5 ms·
Even here on Vancouver Island it seems the possibility of owning our own home is becoming unattainable as prices sky rocket. Something needs to be done about fo
by jseliger 11y ago
Even here on Vancouver Island it seems the possibility of owning our own home is becoming unattainable as prices sky rocket. Something needs to be done about foreign investment.
Not really. Something needs to be done about parochial land use laws that prevent supply from rising to meet demand: http://www.amazon.com/TheRent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp/B0078XGJXO?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957 http://www.amazon.com/TheRent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp.... Until that happens, prices will rise. Despite many efforts to the contrary, you cannot legislate away supply, demand, and prices.
Preventing new development appears to have really taken off in the 1970s, according to Chapters 7 and 8 of William Fischel's Zoning Rules!: http://www.amazon.com/Zoning-Rules-Economics-Land-Regulation/dp/155844288X http://www.amazon.com/Zoning-Rules-Economics-Land-Regulation.... Until we reverse that dynamic (or make cities less attractive places to live) we're going to see rising prices.
- roymurdock 11y agoI think increasing supply is a good idea in the short run, but in the long run, I think the answer lies more in changing the way society views real estate. As the article makes clear, real estate is increasingly viewed as an asset that can simply be purchased and held on to diversify a risky portfolio. Foreign property owners add little to no value (in a true, human, social sense) to the greater society. They do contribute tax revenue, but at the expense of making real estate unattainable for others by driving up prices. Real estate used to be the center of a business owner's livelihood or a family's multi-decade investment in an area with family, good schools, a good community, etc. While increasing supply would reduce price, foreign investors would simply purchase more. Demand for (perceived) stable assets to offset market volatility is at an all time high, especially in China where many are trying to export wealth. When the market crashes, you'll have an oversupply of property that was built for people who did not actually inhabit the area.
- eru 11y agoSee http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2015/04/land-value-tax http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2015/04/land-val...
- roymurdock 11y agoLVT is thrown around a lot, but rarely understood by its proponents. Can you explain who would value the land and by what method it would be valued in order to guarantee fair payments from all parties? Would it completely replace the current property tax?
- eru 11y agohttp://kaalvtn.blogspot.com.au/ http://kaalvtn.blogspot.com.au/ has worked out some good answers for the UK. > Would it completely replace the current property tax? Of which country? There are lots of ways to implement LVT in different countries and different states (and it could even be implemented at even more local levels). I have a softspot for methods that ask the owner themselves to value the land, but apply mechanism to keep them honest. (Like, `you have to sell at the declared value to any comer.') But honestly, those are probably not even the most practical ones.
- andrewjl 11y agoGiven the current supply constraints in that market, it will take a very long time to build up a level of inventory that will cause a crash. The solution to the problem you're describing is more units, not less. Also, this transition in real estate's role is a result of globalization. Without some kind of capital controls it's very hard to undo it's effects. Your best bet is a supply-demand oriented solution.
- roymurdock 11y agoWhen I talk about a crash, I mean a global correction in property and equity market values akin to the correction post-financial crisis. This would probably be triggered by a withdrawal of liquidity from public markets due to non-performing debt, or simply a prevailing market sentiment that investments have been channeled into the wrong assets following the great recession - not enough gov investment into TFP-raising infrastructure and decreasing lack of aggregate demand is a recipe for stagnation. I don't see a mechanism whereby an increasing level of inventory causes a crash. I'm saying that when a crash happens, we'll be left with wasted excess capacity as investors rush to sell off ill-thought out high rise complexes, micro apartment buildings, second and third homes they can no longer afford to pay taxes on, etc.
- andrewjl 11y agoThe North American correction in property values post the 2008 financial crisis was due to two factors: 1) Increase in inventory levels as subprime borrowers tried to exit their mortgage via a fire sale 2) Total shut down of the mortgage markets, meaning only cash buyers could get deals done. Given the profile of the typical buyer at the high end of the market in Vancouver, an outsized effect like the one described above is unlikely. These homes are not mortgaged and their owners have savings they draw upon instead of income from employment. Job losses a la 2008 do not affect them as much. For these reasons I doubt we will ever see the kind of corrections in Vancouver like we saw in places like Phoenix and Las Vegas in 2008. Finally, a somewhat normative question, what's wrong with cheap housing? I agree with you that ill-thought out planning is detrimental to the city's quality of life. But to me at least it seems that the planning and permitting process is overly restrictive.
- Tiktaalik 11y agoThe spiking real estate in Vancouver is detached single family houses, which you cannot increase the supply of in Vancouver. There is some component of demand that is buying these single family houses just for the extra space for their family. Rezoning detached houses to slightly more dense row houses will help increase supply for this group. The city is already doing this, but should certainly do more. The city can't do anything about people buying detached houses for investment and prestige reasons. Vancouver is not SF. It has been building condo towers non stop since the 90s. Rent is not extremely unaffordable and condo valuations have been largely flat in comparison to single family houses.
- sintaxi 11y agoThe issue isn't detached houses so much as the lack of homes in general designed for families (both house and condo). There are very few.
- Tiktaalik 11y agoAbsolutely. Condo developers have been satisfied to build what makes them the most amount of money, which has resulted in heaps of bachelor pads. More three bedroom apartments need to be built. This is a regulatory issue that shows how important the role of government and urban planning is. The city has already indicated that they're going to require developers to include a greater percentage of multi bedroom residences.
- dogma1138 11y agoThere is no shortage in supply that's an utter myth most countries and cities have tons of abandoned houses Europe has over 11M confirmed and that's just the tip of the iceberg http://www.theguardian.com/society/2014/feb/23/europe-11m-empty-properties-enough-house-homeless-continent-twice http://www.theguardian.com/society/2014/feb/23/europe-11m-em... The biggest problem with housing is that it's just too easy to influence people to create an artificial scarcity when there is now, and in the few places there is no land laws will help as developers like to keep the supply short in order to increase it's value. Even a small shortage (fake or real) can increase the value of properties by 100's of percent this means that building more isn't lucrative to neither developers nor investors, if you just bought a property as an investment you sure as hell do not want the developer going on and building 10 new ones as it will tank the price of your property. This means that even on the off chance that a developer might find formula that will allow them to build more the investors wont buy in and without that they can't build as no sane developer builds even a parking lot out of pocket these days. On the other hand government housing isn't good either in most places government housing turns into ghettos faster than you can open a 7/11 and in the few countries it didn't like say Sweden it created the worse housing shortage anyone can imagine while creating a black market which corrupted the entire system. If anything oddly enough China is taking the best approach just build entire cities, sure some of them rest as ghost cities for some years but unlike what the media reports in the west they tend to be filled almost instantly once the planets align.