4 ms·
Long before? Didn't they just adopt Metal on Mac OS mid last year? Surely they knew Vulkan is almost done. I think they just wanted to see if they can push maj
by mtgx 11y ago
Long before? Didn't they just adopt Metal on Mac OS mid last year? Surely they knew Vulkan is almost done.
I think they just wanted to see if they can push major game developers to adopt Metal for Mac games early on. If they could do that - awesome for them, and they would never have to adopt Vulkan. If they can't, they'll have to adopt Vulkan.
Here's hoping the latter will happen.
- masklinn 11y ago> Long before? Didn't they just adopt Metal on Mac OS mid last year? Surely they knew Vulkan is almost done. Metal was made available in iOS8, in September 2014, almost 18 months ago. That's pretty long. In fact the first Metal public demo predates the Vulkan private kickoff meeting. > I think they just wanted to see if they can push major game developers to adopt Metal for Mac games early on. Mid-2015 they made their iOS graphics API — which had been available for nearly a year at this point — available on OSX. Fact remains that they realised a need for and started working on a lower-overhead API much earlier than Vulkan was conceived let alone released, likely circa 2012~2013 if they were almost done by mid-2014.
- creshal 11y ago> Didn't they just adopt Metal on Mac OS mid last year? Surely they knew Vulkan is almost done. Vulkan was announced in December 2014, with no significant commitment. iOS 8 including Metal was announced mid-2014, and would have been in development for a considerable time before. By the time it was announced for OSX, Vulkan was still anaemic and not showing significant progress. So it does make sense to keep using Metal for them. > I think they just wanted to see if they can push major game developers to adopt Metal for Mac games early on. If they could do that - awesome for them, and they would never have to adopt Vulkan. If that was the plan, it's probably going to fail: The developers of Unity e.g. found Metal, DX12 and Vulkan so similar that they estimate to be able to support all three with minimal development overhead.
- mtgx 11y agoWhy does everyone misinterpret my comment to mean that I was talking about iOS? I know Metal was announced for iOS earlier - I was talking about the support for Mac OS X. They had no good reason to adopt it for Mac OS X at that point, if they were planning on adopting Vulkan in the near future anyway. Unless, like I said, they'd prefer to keep Metal over Vulkan, and wanted to give it a head start to see if PC game developers would start adopting it. > If that was the plan, it's probably going to fail: The developers of Unity e.g. found Metal, DX12 and Vulkan so similar that they estimate to be able to support all three with minimal development overhead. I'm not sure how you see that as a "failure". If they are so similar that game engine developers will keep Metal around anyway, then we'll see games be built on Metal, not Vulkan, for Mac OS X. How is that a "failure"? It would mean Metal "won".
- masklinn 11y ago> They had no good reason to adopt it for Mac OS X at that point Of course they did: it was already their API of choice on iOS, platform unification alone makes it a damn good idea to adopt it for OSX: iOS is by far their most popular gaming platform, integrating the API back to OSX makes it more likely they'd get more OSX support. Not to mention a mid-2015 release of Metal-on-OSX means they'd probably been working on it since the Metal-on-iOS release. On top of fragmenting their platforms, waiting for Metal would have meant a year-long delay.
- shmerl 11y ago> Of course they did They did have a reason, except it's nowhere good. They don't want to support Vulkan because it increases their lock-in control and puts extra tax on cross platform development. Same reason MS doesn't want to support it on Xbox. It's not a good reason, it's pretty crooked but very Apple like.
- webjprgm 11y agoApple isn't usually about "locking people in" but more about controlling the experience. That can lead to the same thing, where they want everyone to use their API and not someone else's, but the difference is whether they have greedy, malicious intent or not. I don't think they do. Having good intentions means they are more likely to surprise you and do something good eventually. Still, I wouldn't hold my breath on Apple supporting Vulkan soon. Their OpenGL support is usually a few versions behind so if they do ever support Vulkan I would expect it to be late.
- baq 11y agovulcan was actually a hastily thrown together proposition in response to the shocking (to OpenGL people) announcement of Metal by Apple. it helped a lot that AMD jumped on board by donating Mantle to Khronos.