3 ms·
Except that diamonds are just a form of carbon, whereas gold is divisible and un-manufacturable. Say what you want about diamonds, they way will pass as technol
by 3pt14159 17y ago
Except that diamonds are just a form of carbon, whereas gold is divisible and un-manufacturable. Say what you want about diamonds, they way will pass as technology makes more and more strides, but gold does have industrial use as well as financial use. Gold is money when the future is completely uncertain. Heck, the Dow hasn't moved since the thirties when priced in gold.
- jpablo 17y agoGold is money only because most people agree on that. If our civilization collapses the only 'money' people will take will be corn and rise. Said that, I agree that gold has value, it has it's uses. But when it's get used as a 'safe' currency it's all artificial.
- derefr 17y agoIf our society collapses, rebuilding parts of it will give great economies of scale to those with the requisite knowledge. Gold might not be the most worthful metal, though; that might go to copper, until the infrastructure gets built back up to the point where we're concerned with gold's particular conductivity.
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoCurrency is artifice.
- dkersten 17y agoI would say tinned food and ammunition.
- rsheridan6 17y agoPeople have agreed on gold's value for thousands of years. I don't think anything worse than the fall of Rome is likely to happen, and gold retained its value even then.
- caf 17y agoGold's value isn't based in its industrial uses, though; in fact, the faith-based pricing of it inhibits industrial uses. Real-estate on the Moon is also divisible and un-manufacturable, but no-one seems to be arguing that we should base a monetary system on _that_.
- gwern 17y ago> Real-estate on the Moon is also divisible and un-manufacturable, but no-one seems to be arguing that we should base a monetary system on _that_. From the perspective of a fiat currency serving as a store of value, Moon real estate is a great idea. The exact amount and location of it is available to anyone in the world; it's tamper-proof; and unlike regular paper money, it's difficult for it to be inflated.
- goodside 17y agoA currency with zero nominal inflation translates to effective deflation in a growing economy. If you own x% of the moon, and no more moon can be printed, you'll hold your lunar notes under a mattress waiting for their value to rise and nothing productive will ever get financing.
- gwern 17y agoI'd rather have a little ongoing deflation than risk becoming the next Weimar. Or China(s). Or Turkey. Or Yugoslavia. Or Zimbabwe... And inflation imposes costs of its own just from adjustment and uneven inflation discourages investment on its own (holding debt comes to mind).
- rsheridan6 17y agoI think you're the first person to think of it. Good idea. I will be arguing for it from now on, because not only is it divisible and un-manufacturable, it wouldn't inhibit industrial uses of gold or anything else.