3 ms·
Between this and the seemingly over-aggressive response to the "iGiveHead" patch, I find myself struggling to reconcile my very positive experiences with R user
by danso 11y ago
Between this and the seemingly over-aggressive response to the "iGiveHead" patch, I find myself struggling to reconcile my very positive experiences with R users on Twitter and StackOverflow...and the reportedly closed-off attitude of core members.
I'm not one who thinks that Linus Torvalds is completely out of hand -- in fact, whenever I read the messages and the context for whatever blowup he's allegedly stoking, I find him to be quite reasonable. And maybe that would be the case here after knowing both sides of the story...but the wording of the message received by the author really, really rubbed me the wrong way:
> "You were asked to correct this in 2013, failed to even reply, and it has been archived. Please explain your inaction and lack of the most basic manners."
Sure, I don't know how CRAN works, and maybe the author is an unreliable narrator who is leaving out the part where his "inaction" caused CRAN to experience a week-long downtime...but barring that kind of disaster, the message the author received struck me to be not just callously judgmental, but just...sad. Has this person never been on the receiving end of a missed email? Does this person not realize that life happens, even to people who contribute to CRAN? And that the author may have experienced some serious downtime in his life, such as a death of a loved one, or unemployment, and just simply missed the email? Why the fuck would you harass someone who is actively seeking out to update his contribution in response to users' pleas? How jaded must you be to accuse someone through email of lacking "the most basic manners" when this person is offering help, rather than thinking that just maybe you should give him the benefit of the doubt?
Maybe the author was an inattentive jerk. But there's no reason to assume that right off the bat. Yeah, I know this is a relatively small scuffle in the scheme of things...but that's what really bothers me. One of R's disadvantages is that it doesn't have enough contributing developers...but small communities have their own advantages, and I feel that's why my interactions with R-users have always made me feel good about the language. But the way this CRAN maintainer allegedly acted...it just makes me sad...if someone in a community this small can be so cold to another member, then it's a downer to think how things in much bigger communities that lack the personal connectedness.
But good on the author for taking it in stride...he probably doesn't need R as much as R needs more people like him.