16 ms·
Why Modern Makers Are Bringing Back Ham Radio
- AstroJetson 11y agoNot sure that it ever left. But I'm seeing more makers get into software defined radio due to the very low cost and the growing base of hams to exchange ideas with. There are also new digital modes that require less power to complete back and forth messages. Lots of cool things to work with, easier than ever licensing, have kept the hobby active.
- zoidb 11y agoIt seems like not allowing encryption for amateur radio bands is a showstopper for a lot of people, it would be nice if the FCC would change their position on it. Does anyone know if there has been any movement in this area?
- hga 11y agoIt would be much harder to keep commercial traffic off the ham bands if hams and the government can't read the traffic.
- goda90 11y agoI hate the implications of such a system, but perhaps an encryption system could be developed such that both the sender and receiver are verifiable in any one message based on their public key but the message remains encrypted. Then only ham licensees are granted valid certificates. I don't think encryption should be allowed on most ham bands, but I was trying to come up with a solution(while making all sorts of new problems)
- lmm 11y agoYou could do that at the SSL level with client certificates, I think.
- jlgaddis 11y agoHam radio is about communicating with others. How am I supposed to respond to your digital "CQ" if it's encrypted and I can't read it? There has not been any movement in this area and I hope that there never is.
- adrianN 11y agoPrivate communication is a form of communication. Public key cryptography makes it relatively easy.
- unethical_ban 11y agoBut the whole point of amateur radio historically has been making contact with strangers and/or being welcoming to new people to the hobby. I'm a privacy zealot, but the spirit and discoverability of amateur radio would be diminished if all the traffic was just static. PERHAPS a small band could be allocated for secure comms experiments... but I don't know. Besides, wouldn't encrypted noise over the air be confusing to others? Wouldn't people just broadcast over each other?
- adrianN 11y agoThe internet allows for encrypted communication, yet you can talk to me, a stranger. Allowing encryption doesn't mean that all traffic necessarily needs to be encrypted.
- unethical_ban 11y agoDecentralized transmission with no easy attribution on a limited resource is different than posting to a central server via a virtually unlimited resource (the Internet).
- VLM 11y ago"showstopper for a lot of people" People trying to do what, exactly? And how would existing ham users benefit by having the bands taken over by those commercial activities that the FCC regulates under other parts? There are multiple roadblocks: FCC part 97.113(A) prohibited transmissions contains: "(5) Communications, on a regular basis, which could reasonably be furnished alternatively through other radio services." So... if all you're trying to do is replicate a wirelessISP or satellite internet service, but do it for free on the ham bands, well, that's illegal in and of itself aside from encryption. This part of the law has occasionally caused controversy for the RC airplane people on the 6M band, the "text email service for sailboats" people on HF, couple others. And if you live near the border of a country or have impressive range there's part 97.117. And there are interesting regulations for 3rd party traffic across international boundaries. And there are pecuniary interest regulations, so no doing work or getting paid for it or having money change hands except under relatively weird and limited forms. Its not as simple as crossing out a couple words in 97.113(A)(4) that prevent "messages encoded for the purpose of obscuring their meaning". That alone will not magically let wireless ISPs offer service pretending to be ham radio.
- csirac2 11y agoThe spirit of amateur radio rights in most jurisdictions is that of an open/public communications medium that any licensed person can join in on (it has twitter-like aspects in that sense). Education and technical investigations are also usually encouraged. In that sense, encryption might be viewed at the very least as being selfish by some; and at the worst, some jurisdictions would start having to think differently about threats on ham radio bands.
- grandalf 11y agoshowstopper? the idea is that you are broadcasting. How is a public (low budget) radio system supposed to have the money to establish the widespread cryptosystem necessary to maintain the spirit of openness while also maintaining privacy? As such, privacy is not a goal of amateur radio at all. If you desire private communications, the FCC offers different (more costly) licenses for that. There's also the internet.
- pingec 11y agoAlso I would like to mention that the lack of interest in packet radio is quite sad. I hope the trend will reverse at some point. How long has it been since you could solder your own transceiver for a practical purpose? I'm talking DIY "wifi" with a range of tens of kilometers (of course ham radio restrictions apply). AX.25 is ancient and slow, I want to watch youtube over packet radio internet with my ham radio license. Because... why not? The only guy working in this field I am aware of is this one http://lea.hamradio.si/~s53mv/ http://lea.hamradio.si/~s53mv/
- Gracana 11y agoModern (absolutely enormous) websites and ssl make packet radio internet gateways a difficult proposition.
