5 ms·
That's a great way to reintroduce nuclear tests discretely (well, sort of discretely). The cold war is back!
by cm2187 11y ago
That's a great way to reintroduce nuclear tests discretely (well, sort of discretely). The cold war is back!
- DominikR 11y agoThere is no indication in the article that a nuclear weapon will be used in the test. I doubt that Russia or the US needs to really test nuclear weapons at this point, it is all about the delivery mechanism.
- cm2187 11y agoI think any engineer or developer would agree that we only know a technology works after testing it, not just because it works on paper. I wonder how the US or Russia can really have any confidence in any nuke designed since the early 90s.
- konart 11y agoWhat nukes? All of them are pre-90s. Delivery systems and containers can be new though.
- cm2187 11y agoI would expect even nukes to have a shelve life. There are chemicals (explosives) that surely are only stable for a given period.
- iSnow 11y agoThere's indeed a case to back you up: >Air-launched weapons like cruise missiles must endure hours of sub-freezing temperatures at high altitudes while riding their carrier aircraft. Weaponeers successfully subjected the W-80’s components – including the IHE – to temperatures down to -65 Fahrenheit – during development. >But when actually tested in Shot Baseball during Operation Guardian in January 1981, the W-80 fizzled. The new nuke failed to ignite its fusion secondary and produced only a fraction of its intended yield. The IHE proved to be the culprit. It didn’t burn well at very low temperatures. http://warisboring.com/articles/america-had-a-problem-with-its-nuclear-warheads-freezing/ http://warisboring.com/articles/america-had-a-problem-with-i...
- finid 11y agoWe never really stopped testing nuclear weapons. After the ban, we continued using supercomputers to perform the tests, which, given how powerful the supercomputers are, is just as good as testing the real thing. Ditto for the Russians and other nuclear powers.
- varjag 11y agoThe virtual tests are as good as the models behind it. How fast or detailed you get the wrong answer is irrelevant. Not to say the models are actually wrong: I certainly wouldn't bet my hometown on it.
- valarauca1 11y agoIf you believe this you are pretty naive. The space program was initial started to support Starfish Prime type high altitude nuclear tests. All launch vehicles until Apollo were ICBM's. The moon landing was originally planned to be a diplomatic stunt by JFK who wanted a peaceful mission to open a larger diplomatic dialog. Space programs have always, and likely will always be a way to project power. And test high end military weapons under the guise of peace and science.
- DominikR 11y agoFirst of all it would be great if you didn't insult me to bring across your point. The second thing I'd like to say: I never contradicted any facts you state here. Likely they will be using the data to improve their ICBM's, it would be an enormous waste of resources if they didn't. (and so does every other country that has ICBM's) I said: nothing indicates that they will use a nuclear weapon, "it is all about the delivery mechanism" -> they will use ICBM's but without the warhead, which does not break any treaties to my knowledge.
- rl3 11y ago>The space program was initial started to support Starfish Prime type high altitude nuclear tests. Do you have a source for that? I'd think there were a multitude of reasons in reality, a specific defense purpose being but one. Funny enough, high-altitude nuclear testing proved to be a serious concern for the safety of manned space flight.[0] [0] http://www.wired.com/2012/03/starfishandapollo-1962/ http://www.wired.com/2012/03/starfishandapollo-1962/
- gherkin0 11y ago> I doubt that Russia or the US needs to really test nuclear weapons at this point, it is all about the delivery mechanism. IIRC, there's still some need to test in order to evaluate the performance and other aging characteristics of old warheads. The US, at least, is trying to accomplish that testing via simulation rather than actual detonations. though.
- jgreen10 11y agoRussia and the US are more than capable of destroying the world already, but it's far harder to save it.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoDo you mean that literally? If you had access to the entire arsenal of the US or Russia and wanted to destroy the planet, how would you do it?
- chunkiestbacon 11y agoThis question reminded me of "the weird and worrying questions" pages in what if from the xckd guy.
- bitL 11y agoIf you just detonate all nukes at their own silos, fallout & nuclear winter will wipe most of life in a few months. If you want to demolish the whole Earth DeathStar-style, nukes won't help.
- cocoablazing 11y agoTTAPS assumed strikes on petroleum facilities and cities. I don't think your scenario fits the assumptions of any study on nuclear winter.
- bitL 11y agoThanks for correcting me!
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Russia and the US are more than capable of destroying the world already They aren't capable of destroying the world; their definitely, OTOH, capable of really dealing a severe blow to human civilization and might even manage to wipe out humanity entirely.
- cocoablazing 11y agoThe United States continues to invest billions of dollars in advancing nuclear weapons science (NIF,ASCI,LEP). A critical detonation of a weapon is unnecessary. There is plenty of useful data available from a long-term program such as NIF, which DOE uses to refine physical simulations of weapons phenomena.