13 ms·
Vellum works and has been proven to work for hundreds of years. Archival paper is interesting but largely unproven tech. On paper it works (no pun intended) but
by Someone1234 11y ago
Vellum works and has been proven to work for hundreds of years. Archival paper is interesting but largely unproven tech. On paper it works (no pun intended) but we really haven't seen if it will last even 200 years, and we should before we start printing our most treasured documents on it.
Digital long term storage is just, no. Look, all key UK documents are ALREADY digital they're available to download right now. However we aren't talking about digital Vs. non-digital, we're talking about what to store BACKUPS on.
Digital long term storage is something people who frankly know little about technology point to. It is up to IT-types to figure out the costs and the "how?" from then on out. There is no digital storage media which will still exist reliably in 200-400 years, not CDs, not HDDs, and not SSDs. Tapes are the closest and they won't last that long.
So we aren't talking about slapping it on a CD and storing it in some archive, we're talking about slapping it on a piece of digital media today and then moving it every one hundred years without fail, or we lose it forever... If one government or generation loses interest then future generations suffer (see the current government as an example: moving away from reliable Vellum to unproven papers).
Plus with digital you also have to worry about: solar flares/EMP, format knowledge (both of the file system & file format), media protocol knowledge (SATA or CDs might be forgotten technology), and the ability to alter historical documents without detection (not that vallum is immune, but it requires more skill/time).
PS - The "Digital Preservation Coalition" are a group of historians and archivists. They aren't technologists, they just point blindly at digital without explaining the nitty gritty of HOW.
- imprecision 11y agoEntirely agree with you about the current lack of longer term stable data storage options. That said, waiting the full duration of a material's projected life span before actual use of that material would limit options hugely, especially with the massively increasing corpus of generated data. In this sort of context (amount of data) one can spread your bets and use vellum, as well as other methods, until other more stable forms of storage are easily available. Interesting piece released yesterday related to long term data storage; a projected lifespan of 13.8 billion years doesn't sound too bad... University of Southampton - http://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-update.page http://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-up...
- alkonaut 11y agoArchiving things for future civilizations to dig up is one thing. Then you may be talking about hundreds or thousands of years that the data just sits there. Then you have to worry about the longevity of bits, and whether the technology and knowledge to read the data will exist in the future. Digital is very hard for that use case. On the other hand, storing data for an active/continuously used archive doesn't seem so hard. You just keep the data digitally on some media and every few years you upgrade the tech to whatever technology and formats are "current" before the old format and tech is completely forgotten. Keeping digital data around for a decade is pretty easy. If you do that 100 times in a row you have kept it for a thousand years and you never had a file format or a storage media older than a decade. You could "forget" to upgrade the archive, but you could also "forget" to scribble on the calfs some time.
- DanBC 11y ago> You just keep the data digitally on some media and every few years you upgrade the tech to whatever technology and formats are "current" before the old format and tech is completely forgotten. But you need to avoid the mistakes that people have already made: using some weird format that dies, and then having all your data locked away in a semi-readable file.
- rayiner 11y agoI mean, what's a "weird format?" Did anyone anticipate EDBIC wouldn't survive into 2015?
- michrassena 11y agoOff the cuff, I'd point to any format for which you'd have to fire up an emulator to run the software to read it. I would also include any format which is not openly documented or which requires a propriety tool to view it. When you look at archiving digital formats, you have to look at the whole toolchain and realize that the substrate of the medium itself will degrade, the electrical or magnetic field will degrade, the storage format will quickly become obsolete, the digital file format will be and so forth. More relevant to the discussion at hand, supposing you do intend to store important documents in a digital format as a long-term archive. What format do you store the instructions for reading and decoding the archive? Wouldn't carbon pigment on vellum be stable enough? Edit: On further consideration, I think we have to regard digital media and formats like a form of encryption (a simile, I don't mean this literally) which gets stronger over time. Time will bury extant evidence of what is contained on the media and how it is stored. Why should not make the information as explicit (plain-text) as possible? People in 800 years will still have to spend their efforts decoding early 21st century English legalese.
- gglitch 11y agoWhile there's much truth in your statement, I wouldn't be so quick to discount the knowledge and experience of archivists, who have collectively as a profession put a tremendous amount of time and effort into researching archival theory and practice, both physical and digital, and who count among them extremely knowledgeable technologists. They are acutely aware of the fact that you can't just burn a cd and call it a day. With that said, I don't know anything about the Digital Preservation Coalition; you may be right about them in particular. [Edited for clarity]
- Someone 11y agoFor the kind of backup they are thinking about, you cannot count on archivists being present all the time. It is more like the way the Long Now Foundation wants to build a clock that will run unattended for 10.000 years (http://longnow.org/clock/ http://longnow.org/clock/) I personally would go for clay tablets, rather than vellum.