- Ao7bei3s 11y ago@Encryption: Not really. If you have an expensive gateway anyway, you can just terminate the SSL there.
- pps43 11y agoInternet is much less useful without encryption, when you can't even log in to any web application.
- 11y ago
- unixhero 11y agoHam Radio was always there.
- VLM 11y agoThere's a meme in ham radio that's been around over half a century that "ham radio is dying woe is me". Its funny reading impassioned letters to the editor in 1950 about this being the last generation of operators, nobody new will ever enter the hobby, etc. Its useful for non-hams to know this is a very old and unkillable meme. There are other long lived memes in ham radio such as its impossible to build equipment at home anymore, its impossible to install/solder whatever connector everyone is using at this time (anderson powerpole for DC, PL-259 RF connectors, hardline connectors, etc), its impossible to do surface mount at home, my antenna system is great but anyone who spent less than me has a "compromise antenna" because they didn't spend as much as me, all frequency bands above which I operate are line of sight only (no matter if that's 80 meter phone band or 47 GHz the ops say it the same way). There's been trolling on the voice band segments of 80 and 20 meters since at least the 50s. Another popular meme is ham radio might be an infinitely large map to explore for a lifetime but my favorite activity is "real ham radio" with a side dish of the map may be infinitely large but how far I've gotten, no matter how small, is as large as the whole thing is. Hams do have amateur physicists who understand radio propagation vs the ionosphere as well as any professional, but there's probably two guys disseminating pure bro-science for every reality based amateur physicist, I donno if broscience counts as a meme, I guess so. There are a lot of weird memes about age and ham radio because to some extent money and time result in a longer ranged station, therefore most of the guys you'll talk to have the longest ranged most expensive stations therefore you'll get the peculiar idea that all hams are 70, whereas what it really means is if you spend a lifetime building up your station you tend to end up with a really impressive station just before you die. I refer to the 50s alot above not because it started then, but as a third generation ham, my ancestors had a lot of old magazines and books to read when I was growing up. The hobby mostly being male and often transmitted from father to son is highly susceptible to the overall cultural trends WRT single parenthood and boys growing up without male role models.
- unixhero 11y ago
- ai_maker 11y agoAsk HN: What value can makers add to ham? I feel I belong to this "new makers" wave and I'm thinking about using Artificial Intelligence to model noise (and cancel it) so as to use cheap SDR dongles more effectively. What do you think about this?
- luxpir 11y agoI think you should try it out! It'd be a great patch to gqrx or similar. The extent of my calibration of a cheap SDR dongle is just adjusting the PPM to correct any offset.
- VLM 11y agoham radio and makers share a common problem where its too big of a hobby to come up with a simple definition. Almost by definition if you think you know the limit of the hobby, its only because you haven't done enough research, in both fields. Something I've noticed about maker movement is to maintain the cultural pool cohesion or whatever they don't socialize with existing clubs, teams, groups in other hobbies, leading to, at best, reinventing the wheel, at worst, safety situations. Starting with zero person-years in a makerspace is probably unwise if the local ham radio club meets across the street on a different day and has person-millennias of combined RF experience. Not to mention online groups, podcasts like the soldersmoke guys... Its hard to come up with something strictly ham radio that isn't more widely applicable to electronics in general. But possible... Generally the hams are extremely talented at metalworking and trad carpentry for cabinets and RF component structures. I'm sure that could be 3-d printed and laser cut plywood and who knows what else. Imagine printing out a new custom plastic case for a field radio. Could you print out a power distribution panel, its just an array of rectangular holes, perhaps designed specifically for powerpoles to snap into. Could you print out low/medium power coil winding forms? For high power use you could remove the PLA if the copper wire is thick enough to self support. I've been fooling around with printed temporary antenna components. Fooling around with, as in "breaking" but eventually I'll print something that works. I (very briefly) talked to a guy who sewed a vest thing for his goat and his goat carries radio gear to the top of a mountain where he operates just for fun. I'm sure thinking outside the box someone could laser cut a wood backpack antenna support for backpack mobile people. Microwave waveguide work has been traditional metalworking and brazing, but maybe 3-d printing fixtures and things? There's some waveguide stuff on thingiverse but I'd be happy starting out with just WR-42 standard flange dust caps to snap on the unused end. (WR-42 size waveguide is for 24 GHz ham band, others are also useful). Alignment jigs and things? 3d Printed mounting brackets to attach standard microwave horn antennas to tripods? Basically anywhere you'd see a ham using 2x4 wood cutoffs and duct tape, a printer and lasercutter could do better. Most of the above is "in my infinite spare time I plan to..." who knows how many ideas you'd get from a large club. The ham radio construction / homebrew group is "probably" larger than the group of makers specifically into electronics. The hobby is big enough that it should be easy to find an existing spot to extend.
