5 ms·
This man absolutely was imprisoned for debt. Being compelled by the court to either pay your debt or go to prison is, by very definition, being imprisoned for f
by mywittyname 11y ago
This man absolutely was imprisoned for debt. Being compelled by the court to either pay your debt or go to prison is, by very definition, being imprisoned for failure to pay a debt.
The court should have ordered the seizure of bank assets to cover the debt. In no way should owning money ever result in jail time, fines, judgements or otherwise.
- maxerickson 11y agoWhat do you see as the threat to go to prison? He was certainly compelled to appear in court (at what is probably a great waste of taxpayer resources), but after that appearance, I don't see where he would be detained if he didn't agree to pay the debt.
- greggyb 11y agoFrom the fine article, emphasis mine: > He says seven deputy US Marshals showed up at his home with guns and took him to federal court where he had to sign a payment plan for the 29-year-old school loan. He was not taken to prison, he was arrested. These are wildly different actions. Nowhere in the article do the strings "prison", "jail", "gaol", "cell", "penitentiary" or any other synonym for prison appear. There is plenty of discussion elsewhere in the HN comments on what may have led to this arrest.
- kels 11y agoIn the video he said he was placed in a 4x4 cell for an hour before being taken to a judge. He said no one read his rights or allowed him to get representation.
- mywittyname 11y agoA more thorough article: http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/u-s-marshals-arresting-people-not-paying-student-loans-article-1.2533153 http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/u-s-marshals-arrest... > Aker said he was put in the back of a truck and placed in a cell at the federal building in downtown Houston. > Aker told The News that he was ordered to pay $5,700 for the loan, including interest. However, Aker was also ordered to pay for the cost of the morning arrest — nearly $1,300. > If he didn't pay that amount by March 1, he said, he was told he would be arrested again. Wonder what will happen when he's arrested again when he can't come up with $7000 in two weeks.
- greggyb 11y agoSo, a courthouse cell is a very different thing than being imprisoned. It's reasonable to assume that someone brought to court against their will would not be so willing to stay there. I have made no statement about the propriety of the actions described in either article, merely observed that this is not a case of sending someone to prison over a debt.
- morgante 11y agoHe still hasn't paid the debt. Where in the article did you see that "choice" presented? All that he was compelled to do was show up in court and agree to a payment plan. He might still never pay the debt.