- ddingus 11y agoSeconded. Doing this doesn't cost much, and it's a basic archive of the business of the people worth keeping in human readable form. At the end of the day, tech is good, but the business of people needs to be human readable, accessible in a court, trusted by all. This is a basic requirement humans have, and without it in place, we are forced to trust and depend on tech for law, and it's real consequences. Nothing wrong with using tech, mind you. We can, should and do. It's more efficient. But, say something bad happens. That's what the vellum is for.
- venomsnake 11y agoDeep engraving in quality stainless steel. This can be as close to eternal as possible.
- Animats 11y agoThat's a good choice. Laser-marking stainless steel sheet is a common operation with modern laser cutters. That should last thousands of years. It will survive water, fire, and handling.
- rtkwe 11y agoLong Now is doing something like this but with a nickle disk instead of stainless and etching and electroforming instead of engraving. It allows much smaller features vs engraving. They're engraving 13000 pages about 1500 languages onto a small 3inch disk. http://rosettaproject.org/disk/concept/ http://rosettaproject.org/disk/concept/
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> Archival paper is interesting but largely unproven tech. On paper it works (no pun intended) but we really haven't seen if it will last even 200 years, and we should before we start printing our most treasured documents on it. No no. This doesn't make sense. If we're not going to put our treasured documents on archival paper until we've proved that archival paper really will last for centuries, they're never going to be put on archival paper, no matter how great it might or might not be, because we'll all be dead. You wanted to say we should see how archival paper pans out before we stop printing our treasured documents on other types of material.
- KineticLensman 11y agoYes, also makes complete sense from a cultural perspective. If there is any sort of process involved in making a copy on new formats as they emerge, then you have to maintain a culture of people that are willing and able to execute the process. Far simpler to use a technology that is proven to work over several hundred years. Exhibit A: The Magna Carta [1]. With care, you can pick it up and read it, even today, Automation won't hack it either. At the moment, the most complex machine that we know how to make persist into deep time is a very simple clock [2], and even that requires human intervention. In Anathem [3], Neal Stephenson speculates on what this combo of culture and deep-time technology might look like. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Carta https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Carta [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clock_of_the_Long_Now https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clock_of_the_Long_Now [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anathem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anathem
- flashman 11y ago> Archival paper is interesting but largely unproven tech. Archival paper is tested by artificially aging it (e.g. exposure to heat and moisture to simulated passage of time.) Some long-term tests are underway to determine whether accelerated aging tests accurately simulate the natural aging process.[1] And there are associated standards, e.g. ISO 5630-3.[2] But you are correct, we really have no proof of how modern archival paper will perform over a multi-century timeline. [1]https://www.loc.gov/preservation/scientists/projects/100-yr_nat_aging.html https://www.loc.gov/preservation/scientists/projects/100-yr_... [2]http://www.iso.org/iso/iso_catalogue/catalogue_tc/catalogue_detail.htm?csnumber=23402 http://www.iso.org/iso/iso_catalogue/catalogue_tc/catalogue_...
- tsaixingwei 11y agoActually, archivists and technologists have been working together to solve the problems of digital preservation for a long time. There is an ISO Standards for digital preservation systems - ISO 14721:2012 originally authored by and still maintained by The Consultative Committee for Space Data Systems (CCSDS, which part of NASA). There are commercial systems that were developed to these standards, among them Preservica (http://preservica.com/ http://preservica.com/) which is used in many archives in Europe. Archivists are acutely aware of the obsolescence of digital formats and media. And the solution cannot be just printing them out on vellum or archival paper because increasingly records are being created digitally that cannot be meaningfully or adequately converted into printed formats. I am talking about records that are audio, video, high resolution photographs (like those that NASA is seeking to preserve digitally) etc. Even emails when printed out onto paper would be missing a lot contextual information that would have been kept if you preserved it as a digital format like EML or MSG. So, existing digital preservation systems may still be imperfect, but nevertheless we still need find improved solutions for preserving them digitally. I don't work for CCSDS or Preservica. I work for a national archive as a specialist on digital records and archives, but my background is in IT having spent about 15 years in software development.