3 ms·
Please try to make your points without quoting random people. Quotes are not sources, they are not facts, they're just something someone said.
by pc86 11y ago
Please try to make your points without quoting random people. Quotes are not sources, they are not facts, they're just something someone said.
- alanwatts 11y agoIf you think the thoughts of great scientists and engineers like Buckminster Fuller (Former president of the Mensa Society) and Carl Sagan are unwarranted in a place like hackernews then you should find a new forum. Do you have anything to contribute to this discussion? Edit: "The argument from authority (Latin: argumentum ad verecundiam) also appeal to authority, is a common argument form which can be fallacious, such as when an authority is cited on a topic outside their area of expertise, when the authority cited is not a true expert." Please do tell who might be a true expert on science and technology as it relates to societal organization, if not Fuller or Sagan.
- pc86 11y agoSince you're a fan of linking to Wikipedia articles about fallacious arguments, I'll just leave this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority
- tremon 11y agoThat doesn't apply, and you know it. The fallacy is constructed as "A has said B, A is great, therefore B must be true". The GP never stated that B must be true. Simply quoting somebody is not in itself a fallacy.
- logfromblammo 11y agoQuotes do have the notable advantage of still being remembered and recognized many years after their original utterance or publication. This is often because they are a more concise and eloquent expression of a particular thought than the people repeating the quotes can manage themselves on short notice. And they have the additional rhetorical impact of appeal to authority. While this does nothing to establish the validity of facts, it works wonders with garnering emotional support from your audience. Don't fall into the trap of arguing with rhetoric. That's bringing a knife to a gunfight. The Internet is not a formal debate forum. The audience is filled with humans, not robots. Sometimes, if your goal is to sway people to a particular point of view, or even just to force them to acknowledge that other points of view exist, it is easier to take rhetorical shortcuts. Saying "that's cheating" doesn't help. We all know it's cheating. We just don't care, because it allowed the point to be expressed in a quicker, more entertaining way.