- ck2 11y agoHow accurate is this? How high powered? They are able to, among other things, hack together Wi-Fi routers that can operate over longer distances and use more power than standard, commercial Wi-Fi.
- luxpir 11y agoFairly accurate, from what I've read about previously: http://www.broadband-hamnet.org/just-starting-read-this.html http://www.broadband-hamnet.org/just-starting-read-this.html "Mesh nodes can easily have a range of 10 miles or more using stock power and gain antennas if you have true line of sight" "Mesh nodes on channels 1-6 use FCC part 97 rules instead of part 15. This allows big antennas, more power, other changes"
- tixlegeek 11y agoIt's absolutely accurate. But no real hacks needed. Yagi antennas and boosted interfaces are now common. In lots of commercial WiFi appliances, power is software-defined. And norms have their own power index. Values can be tweaked using free software solutions/a bit of magic. In addition with networking technologys, power amplification,... It's totally legit, quite accurate, and underestimating the reality.
- tzs 11y ago> How high powered? Up to 1500 watts in the US. Various specific frequency ranges have lower limits either across the board or in specific geographical areas (e.g., there are some restrictions near the Canadian border, and near White Sands Missile Range), but I don't see any that apply to the amateur bands that overlap with wifi bands.
- topspin 11y agoDavid Rowe is creating fully open digital voice hardware, including a TDMA repeater system. He presented his latest work at linux.conf.au 2016 and it is pretty amazing. Worth learning about even if you aren't into radio: Open Source Two Way Radio: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xDeMT7eUf4c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xDeMT7eUf4c BTW, anyone likely to be reading this in the US can earn an FCC Technician license granting full privileges to the VHF/UHF bands David discusses here in maybe 5-6 hours of study.
- throwaway1979 11y agoDo you have any book recommendations?
- cannikin 11y agoThis book has everything you need: http://www.amazon.com/ARRL-Ham-Radio-License-Manual/dp/1625950136 http://www.amazon.com/ARRL-Ham-Radio-License-Manual/dp/16259...
- topspin 11y agoThe definitive source of amateur radio literature is the ARRL. You can learn about licensing and efficiently practice the current test material at hamstudy.org.
- grandalf 11y agoI was originally licensed when I was 12, and was active on HF, but slowed down in college a bit. A few years ago I got back into it and it's been incredibly fun. There is so much exciting stuff going on. My current "maker" interest in ham radio is designing a distributed SDR system using FPGAs. I'm still a ways out from a prototype, but the chips keep getting better. I do a fair bit of HF contesting and CW as well. When I was first licensed I had to take three separate CW proficiency exams, but these days it's no longer a requirement. The beauty of CW is the simplicity of it and the way it's a highly effective weak-signal mode. I strongly encourage anyone with an interest to dig deeper. It is a very broad hobby and so you might find an entire club doing things that you have no interest in, but keep trying, as there are so many highly active niche areas to choose from. There is also (thanks to the maker movement) a tremendous amount of great learning material about electronics. W2AEW has a superb youtube channel, and 4Z1UG has a great podcast for anyone getting into it (though he's currently interviewing the older people to capture their stories while they are still around).
- criddell 11y agoI tried to get my kids into amateur radio and failed miserably. When I described being able to wirelessly talk to people around the world they pointed out that they already do this - on their phones. The only thing I could come up with that they didn't instantly shoot down is being able to communicate in the event of an emergency when the cell system is down. It didn't really resonate with them.
- wrash 11y agoI think my inspiration for writing the story on the maker movement and ham radio was my daughter, who decided to get her ham license when she was 8. Since then she's become deeply involved in the maker movement and wearable electronics. These days she's an engineer. But what really motivated her wasn't the fact that she can talk to people around the world, but rather that ham radio is the only way she can build the gear that she wants to build. You can't do that with your cell phone or a WiFi router unless you have the right license.