4 ms·
Is it possible for this data to ever be useful? Given the time necessary to acquire the data, and the rate at which improvements are made to drives, cannot we
by sandworm101 11y ago
Is it possible for this data to ever be useful? Given the time necessary to acquire the data, and the rate at which improvements are made to drives, cannot we make the assumption that drives purchased today probably won't operate in exactly the same manner as drives purchased a year ago?
I don't mean to insult, just to ponder the relevance of such long-term studies on tech that changes so quickly.
- taylorwc 11y agoMy takeaway in the long run is in trying to narrow the list of HD manufacturers I am comfortable purchasing. Your point has truth in it, but it also seems fair to observe that companies known for producing reliable products consistently will continue to do so, all other things equal.
- toast0 11y agoThis is definitely useful, although maybe not for purchasing. It lets you know which smart attributes are most useful, for example. Also, given the periodic reports, you can make judgments about how brands are trending (although you have to be careful about age factors). I think their reports showed 3tb drives are not great as well.
- baruch 11y agoWhen the data is consistent for several years you should already figure out that Seagate is not going to improve so fast, when they do improve in BackBlaze data you can start buying them again. Large companies may buy Seagate due to the price advantage and the fact that their storage systems can better handle the drive failure rate.
- kirian 11y agoThe Seagate drives do seem to be improving in reliability though. The higher capacity Seagate drives which I presume are newer models have better failure rate numbers than the lower capacity drives. The 4 and 6TB drives seem to have reasonable failure rates compared to the other manufactures - only HGST is better than Seagate for the 4TB and Seagate 6TB drive has a lower failure rate than the HGST 8TB. FOr >4TB drives the Seagate 6TB has the lowest failure rate. 6TB 1.89% 4TB 2.19/2.99% (depending on model) 3TB 5.1/28.34% (depending on model) 2TB 10.1% 1.5TB 10.16%/23.86% (depending on model)