5 ms·
Hmmm... biggest shortage of housing is in the London area, I guess? This is due to people parking their funds in real estate because interest rates anywhere in
by mschuster91 11y ago
Hmmm... biggest shortage of housing is in the London area, I guess?
This is due to people parking their funds in real estate because interest rates anywhere in the stock market are basically zero when compared to real estate, and because transferring ownership of an estate holding company is a pretty nice way to launder/transfer money.
I'd propose a law that makes it illegal for an estate owner in housing-crisis areas to leave a home un-occupied for over 4 months a year; if this is not the case the state is allowed to choose an arbitrary person and let him rent the apartment at a rate similar to the non-luxury-housing market.
In Germany, in some areas this law is already in effect (e.g. http://www.hamburg.de/contentblob/3999156/data/hamburgisches-wohnraumfoerderungsgesetz.pdf http://www.hamburg.de/contentblob/3999156/data/hamburgisches...). The legal foundation for these laws is in the Grundgesetz: "Eigentum verpflichtet. Sein Gebrauch soll zugleich dem Wohle der Allgemeinheit dienen.", which basically means that if you have the privilege of owning something, you have to contribute to common wealth with it.
- autotune 11y agoHow do you determine that someone has occupied the home before 4 months? How long should the length of the stay be? If some ridiculously rich person has a bunch of houses, this would mean they just need to visit each house once every 4 months, or send someone to do it, which for the people lucky enough to own a home in London I can't imagine being difficult.
- mschuster91 11y ago> How do you determine that someone has occupied the home before 4 months? Make the owner register his primary residence. I forgot not every country has something like we Germans have with the Meldewesen. Seriously, using utility bills as proofs of residence... what a load of ...
- paulddraper 11y agoSo...you can't have a summer home? Ever? And if no one uses a timeshare over the winter they lose it? Taken literally, this seems horrible. I'm assuming that the tenant gets rights and you can't just walk in and kick them out.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> So...you can't have a summer home? Ever? Reading grandparent post, sure, you could, but if it was in a housing crisis area, the government would be empowered to appropriate it for the purpose of renting it out at rates comparable to non-luxury housing (presumably, with you receiving the proceeds of the rent.) Clearly, such a rule would need an objective definition of "housing crisis", but the temporary seizure of property with compensation this proposes is actually fairly mild compared to the way critical resources are generally treated in times of genuine crisis.
- paulddraper 11y agoHow "temporary" are we talking? In my experience, one someone starts living somewhere, they're not in a hurry to leave.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> How "temporary" are we talking? Again, reading the post with the proposal, the government's authority to rent the property out exists only within the geographic and temporal extent of a "housing crisis". So, again, the concrete definition of the crisis would be critical.
- dclowd9901 11y agoThis may be an astonishing question, but Why do you need a summer home? Seems like an incredible waste of resources, natural or otherwise.
- paulddraper 11y agoWell, I don't need one, but I want one. Few places in the world are temperate year round. When I'm old and rich and retired, I'd like to enjoy the outdoors. And if you spread out the latitude, you can even capitalize on differences in day hours.
- Radim 11y agoRight. Let's give government the right to check on people, see where they live, where they sleep, for how long. Hell, let's throw "with whom" in there as well, why not, honest people have nothing to hide. And if the secret police don't like something, they'll take over your property and put "an arbitrary person" in there. Brilliant. mschuster91, I don't know if this is really acceptable in Germany, but I downvoted your post because I find the proposition in(s)ane and harmful.