4 ms·
Part of the problem is this whole thing of use "STEM" as though it identifies a cohesive / unified group of employment positions. It's too much of a catch-all
by mindcrime 11y ago
Part of the problem is this whole thing of use "STEM" as though it identifies a cohesive / unified group of employment positions. It's too much of a catch-all and there's room for TONS of variance within the overall "STEM" rubric. For example, you could have raging demand for software engineers at the same time you're having massive layoffs among, say, chemical engineers. So what can you say about "STEM" as a whole in that case? Very little.
IOW, precision matters and we should be leery of over-generalizing.
- JoeAltmaier 11y ago...except, chemical engineers never get laid off. Those folks rock, and are always in high demand.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoDidn't DuPont just axe a whole bunch of them.
- gozur88 11y agoI'll bet a whole lot of chemical engineers got laid off in the last year with the oil glut.
- mindcrime 11y agoIt was mostly just a made up example. That said, I've actually known a few people with degrees in chemical engineering who were complaining about the lack of jobs in their field recently. Maybe that's why that particular example came to mind. But still, substitute "mechanical engineering" or "civil engineering" or FSM-only-knows what and the overall point remains the same. "Engineers" or "STEM" people aren't all filling the same positions and the people aren't really fungible (at least in the short term, retraining to change fields takes time).
- gojomo 11y agoPerhaps that's true in your experience, but 'STEM' also includes jobs as varied as 'actuary', 'geographer', 'dental hygienist', 'soil technician', 'physical therapist', and 'anthropologist'.
- dalke 11y agoI'll add 'string theorist', 'paleobotanist', 'exoplanetologist', 'dendrochronologist', and 'parapsychologist'. When politicians (or most people, for that matter) talk about needing more people in STEM, they don't usually mean to increase funding for these fields. Rather, "STEM" is short-hand for "the sorts of people who solve problems that are useful for industry, business, and health."
- HillaryBriss 11y agoYeah. There seems to be a paradox embedded in the national conversation about STEM and the job market. On one hand, various thought-leaders insist that people in the US should get training in STEM fields. Education is the answer, your answer, to employability. It doesn't matter who you are; you can get STEM training and become competitive in the job market. On the other hand, some of these same thought-leaders insist that the US absolutely must import lots more people from foreign countries. There's no way to train existing people in the US to do the necessary work. It doesn't matter who you are; you can't do it. Step aside. We're replacing you. A lot of times the people making these arguments are lawyers.