bunch of defenseless people... Why is Apple dragging their feet? This is tasteless. I'm NOT for backdoors, but this is ridiculous.
by exabrial 11y ago
Ok someone murders a bunch of defenseless people... Why is Apple dragging their feet? This is tasteless. I'm NOT for backdoors, but this is ridiculous.
- bbatsell 11y ago> I'm NOT for backdoors I think you've just learned that you are, in fact, for backdoors. A backdoor doesn't become any less of a backdoor when it's only used against bad people.
- exabrial 11y agoNo, don't put words into my mouth. I think Apple should go to some extraordinary means to assist here. Any system is hackable if have physical possession and control over the input.
- feld 11y agoDo you know what a HSM is?
- feld 11y agoDo you know what a HSM is?
- Natsu 11y agoIt's true that we haven't seen perfection yet, but there are tamper-resistant devices where the above is not trivially true. If each device were protecting the same keys or we just needed to break the platform, I might be more inclined to agree, but given that they have individual keys and a failed break could leave the data unobtainable, I'm not so confident. That said, I think this particular phone doesn't have the secure enclave, so it may be breakable here.
- dmak 11y agoIt's more than just that. It's about setting a precedent. If you let the government walk all over your security, then where do you draw the line? What's the point of security at that point? Security doesn't favor good or bad.
- exabrial 11y agoGreat point about good/bad, so here's the line: systems should resist and prevent mass warrantless surveillance. We are innocent by default, a government should not be able to dragnet it's citizens. However I don't understand why everyone on hn thinks it's impossible to design things in this manner.