5 ms·
He gets cause and effect wrong. The reason why enrollments are so high is BECAUSE of the shortage. An increase in demand for X causes wages for X to increase.
by stale2002 11y ago
He gets cause and effect wrong. The reason why enrollments are so high is BECAUSE of the shortage. An increase in demand for X causes wages for X to increase. This increase in wages causes more people to want to supply X, by joining that field.
Also, the common argument of "There is no shortage for X, people just want to pay less money, than the current, extremely high price of X", is completely nonsensical.
The DEFINITION of a shortage is "I believe the price is too high". Thats how supply and demand works.
Example: Imagine if bread costed 100$ a loaf. Is there a shortage of food, or is it just people complaining that the price of bread is too high?
How else would you even define a shortage other than "the price is too high"?
- LordKano 11y agoHow else would you even define a shortage other than "the price is too high"? More people want to buy product or service X than there is currently available in the marketplace. So, let's say that during the next growing season, some new fungus appears and decimates the US grain crop. That will result in bread shortages. Even at $100 per loaf, there won't be as much bread available as there are people looking to buy it.
- stale2002 11y agoYes there will. Then price will just increase to 200$ a loaf. And if there are still too many people looking to buy, then 1000$ a loaf.
- LordKano 11y agoAnd at $10,000 per loaf, the overhead to bake them would be too great and there would still be a shortage.
- Nutmog 11y agoThat definition doesn't work. If bread was 1 cent per loaf, I bet more people would buy it. So all those people who currently aren't buying bread because it costs a couple of dollars are people who want bread but there isn't enough available. Does that mean we always have a bread shortage? Maybe we do. But then it becomes a useless definition. If it cost $100 per loaf, there would again be people who want it but can't buy it, just as the situation already is but more of them.
- zanny 11y agoIf bread was 1 cent per loaf, bread would be near worthless. The people who cannot afford bread are not economically generating enough demand for bread to have more bread created. Markets do not care how much you intrinsically want something - that is not what market demand is - demand is simply a measure of how much money is willing to be spent on a good or service. The more money seeking bread, the more pressure there is on bread makers to make more, because each loaf is more valuable. If there is no money seeking bread - ie, the poor - then nobody has a reason to make bread, because there is no profit to be made. Capitalism is literally defined by the perpetual shortage of scarce physical resources. Bread costs what it does because people want it - that means they do not already have it - and are willing to pay so much for it. And the highest bidders get their bread, with the price being set at approximately the lowest bidder who would still get a finite loaf of bread if they were dolled out in sequence of most demand to least, while anyone below that "bid" amount does not get bread. If bread were market valued at $100 a loaf, it would mean either more people are willing to pay more for the same bread - say, someone wants to buy all the bread and offers way above market price to capture the bread supply - or the supply itself has diminished enough that the lowest bidders at $1 and $10 and $99 were too far back in line to get bread behind all those willing to pay $100 or more. If something is worth value in market exchange, it means someone wants something they do not have, and are willing to pay an amount of money for it. Demand is dictated by the total amount of money seeking something, and supply is determined by how much of something can fill that demand. And demand can include those seeking loaves of bread for a cent - but it is very unlikely their demand will ever be met, because they offer so little in return.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoBut, see, in a supply-and-demand market, the price is always too high for somebody, and always not too high for somebody else. So "I believe the price is too high" is a completely meaningless metric. And, in fact, the same thing applies in reverse from the sell side. They never complain that the price is too high, but some of them think the price is too low - and others don't. I'd expect that everyone who thinks there's a shortage of engineers is on the employer side. And most of those on the employee side think that there quite clearly is not a shortage. The actual definition of a shortage is "a deficiency in quantity" (per dictionary.com). Well, that's not very helpful. Deficiency compared to what? Or, deficient by what measure? You can have a shortage personally, compared to what you desire; but for a market as a whole to have a shortage, you have to have something to compare it to. That usually is the state of the market at a time when [it is generally agreed that] there wasn't a shortage. So if you say, "STEM salaries are twice as high as they were in 1990, even after adjusting for inflation", then you might be able to make a case that there is a shortage. If you say, "we can't find people at the price we're willing to pay, but that price is less than the market rate in 1990", well, my heart fails to bleed for you.
- aswanson 11y agoThe reason why enrollment is so high is because of the shortage Or because they hear politicians on TV without the slightest clue telling people there is a shortage. Or because they enjoy building things. Not so black and white, is it?
- gozur88 11y agoThe other possibility is fields which would have attracted bright people are no longer looking as green. Like, for example, law.
- LordKano 11y agoLaw and Medicine used to be the the fields that attracted the best and brightest. Now, we have an overabundance of lawyers and the margins are very thin on medicine. It's just a matter of time until IT is in a similar position and something else becomes the hot new field.
- bsder 11y ago> Also, the common argument of "There is no shortage for X, people just want to pay less money, than the current, extremely high price of X", is completely nonsensical. Your definition of shortage is nonsensical, and it's easy to prove it: From MY point of view, there is a shortage of supermodels willing to have sex with me. Everybody would laugh at that being a "shortage". The same applies in that there is a shortage of engineers willing to work for me for free. Everybody would also laugh at that shortage.
- bsder 11y ago> He gets cause and effect wrong. The reason why enrollments are so high is BECAUSE of the shortage. As do you have the cause wrong. The reason why enrollments in STEM are high is because it is one of the last remaining degrees which actually pays back the money spent to get it. Until they start feeding a quarter million H1-B's into the system a year.